In the wake of recent debate about the purpose of superannuation, I spoke with former ACTU secretary Bill Kelty about why the system was created, whether it has achieved its aims, and why he believes super is being asked to solve problems it was never designed to address.
Kelty is often described as one of the two 'fathers' of Australia's super system, a title he is quick to rebuff. Some of his views may surprise readers.
Q. Who was the father of super?
There isn’t one. The truth is, without Paul Keating there would be no legislated super.
But without union agreement, there would have been no industrial buy-in.
I would never claim to be the father – so many others went ahead; Tom McDonald, Simon Crean, Jim Maher, Pat Clancy, Gary Weaven and Charlie Fitzgibbon to name a few.
If you personalise these things, it oversimplifies the achievement.
Industrial super goes way back, starting with the coal miners (and Communist Party) in 1948. Then the seamen in the 1950s, Charlie Fitzgibbon and the Waterfront Federation also achieved it, as did Wally Curran and the Meatworkers (union) and Chris Northover and the Storemen and Packers (union).
Everyone has a different view of the purpose…
Q. What was the original purpose of super?
The purpose of super was to deliver a retirement benefit. Not to deal with women and equal pay or the fact that the aged care system is no good.
It can’t solve everyone’s problems, including investment capacity for housing.
It can provide capital. But if a government wants to make housing affordable, then that government has a social role to play.
When it comes to affordable housing, a government could be a developer at market rates.
It shouldn’t be a hard problem to solve if the government creates an instrument rather than simply subsidising it. Look at the Singapore model, which actually made money.
Just don’t try to use super as a band-aid.
Q. Governments have struggled to articulate an agreed intention for super over recent years. What was the overarching intention of super in 1992?
It was self-evident. Super, released from age 55 or 60, would facilitate early retirement. It would supplement Age Pension entitlements, then fewer retirees would depend upon a pension. With a relatively small proportion on the Age Pension, there could be an increase in the pension in real terms.
Put simply, it was always about retirement.
It was not a gift from employers or government. The employer was the means of organising super.
We gave workers a sense of ownership from the start. We asked them to give up their wage increase, to defer wages and put this money into the super compact. The biggest contribution was employees’ wages – not government funding. It is still workers’ money.
And if you get the economy to work, as part of the productivity increase there will be higher super from higher wages.
Contributions and low member engagement are hotly debated
Q. The current 12% super guarantee has been criticised as too high. Do you agree?
Initially 9% was adequate for retirement from age 55 to 75. It gave the flexibility of early retirement. After 75-80 or 80-85 there would be pressures on individuals to continue to fund a good retirement. Moving the percentage from 9-12% and above would provide the best retirement for the over 80s.
But older people voted in increasing numbers for the Liberal Party. It’s ironic, as these were the people for whom the change (from 9-12 -15%) was designed. And Australia now has a problem with aged care.
Q. Do you have a view on the level of engagement of members of super funds?
The rate of engagement is not a measure of success. Support for super has grown and returns are better – in fact, it is outperforming the original ambition.
General disengagement is not surprising. The more trust there is in a system, the less engagement you tend to see. As a member you receive a return of 8-9% per annum. The system is doing what the policymakers said it would.
Most people trust super and get advice in super until they retire.
If you’re 23 and have a small amount in super, why would you worry about it? Leave it there, it grows and then it gets to the point when the saver is very interested. The rate of concern grows with the amount invested and when the saver can access it. The best decision you can make in your earlier years is to buy a home.
Should super be freed up for first homebuyers?
Q. Which leads us to whether super should be withdrawn early to buy a house?
Super is workers’ money negotiated as part of a system and tax-preferenced… Remember, when super was introduced in 1993, people could still buy a house.
How can using super be a solution to a different problem – namely low housing stock and declining wages?
Super access settings are generally correct. It is the people’s money and I’m not sure that the electorate likes the idea of taking all that money out.
Q. Does super have a role to play in increasing productivity?
Super is an investment for retirement.
The AFL plays football, not cricket.
Funds are singularly directed to look after people's retirements so how they collect and then invest the contributions is up to their trustees.
Is super a policy failure?
Q. Senator Andrew Bragg has described super as: "One of the biggest public policy failures since federation. - It hasn't helped the budget, and it has not really helped many people get off the pension". How would you respond?
I would start from the facts. The Australian Age Pension is 2.7% of GDP – France is 9 or 10%. In the US, longevity is starting to go backwards. It’s hard for Bragg to make that argument.
Super income is substantial – in real terms there are fewer people on the Age Pension – the pressure on the budget is coming from the NDIS and defence. Super actually frees up capacity for the NDIS. The truth is that super has significantly reduced pressure on the budget for the Age Pension. If the Age Pension was at 5-6% of GDP we would have no capacity for other social services.
It’s time to make life simpler
Q. Do you agree that the decumulation phase of super needs fixing? If so, what could be improved?
The decumulation phase is not perfect. People trust the super system for accumulation. Most working people work their way through the system and live in retirement in accordance with both rules and expectation. They have savings of $300-400,000, then receive a pension and are able to take an overseas trip or help the kids.
But yes, there is complexity.
It could be simpler. It could be simplified by letting your super account show your combined position, linking systems to show savings, and then, from age 60, how you’re tracking for a mix of super and Age Pension. Show people their options, such as option A, transfer to an account-based pension income stream, pay no tax, maybe take 10% of savings in a lump sum, with an Age Pension buffer of, say, $380 per week.
These sums are relatively simple, and most people manage them well.
As far as retirement income decision making goes, if you make life simple – for instance give people say four options – then most would prefer to tick a box and most are likely to choose a balanced fund.
Yes, some people get caught out, as in the case of Shield and First Guardian Master Funds. If someone offers really high rates of return and you knowingly take the risk, the results won’t be good. But most working people are pretty smart.
Q. In regard to super, what do you believe to be your legacy?
It’s not a single thing.
We were a unique group of Australian trade unionists and political leaders who helped build the biggest safety nets – wages, super and Medicare. Keating and Hawke helped focus the country on economic growth. If not me, then someone else would have supported them.
After the interview, I put one of Professor Ron Bird's central criticisms of the superannuation system to Kelty and asked whether he wished to respond. Bird wrote that:
"...the system has never been built on rigorous economic analysis. The original 3% contribution was introduced as a wages workaround during high inflation, not as part of a coherent retirement income model."
Kelty’s response:
The biggest test of all is life. We have proven the economic analysis in intensive Senate inquiries and been judged over a 30–40-year period. The ultimate test is not an economic policy in a university – it’s the real test in the economic model called life. Ask whether super has:
- reduced the cost of capital,
- rectified balance of payment constraints,
- delivered a more flexible capacity to retire, and
- facilitated big lump sums at retirement?
The answer is ‘Yes’, just as we intended it. The only variation is a positive - that the returns have been in excess of what we originally thought.
Kaye Fallick is an independent retirement commentator and author, www.kayefallick.com. This article is general information and does not consider the circumstances of any person.