Fifteen years ago, I attended a conference for financial advisers. The highlight of the day was a debate on the merits of the ‘Bucket Strategy’, with three advisers per debating team.
I can’t recall all the points made but what I vividly remember is the passion shown by all participants. An unofficial debate then spilled over into the evening function that night. Yes, those financial adviser events are wild!
Since then, I’ve maintained an interest in the topic, reading research and commentary on bucket strategies and, whenever I get the chance, asking financial advisers for their take. There are plenty of different takes.
What is the bucket strategy trying to achieve?
At its heart, the bucket strategy is an attempt to manage sequencing risk.
Sequencing risk is the risk that poor investment returns occur early in retirement, when you are also drawing down your savings. Withdrawals after market falls can require more assets/units to be sold at depressed prices, leaving less capital invested to participate in a subsequent recovery. The effect can be severe. Sequencing risk can contribute to another problem: longevity risk, the risk of outliving your savings.
Additionally, it can aid in mental accounting, that is having separate buckets of money for separate goals. So, the attraction of the bucket strategy is easy to understand.
So, what is the ‘bucket strategy’?
We have now encountered our first problem.
There isn’t really one bucket strategy. The term is often used as if everyone is talking about the same thing, but in my conversations with advisers and super funds, I have come across many variations.
The bucket strategy tries to prevent the sale of growth assets, such as shares, when markets are down by drawing initially from a cash or defensive bucket and giving growth assets time to recover.
In an account-based pension, a bucket strategy will generally involve dividing the account into two or more pools of investments. There might be a cash bucket containing money for upcoming pension payments, with another bucket, or several buckets, invested for longer-term growth.
Now to some potential differences. Does the cash bucket form part of your targeted asset allocation? Suppose you have agreed on a strategic asset allocation of 60% growth assets and 40% defensive assets. Where does the cash bucket fit?
Most approaches treat the cash bucket as something separate from that 60/40 allocation. If so, the overall portfolio may end up more defensive than the stated asset allocation suggests, creating a cash drag and reducing returns when markets perform strongly.
Alternatively, the cash bucket can be included within the target asset allocation, with the other investment buckets adjusted down accordingly.
But this raises another issue. As pension payments are progressively drawn from cash, the remaining portfolio can become increasingly more aggressive unless it is regularly rebalanced. We need to know how that cash bucket is being treated.
How many buckets are there? Two, three, four or five? Often, it depends on your investment goals and timeframes, with each potentially having its own identifiable bucket.
How much is in the cash bucket initially? Some target one to four years of pension payments. Others target a percentage of your account balance.
When and how to rebalance? Almost everyone agrees a bucket strategy needs to be rebalanced regularly. But how often?
Is it just when you come in to see your adviser for a review? Is it when your cash bucket gets below a certain dollar or percentage value? Is it based on upcoming pension payments?
By how much should it be topped up and from where? Who decides when it should be rebalanced, and is there any attempt at ‘market timing’?
I note that any sell down of growth assets involves an element of market timing, whether it's conscious or not, and whether it's automated or done manually. This may or may not happen at a favourable price.
Two funds, two very different buckets
Interestingly, two smaller super funds both had their own version of a default bucket strategy within their account-based pensions.
One had a cash bucket and a balanced investment option. When the cash balance fell below a predetermined level, some of the balanced investment option was automatically sold to replenish the cash bucket.
The other fund, whilst calling itself a bucket strategy, I thought of as more of a reverse bucket. It had three buckets of pre-determined percentages. Pension payments were initially drawn from the most aggressive bucket. Once that bucket was exhausted, payments were drawn from the next most aggressive bucket, leaving the most conservative investments until last. No rebalancing.
The idea was that, over time, the member would progressively be left with a more conservative portfolio as they aged. It was described as a bucket strategy, but it operated quite differently from what many people would ordinarily think of when talking about buckets. Both super funds are no longer in existence, being taken over by larger funds.
Does a bucket strategy work?
It depends on what you mean by “work”.
The bucket strategy is not an asset-allocation free lunch. Dividing investments into separate buckets doesn't, by itself, create additional investment returns or make sequencing risk disappear.
When comparing a bucket approach with a more traditional retirement portfolio, what matters is the underlying asset allocation, withdrawal rules and rebalancing methodology, rather than simply the labels attached to different pools of money.
There is an interesting parallel with Dollar Cost Averaging.
Many investors believe in ‘Dollar Cost Averaging’ (DCA) to minimise risk when accumulating money. That is, they invest a regular amount at regular intervals. Say, $1,000 at the start of each month, regardless of whether markets are up or down.
Similar principles apply when withdrawing money, but investors tend to abandon DCA in retirement. Admittedly, the advantages and disadvantages are simply reversed. When markets fall you buy more units when accumulating but must sell more units when de-accumulating. However, the reverse is also true in growth markets.
The strongest benefit may be psychological. Humans tend to compartmentalise money. We like knowing that certain money is there for specific purposes. Having a cash bucket is comforting.
A retiree might find considerable reassurance in knowing that their next period of pension payments is sitting safely in cash, regardless of what share markets are doing today. In other words, its advantage is more behavioural than mathematical.
If structuring a retirement portfolio via buckets reduces the retiree fear factor, supports someone to stay invested through difficult markets and helps them sleep better at night, then a bucket strategy may have genuine value.
So, do you want a bucket with that?
Maybe.
Just make sure you know what sort of bucket you're getting, what's inside it, and how it actually works.
Craig Sankey is a Member Education Specialist at UniSuper and financial services writer and presenter. UniSuper is a sponsor of Firstlinks.
This is an opinion piece and the personal opinions expressed are not intended to act as financial or other advice. The information is of a general nature and doesn’t consider your personal circumstances. Before making decisions, you should consider whether the information is appropriate for your circumstances otherwise seek financial advice.