Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 686

Making the case for a 'good enough' portfolio

I was sitting in the lobby of the Hyatt Regency in San Antonio last October; my flight wasn’t until later, and I was basking in the glow of a successful Bogleheads conference. (Bogleheads are investors who believe in minimalist index-based investing as espoused by Vanguard founder Jack Bogle.)

Conference attendees were streaming out of the hotel to catch their flights, and I was in a prime spot to gather feedback. We send out a survey that we use to improve the conference and build out the lineup of future speakers and topics, but there’s nothing like unvarnished human input.

In my moments of downtime between conversations, I tried to make sense of the comments that were coming my way. But here’s what was making me crazy: Attendees kept giving completely contradictory feedback. The same sessions and speakers that some people loved bugged others. I found myself thinking: “What are we supposed to do with this?”

Are you an optimiser or a satisficer?

But as I pondered all those comments on my flight home, I realised they were contradictory because our conference is trying to serve two completely different audiences.

The first group is what has historically been the Bogleheads’ bread and butter: the portfolio maximisers, or optimisers. These conference attendees were telling me they wanted more sessions about building a laddered portfolio of Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS), broadly equivalent to Treasury Indexed Bonds in Australia, setting allocations to categories like small-cap value and real estate. More deep dives. They love steeping themselves in the research about how best to create a financial plan and manage a portfolio, and they enjoy debating the finer points on the Bogleheads forum. 

The second group doesn’t want to spend a lot of time on those smaller-bore issues. They’re more of what psychologists call satisficers, a term coined by economist Herbert Simon to be a hybrid of ‘satisfy’ and ‘suffice’. When making choices, satisficers are looking for an acceptable option rather than the best possible one.

The satisficers that I heard from at the conference told me they were more interested in big-picture topics: finding ‘enough’ (Brian Portnoy’s talk about “funded contentment” was a big hit), retirement lifestyle considerations, and leaving a legacy for their kids, for example. They’ve set their asset allocation, populated their portfolios with low-cost index funds, and moved on to other things. 

I’ve been thinking that we don’t spend enough time urging people to place themselves on the maximiser/satisficer continuum. At our Bogleheads conference, we ask attendees to select streams based on life stage and knowledge level. But a more important question might be: “Are you looking for perfect or will ‘good enough’ do?” Prompting people to answer that question and perhaps giving them a little data-supported nudge to go in the satisficer direction has the potential to save people a lot of time and money.

My journey to satisfice-ment

As you’ve probably guessed if you read my columns or any of my books, I’m on ‘Team Satisficer’, at least with respect to money matters. (If I’m picking a restaurant or plants at the garden store, now that’s another story.) My bias is toward simple, low-maintenance solutions.

But it took me a while to get there. When I was a fund analyst, I spent a lot of time thinking and writing about the ‘best’ large-cap growth or REIT funds, or the best interval for rebalancing. And the fact is, maximisers are often incredibly smart people who ground their conclusions in data and genuinely love this stuff; they may even get paid to develop portfolios and plans for their clients.

In many aspects of investing and financial planning, these maximisers rule the debate. Listening to them, you think that you probably should use budgeting software, build that TIPS ladder for retirement income, and fine-tune every aspect of your retirement plan.

The catch is that maximising can take time, and not everyone is cut out for it. If I had realised that I wasn’t really a maximiser earlier, for example, I wouldn’t have wasted any time trying to track our household’s spending to the penny in an effort to figure out our budget. I would have moved straight to the method we use today, reverse budgeting, which simply means that you set up automatic savings contributions, and any money left over is yours to spend. Do I know exactly how we’re spending our money? No. Does it matter? Also no.

The same goes for portfolio allocation and investment selection. Inertia is a common theme running through my major investment and portfolio mistakes: I’ve been slow to tackle jobs and problem areas. If only I had decided to ‘settle’ for indexing earlier, my portfolio would have performed better, and it would have also required less oversight. (The funny thing about indexing is that it’s a strategy that both satisficers and maximisers can agree on. The data supports the effectiveness of indexing, pleasing maximisers, and satisficers see indexing as an acceptable option that’s also hands-off.)

In any case, having a reasonable savings rate and asset allocation has more than made up for any portfolio problem spots. Satisficers know that if you get the big things right, they more than offset any smaller issues.

And while I know many happy maximisers, the data support that we satisficers are generally happier overall. The reason is that satisficers make what they think are reasonably well-informed choices and then move on, whereas maximisers are more likely to second-guess their decisions. Maximisers are also more likely than satisficers to engage in social comparisons.

Finally, author Mike Piper pointed out at the Bogleheads conference that it’s impossible to truly maximise without a crystal ball. The ‘right’ answer to a lot of financial questions, including the best asset allocation, the highest safe withdrawal rate, or how to pay the least taxes over your lifetime, will only be apparent in hindsight. In the meantime, it’s all a bit of a guess.

So, here’s my advice: Before you go down the maximiser rabbit hole, take a step back and ask yourself: Am I cut out for this? Do I enjoy spending time this way? Or will ‘good enough’ decisions achieve a similar result with much less time and hassle? With respect to money and investing, my hunch is that Team Satisficer has growth potential.

 

Christine Benz is director of personal finance and retirement planning for Morningstar. She is also the author of How to Retire: 20 Lessons for a Happy, Successful, and Wealthy Retirement. This article does not consider the circumstances of any investor. Minor changes have been made to the original US version for an Australian audience.

 

  •   28 October 2026
  • 8
  •      
  •   
8 Comments
Nadal
October 29, 2026

Good article, and agree with your comment David.

On reflection, I think I lie in the middle of the spectrum Christine refers to. I very much enjoy reading material from professional fund managers eg. Howard Marks, but their overt focus on outperformance / alpha (because it is their livelihood on the line with FUM flows) is not directly relevant to me as a personal investor. I often have to pull myself up when I think I want to replicate their approach - and remind myself that as a personal investor I am concerned about absolute returns, not relative returns. If I make 15% and my neighbour makes 17%, I should still be happy (for both of us), and not resentful.

Kieran
October 29, 2026

Yep I used to be an optimiser too. Took up a lot of time and didn’t make me any happier or better at picking stocks/ investments.
Switching around my super in fact made me worse off overall.
When I discovered Bogle and his cohort I moved to index set and forget.
Better off financially and more time to spend on the things I enjoy. No brainer.
Still read Firstlinks for the interesting articles and the thoughtful comments - not really looking for investment advice though - I’m now 100% satisficer.

4
Irene
November 01, 2026

After Covid, investment is harder than before. Like not long ago, Cochlear can dropped 49% in one day, that’s something I never see a blue-chip stock happened in my 25 years investment life. I am now 73, to spend more time with family is important than to have gain more in my portfolio.

John
October 29, 2026

The primary reasons at 72 that I continue to invest in individual Australian and US company stocks rather than ETFs, REITs, bonds, collectibles etc are dividend imputation, low safe bond yields, aversion to CGT events and to keep my brain busy.

3
Abel
October 29, 2026

Excellent article. I too started as an optimiser and have migrated to a position much closer to a satisficer regarding portfolio selection. Like Christine, I still want to optimise other things. But be aware: Your ability to make complex decisions is a limited resource. Make sure you spend it on those aspects most important to you and where it adds the most value.

2
Stella
October 29, 2026

Ah, Christine, knowing how you spend your money will matter to you later, when you're about to retire. It's an important decision-making tool to answer the "Do I have enough?" and the "How long will it last me?" questions.
Happy retiree.

2
Jeff O
October 29, 2026

Agree - excellent investment advice - especially when considering the evidence of active investment portfolio mgt and the actual delivery of outperformance over the medium to long term is most unlikely .....liability/sustainable income goals matter ....and a lifestyle plan and its actual implementation matters a lot more for your wellbeing.....and even investment satisficing requires stress testing for (income/liquidity) resilience that underpins your choices & freedom...investment satisficing and getting on with a happy life is a great investment strategy

1
 

Leave a Comment:

RELATED ARTICLES

The key question to inspire a confident and purposeful retirement

The retirement account that Australia should have

The mortgage free retirement is fading

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Division 296: the initial moves to make before the windows close

What if the best superannuation strategy isn't about earning more, but acting before your options disappear? Several overlooked planning windows are narrowing, with consequences that can last for decades.

The retirement scorecard: how many of these questions can you answer?

From the maths of retirement, estimating spending and picking the right asset allocation to survive a poor decade, here are the questions every retiree – current or future – should be able to answer for themselves.

Testamentary trusts: Treasury has picked the wrong reading

A decades-old estate planning tool has survived one tax crackdown only to be caught by another. The surprise isn't who the reform is targeting, but who could end up paying the price for drafting choices made years ago.

Superannuation’s structural failings

Politicians are fighting over access to super, but they may be arguing about the wrong thing. The system’s three fundamental flaws have been hiding in plain sight for decades, costing Australians far more than they realise.

Avoid unnecessary CGT with this estate planning clause

A simple estate plan can create a ticking time bomb. One overlooked clause can pit spouses against children, delay inheritances, and potentially leave a family facing an unexpected tax bill worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Higher yields are creating opportunities in global bonds

Bond markets are adjusting to a new reality, but not in the ways investors expect. With markets repricing and capital competing for attention, investors may need to rethink where resilience and opportunity lie. 

Latest Updates

Retirement

The retirement account that Australia should have

Our retirement system asks one account to do two very different jobs. A dedicated "rainy day" account separating income from emergency savings could deliver better outcomes and greater peace of mind for retirees.

Investing

What the US midterm results mean for investors

Democrats have regained control of Congress, changing the equation in Washington. Whether that proves positive for investors will depend less on the result itself and more on what happens next for growth and markets.

Taxation

Should the capital gains tax reward risk?

A reader query on the recent CGT reforms has revealed a bigger issue. One overlooked feature of the old system may have done more than compensate for inflation. As we move to indexation, are we forgetting to reward risk?

Investment strategies

Bonds: The income and diversification trade-off

Rising yields have made bonds attractive again, but that does not mean they will behave as expected. As inflation, fiscal pressures and geopolitical risks reshape markets, the role of bonds may be more complicated than it appears.

Investment strategies

Why high-dividend investing deserves another look

Income investors have endured several lean years, but signs of a recovery are emerging. As opportunities improve, investors face an important choice between chasing headline yields and building a reliable source of income.

Investment strategies

Why 'overvalued' has been such an expensive word

Investors love simple rules, especially when markets appear stretched. Yet some of the strongest returns have arrived when the outlook seemed least attractive. This leaves an important question that history struggles to answer.

Investment strategies

AI – A good kind of bubble or just a bubble?

Investor obsession with AI is attracting unprecedented amounts of capital and confidence. But beneath the excitement lies uncertainties about returns, funding and risks that enthusiasts may not be paying enough attention to.

Sponsors

Alliances

  • ASA-Logo-RGB-ActiveGreen-web.png

© 2026 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.