Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Commodity prices rescue 2019 Budget

It is budget time again in Australia, and the nation is heading for its first Federal Government surplus since 2008, mostly from good luck with China and commodities.

Here is a chart showing the Federal Government’s deficit and debt position since 1901. The upper section shows revenues (green line) and expenses (red). The middle section shows the resultant annual surpluses (green bars – look hard!) or deficits (red bars). The purple bars in the lower section show the level of Federal Government debt. All are expressed relative to total national output (GDP) each year.

Click to enlarge

A brief history of budgets

The Federal Government ran balanced budgets in the early years following Federation but it had very few functions prior to the introduction of Federal Government pensions in 1909. World Wars I & II changed all that, requiring massive war-time deficits and debt build-ups. These were finally brought under control by the 1950s and 1960s booms. The Government still ran small deficits (1-2% of GDP) but rising tax revenues from the booming economy were enough to pay for expanding services and nation-building projects, and still reduce the debt/GDP ratio down to low levels by the 1970s. The current level of debt relative to national output is the highest it has been since the late 1950s.

Producing a government surplus can be done in one of two ways: by cutting costs or increasing tax revenues, or sometimes both. Most of the time the surpluses have been a result of windfall revenue gains, mostly from fortuitous mining booms. The problem is that costs are controllable, but tax revenues depend on mining booms that are based on global commodities price cycles outside our control.

Only rarely have surpluses been achieved by cutting costs. This was the case with the 1930s surpluses. Australia did not follow Roosevelt’s big spending approach in the US. Instead we had to endure harsh ‘austerity’ cost-cutting imposed by London bankers. The government wasn’t able to borrow anyway after it defaulted on its debts in 1931. Arguably the austerity cuts prolonged the depression and stunted the recovery.

The only other period of surpluses produced by cost cutting was the four-year period from 1988 to 1991 by Hawke and Keating. Commodities prices and tax revenues were falling but they were able to produce surpluses by cutting costs by even more, resulting in the deep 1990-91 recession.

The Howard Government had two spells of surpluses – four years from 1998 to 2001, and then another five years from 2003 to 2007 (or six years if you count the 2007-08 year during which Rudd came to office, when boom-time mining revenues were still flowing in prior to the GFC). Both of these surplus spells were driven by windfall tax revenue gains – first from the 1990s ‘dot-com’ boom and the second from the 2003-08 mining boom. Government spending was also reducing during the whole period – from 25% of GDP in 1996 to 21.7% in 2007. But because most of the gains were from boom-time tax revenue rises, the windfall surpluses quickly disappeared when the booms ended.

If the Federal Government achieves a surplus in the current 2018-19 year it will be mainly thanks once again to fortuitous tax revenue gains from the mining boom, not because of cost management. In the past five years the population has grown by just 8%, but government spending has risen by an incredible 21%. By sheer luck the mining boom has increased revenues by 27% but windfall gains like these are not sustainable.


Ashley Owen is Chief Investment Officer at advisory firm Stanford Brown and The Lunar Group. He is also a Director of Third Link Investment Managers, a fund that supports Australian charities. This article is for general information purposes only and does not consider the circumstances of any individual.


April 05, 2019

the Libs are heading toward a real budget surplus, despite all their own goals that make them partially unelectable.
However the Labor budget reply points to more deficits if they are elected. They never raise the revenue anticipated but continue to spend anyway.
Labor only gets into government every decade or so and then want to spend up big to fund all their own priorities.

Don Macca
April 04, 2019

Ashley's chart allows us to stand back, forget the trees & look at the whole forest. The impression i get is that Australia's fortune still mostly relies on being a quarry for the world. In particular Iron ore for China.

We need to expand our economy into other areas. We have outstanding companies in medicine, medical research, software .
Can we be reluctant about spending most of largesse on ourselves; instead we should build a future for our children.

Most of us (myself included) have been beating our own drum. We can pick holes in promises made by both Labor & the Coalition. Each one matching the other & then adding a little more. Let's stop beating our own drum.
We need to carefully consider our "Vote".

Warren Bird
April 06, 2019

Don, how do you get that from the chart? Ashley asserts it in his commentary, but the chart shows only government financing information and nothing about commodity prices, exports or anything that would support the contention that we are merely 'the quarry for the world'.

Donald Horne has so much to answer for!

Warren Bird
April 03, 2019

I wouldn't put it quite that way, for a couple of reasons:

1) "rescue" is usually a term I'd use when something unusual takes place, unexpected or last minute. But as the chart shows, Australia has had a cycle that is connected to commodity prices since, well since Arthur Philip arrived. What we're seeing is a typical economic and fiscal cycle at play. And the fact that we've had a strong run in commodity prices is hardly a surprise.

2) the economy and the budget are far from being one pony shows. For example, as Luci Ellis from the RBA pointed out recently, personal income taxes have increased at a faster rate than usual, from a range of factors including increased compliance efforts by the ATO that has effectively increased the average rate of tax collected. Note that the RBA in its monetary policy statement recently mentioned slow "disposable income" growth as a factor, hinting that tax cuts would give a helpful leg up to consumer spending capacity. This increase in budget revenue has nothing to do with commodity prices.

As an aside, I think that the significant improvement in our fiscal position, from whatever source, puts to the sword the argument used by many in the franking credits debate that 'we can't afford to give those refunds'. I've argued before that I think that's wrong and now we have a budget bottom line to support what I've been saying. So let's just focus in the franking credit discussion on the validity of the policy.

Our fiscal position is nowhere near as dire as many folk would make it out to be.


Leave a Comment:



BHP v Rio v Fortescue: it's all about the iron ore price

Commodities prices and the Australian stock market


Most viewed in recent weeks

Unexpected results in our retirement income survey

Who knew? With some surprise results, the Government is on unexpected firm ground in asking people to draw on all their assets in retirement, although the comments show what feisty and informed readers we have.

10 reasons wealthy homeowners shouldn't receive welfare

The RBA Governor says rising house prices are due to "the design of our taxation and social security systems". The OECD says "the prolonged boom in house prices has inflated the wealth of many pensioners without impacting their pension eligibility." What's your view?

Three all-time best tables for every adviser and investor

It's a remarkable statistic. In any year since 1875, if you had invested in the Australian stock index, turned away and come back eight years later, your average return would be 120% with no negative periods.

The looming excess of housing and why prices will fall

Never stand between Australian households and an uncapped government programme with $3 billion in ‘free money’ to build or renovate their homes. But excess supply is coming with an absence of net migration.

Five stocks that have worked well in our portfolios

Picking macro trends is difficult. What may seem logical and compelling one minute may completely change a few months later. There are better rewards from focussing on identifying the best companies at good prices.

Six COVID opportunist stocks prospering in adversity

Some high-quality companies have emerged even stronger since the onset of COVID and are well placed for outperformance. We call these the ‘COVID Opportunists’ as they are now dominating their specific sectors.

Latest Updates


10 reasons wealthy homeowners shouldn't receive welfare

The RBA Governor says rising house prices are due to "the design of our taxation and social security systems". The OECD says "the prolonged boom in house prices has inflated the wealth of many pensioners without impacting their pension eligibility." What's your view?


Sean Fenton on marching to your own investment tune

Is it more difficult to find stocks to short in a rising market? What impact has central bank dominance had over stock selection? How do you combine income and growth in a portfolio? Where are the opportunities?


D’oh! DDO rules turn some funds into a punching bag

The Design and Distribution Obligations (DDO) come into effect in two weeks. They will change the way banks promote products, force some small funds to close to new members and push issues into the listed space.


Dividends, disruption and star performers in FY21 wrap

Company results in FY21 were generally good with some standout results from those thriving in tough conditions. We highlight the companies that delivered some of the best results and our future  expectations.

Fixed interest

Coles no longer happy with the status quo

It used to be Down, Down for prices but the new status quo is Down Down for emissions. Until now, the realm of ESG has been mainly fund managers as 'responsible investors', but companies are now pushing credentials.

Investment strategies

Seven factors driving growth in Managed Accounts

As Managed Accounts surge through $100 billion for the first time, the line between retail, wholesale and institutional capabilities and portfolios continues to blur. Lower costs help with best interest duties.


Reader Survey: home values in age pension asset test

Read our article on the family home in the age pension test, with the RBA Governor putting the onus on social security to address house prices and the OECD calling out wealthy pensioners. What is your view?



© 2021 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. Any general advice or ‘regulated financial advice’ under New Zealand law has been prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide (AU) and Financial Advice Provider Disclosure Statement (NZ). You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.

Website Development by Master Publisher.