Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 331

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 331

  •   6 November 2019
  • 3

Sludge. Well done ASIC for calling out the meaningless warnings, disclosures and disclaimers in financial presentations and offer documents. ASIC even says they are often harmful to client outcomes. Consider the dreaded disclaimers at the start of every talk. They interrupt well-crafted and strong introductions, and they are usually the butt of jokes by presenters, along the lines of "You've all read that, right? Good, now I'll get on with what really matters."

Nobody reads them. Hundreds of words appear on the screen for a few seconds. I'm waiting for the day when someone shouts out, "I'd like to read that, please. What are you saying? Perhaps it's like the T&Cs for Facebook where I give away my rights." In Product Disclosure Statements, endless and useless warnings can overwhelm the valuable content.

The ASIC survey found that mandated disclosures and warnings are often ineffective, and may contribute to consumer harm. Deputy Chair, Karen Chester, said:

"It's time to 'call time' on disclosure as the default consumer protection. It's not the 'silver bullet' once thought, nor should it be relied upon as one. Disclosure can and has backfired in unexpected and harmful ways ... the over reliance on disclosure in some ways proved an enabler of poor conduct and poor consumer outcomes revealed by the Financial Services Royal Commission."

Here is a random example taken from a fund manager presentation with the identity removed. It's more about protecting the company than warning the consumer. As ASIC says, in practice, we ignore, overlook or misunderstand warnings.

Our first article follows a similar theme of misunderstanding an audience. At least 75% of Firstlinks' readers are over 55, and it is generally a well-off and engaged group. Rose Herceg reports research on how marketers and brands ignore the over 50s audience (and while few people look forward to ageing, a recent Ipsos study says Australians consider 'old' starts at about 66). The over 50 segment is active and enthusiastic and our readers are finding new ways to plan for their so-called 'retirement' every week. We need another word.

While bond funds have been available in the unlisted space for decades, there is a new range of listed options bringing fixed interest to a broader group of investors. We explain the choices.

Mercer has ranked Australia's retirement system third in the world but at a B grade, and David Knox describes the changes needed to create an A grade system.

I recently met with a financial adviser for the first time in many years, and I can attest to the merit of the input. Daniel Reyes weighs in with four reasons to engage an adviser.

We tend to look to the US as the engine for global growth, but George Toubia shows how the future will be increasingly Asian. Continuing this theme, the White Paper this week is Fidelity's confirmation that the region will shine. It's a perfect reminder in the week when Prime Minister Scott Morrison signed a trade agreement with 15 Asian-Pacific countries.

The market's rejection of WeWork is the highest-profile IPO failure this year, a welcome reminder to investment banks that they need to deliver better quality. The $12 billion total raised on the ASX this year is a quarter of the average for the last five years. Damien Klassen reveals some of the tricks sellers may use to inflate the value of their offers.

Last week's survey on including the home in the pension assets test drew a strong response, and Leisa Bell compiles the results and selects from the vast range of comments received. While the Firstlinks' audience is not a random sample of the Australian electorate, could this be a policy measure with far more support than the Government believes, done the right way?


Graham Hand, Managing Editor

For a PDF version of this week’s newsletter articles, click here.




November 10, 2019

A comment on ASIC's new-found enthusiasm about disclosures that confound rather than clarify.
About time, from the agency that till some time ago treated disclosure as the panacea, the whole panacea and nothing but the panacea. This ignored the truism that unless it makes sense to the intended audience all disclosure is in Swahili translated into Sanskrit. No doubt the system is being gamed through incomprehensible and irrelevant drivel loaded onto illiterate and inertia-bound targets of witting ignorance.
Not clear how this will be addressed: would opaque disclosures be treated as non-disclosures and prosecuted by the Hayne-convertee 'Litigate first, Negotiate later' regulators?
As we go about cleaning this mess up, there is another elephant room that we have been impervious to: the pervasive disclaimer of every professional adviser to the world at large 'This may not be suitable to you, seek professional advice'. What do they think we are doing when we engage them: social intercourse?
ASIC, ACCC and the other authorities must require every professional adviser to specify which professional advice they have in mind when they say so, and more critically, explicitly accept liability for their own expertise instead of the usual 'we disclaim...'
Sludge it is - and there is more to be mined before we change into consumer-facing from the current consumer defacing.
Shangri La!

Warren Bird

November 07, 2019

Further to my comment on the "Retire retirement' article, I note Graham's quick summary here.

It's interesting about people thinking that 'old' is 66.

When I was in hospital for a month just before I turned 60 and had some time on my hands to discover new things, I became a fan of Ed Sheeran. One of his great songs, "Thinking Out Loud" includes a line "darling I'll be loving you until we're 70". So it seems that young people like Ed think that 70 = old.

This happens to be just over 10 years less than the average life expectancy in Britain these days. So it would seem that young folk like Ed Sheeran think that you are old about a decade before your expected end.

My thoughts turned to another song, from my younger days, about being old. Ringo Starr once wondered in song, 'will you still need me, will you still feed me, when I'm .... " You all know the number. 64.

Interesting, but back in the 1960's life expectancy (at least in the UK) was 72. Ringo and the Beatles thought you were old when you had just under a decade of life expectancy left. So not much has changed! Young people's perceptions have, at least, kept up with the actuarial statistics!

At the rate life expectancy is increasing, however, I guess it won't be too long before the next Ed Sheeran sings about still being in love when we're 90 or a 100.
Still, as long as the songs are as good as this one, what does it matter! Click on the link, hit play and enjoy one of the great love songs of the 21st century.


November 07, 2019

Thanks Graham. Interesting read again.

I read with interest a quote from Australian Institute of Superannuation Trustees chief executive Eva Scheerlinck on the topic of PDS disclosure for super funds.

"It is the role of regulation and legislation to ensure that members are getting fair value for money, rather than relying on members' ability to compare funds through disclosure."

I just can’t see how the role of regulation and legislation (assuming she means the regulation and legislation around PDS disclosure) is to ensure that members are getting fair value for money. I would have thought this is the role of competition. It is interesting to read the differing views on this.


Leave a Comment:


Most viewed in recent weeks

How much super is enough?

We cannot see into the future, but here are some general guidelines on how much to save in super, and then how much you can spend to enjoy a good retirement. Start as soon as possible.

How to include homes in the age pension assets test

A reader speaks out about the inequity of ignoring own homes in the assets test for the age pension, plus a proposal on how it could work politically. Take our survey on the merit of the policy. 

OK Boomer: fessing up that we’ve had it good

The pre-Boomer generations faced global wars and depressions, but Australians born after 1946 have enjoyed prosperity. Superannuation, education, strong markets and surging property prices locked in gains.  

Four reasons to engage a financial adviser

The value of financial advice is increasingly questioned after the Royal Commission and changes to advice business models, but the case for financial advice for many people remains strong.

Should you buy CBA PERLS XII Capital Notes?

CBA's latest PERLS offer is directly offered to hundreds of thousands of investors who already hold CBA shares or other PERLS securities. How does it compare with the rest of the hybrid market? 

Reader poll on the home in pension assets test

Two-thirds of the responses to our reader poll say the family home should be included in some way in the age pension assets test, but the comments show it is an emotional and divisive subject. 

Latest Updates


OK Boomer: fessing up that we’ve had it good

The pre-Boomer generations faced global wars and depressions, but Australians born after 1946 have enjoyed prosperity. Superannuation, education, strong markets and surging property prices locked in gains.  

Investment strategies

Young women are investing more in shares

Young woment are showing increasing confidence in the sharemarket, promising a better future than the Boomers and Gen X women who hold significantly less assets than males of their generation.  

Investment strategies

Shorting deserves more respect

A fund manager that can short sell stocks with weak investment characteristics while reinvesting the proceeds in long positions in preferred stocks has a high degree of flexibility.


Policymakers fear cutting stimulus can lead to recession

Prolonging a recovery with stimulus could lead to a worse slump later. Even today, policymakers are haunted by actions taken in 1937 which led to a loss of production and jobs and a falling GDP.


Bank reporting season scorecard for FY19

Our annual scorecard for Australian banks shows earnings were hit by remediation costs and slow credit growth, but they are in good health and look attractive versus other listed companies. 



Special eBooks

Specially-selected collections of the best articles 

Read more

Earn CPD Hours

Accredited CPD hours reading Firstlinks

Read more

Pandora Archive

Firstlinks articles are collected in Pandora, Australia's national archive.

Read more