Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 110

What exactly is the ATO’s role in SMSFs?

In 1999 the regulation of SMSFs was moved from the Superannuation and Insurance Commission (subsequently APRA) to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO). At that time, it was suggested that the ATO acquired the role because SMSFs were seen to be just tax play vehicles, not serious retirement funding vehicles. So, in 2015 when SMSFs hold one-third of the $2 trillion or so in super, is it still correct to say that the ATO’s role in SMSFs is just revenue protection? Or does the ATO have a role in ensuring that SMSF members have a comfortable retirement?

Comparing ATO and APRA regulation

Our starting point has been to compare the way that the ATO regulates SMSFs with the way that APRA regulates the institutional super funds it is responsible for (retail, industry and corporate super funds for example) against five criteria.

First, we looked at the main rule which links the way that a super fund is managed with the tax concessions received on contributions, fund income and benefit taxes: that is, how to be a ‘complying superannuation fund’. The compliance test for SMSFs is different to that for the other type of super funds and, generally, it relates to ensuring that the assets of the SMSF are not misused, such as being a liquidity vehicle for a fund member who has an otherwise illiquid asset. What we also saw was that the chances of non-SMSFs falling foul of this rule are virtually zip.

Second, we looked at the ‘covenants’ in super fund trust deeds. Covenants are, in effect, standards of conduct by which the trustee must run the fund. Again, these differ between SMSFs and non-SMSFs and, importantly, the covenants applying to institutional funds are all directed at protecting the members of the fund from mismanagement by the trustee around various risks that members may be exposed to. On the other hand, the covenants by which a SMSF trustee must comply with relate again to protecting against misuse of the fund assets.

One important covenant for SMSFs is that at they have an ‘investment strategy’, which is referenced to things about investing such as having regard to asset/liability, liquidity and diversification. Interestingly, while the ATO will want to see the SMSF’s investment strategy that is about as far as they go. They do not comment on whether it is good or bad. They just want to see that one exists.

Third, we looked at any differences in the application of the ‘sole purpose test’ between the two types of super funds. It’s the principal regulatory tool for SMSFs and it comes from a 1967 High Court decision about whether a Western Sydney solicitor’s super fund, which was running a property development business, was in fact, a super fund (it wasn’t.) In any case, with two exceptions, all the cases on the sole purpose test have involved SMSFs. It’s not a relevant issue for non-SMSFs.

Fourth, we looked at the rules restricting how a super fund invests. Again, with two exceptions, these rules apply equally to both types of super fund, but what we see is that most of these restrictions are about related-party transactions, which is also not an issue for non-SMSFs.

Finally, we looked at the difference in the style of regulation between the ATO and APRA. This is very telling as the way the ATO regulates SMSFs is against breaches of black letter laws, which, necessarily, can only be done after the breach has occurred. On the other hand, APRA is a prudential principle-based regulator, which assesses the risks to members in the way that the super fund is being run and then offers guidance to the trustees about how to manage those risks. Of course, that is regulation in advance of a breach, besides being directed at protecting members’ interests.

SMSF regulation is simply to ensure qualification for tax concessions

Overall then, our preliminary view is that the ATO simply regulates SMSFs to ensure that they are used for the purposes for which they receive tax concessions. For example, all that is required of an ‘investment strategy’ is that it exists, with no opinion on whether 0% or 100% of anything is suitable.

The next stage for us is to compare SMSF regulation with equivalent type pension funds in the US, Canada and the UK, to see how they do it and why. Also, we will have a look at how some other tax preferred funding vehicles are regulated, such as venture capital funds.

So what? Why do we need to know how SMSFs are regulated? Well, they do hold around $600 billion in assets so it would seem sensible to understand how they are regulated and whether this is appropriate, just in case we can make some suggestions for improvement. For example, is it reasonable that there is no guidance given to the trustee of a super fund on how money should be invested?

 

Gordon Mackenzie is a Senior Lecturer in taxation and business law at the Australian School of Business, University of New South Wales.

 

RELATED ARTICLES

What are wealth industry regulators thinking about?

Are you paying tax by not starting a super pension?

Latest SMSF updates from the ATO

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Meg on SMSFs: Clearing up confusion on the $3 million super tax

There seems to be more confusion than clarity about the mechanics of how the new $3 million super tax is supposed to work. Here is an attempt to answer some of the questions from my previous work on the issue. 

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 566 with weekend update

Here are 10 rules for staying happy and sharp as we age, including socialise a lot, never retire, learn a demanding skill, practice gratitude, play video games (specific ones), and be sure to reminisce.

  • 27 June 2024

Australian housing is twice as expensive as the US

A new report suggests Australian housing is twice as expensive as that of the US and UK on a price-to-income basis. It also reveals that it’s cheaper to live in New York than most of our capital cities.

The catalyst for a LICs rebound

The discounts on listed investment vehicles are at historically wide levels. There are lots of reasons given, including size and liquidity, yet there's a better explanation for the discounts, and why a rebound may be near.

How not to run out of money in retirement

The life expectancy tables used throughout the financial advice and retirement industry have issues and you need to prepare for the possibility of living a lot longer than you might have thought. Plan accordingly.

The iron law of building wealth

The best way to lose money in markets is to chase the latest stock fad. Conversely, the best way to build wealth is by pursuing a timeless investment strategy that won’t be swayed by short-term market gyrations.

Latest Updates

Investment strategies

Have value investors been hindered by this quirk of accounting?

Investments in intangible assets are as crucial to many companies as investments in capital equipment. The different accounting treatment of these investments, however, weighs on reported earnings and could render ratios like P/E less useful for investors.

Investment strategies

Investors are threading the eye of the needle

As investors cram into ever narrower areas of the market with increasingly high valuations, Martin Conlon from Schroders says that sensible investing has rarely been such an uncrowded trade.

Economy

New research shows diverging economic impacts of climate change

There is universal consensus that the Earth is experiencing climate change. Yet there is far more debate about how this will impact different economies across the globe. New research sheds more light on the winners and losers.

SMSF strategies

How super members can avoid missing out on tax deductions

Claiming a tax deduction for personal super contributions can end in disappointment if it isn't done correctly. Julie Steed looks at common pitfalls and what is required for a successful claim.

Investment strategies

AI is not an over-hyped fad – but a killer app might be years away

The AI investment trend looks set to continue for years but there is only room for a handful of long-term winners. Dr Kevin Hebner also warns regulators against strangling innovation in the sector before society reaps the benefits.

Retirement

Why certainty is so important in retirement

Retirement is a time of great excitement but it is also one of uncertainty. This is hardly surprising given the daunting move from receiving a steady outcome to relying on savings and investments.

Economy

This vital yet "forgotten" indicator of inflation holds good news

Financial commentators seem to have forgotten the leading cause of inflation: growth in the supply of money. Warren Bird explains the link and explores where it suggests inflation is headed.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2024 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.