Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 360

Chris Cuffe on why private debt is a hidden gem

Among my various investment activities, I am the Portfolio Manager of the $110 million Australian Philanthropic Services Foundation (APS Foundation). This article focuses on how I have navigated the uncertainties and wild gyrations of investment markets during the COVID-19 pandemic and benefited from a relatively-large holding in private debt securities.

What is a public ancillary fund?

The APS Foundation is a communal philanthropic structure called a public ancillary fund, a structure which is very efficient and tax effective for people interested in philanthropy. It is particular attractive to those who need a tax deduction now but want the flexibility to undertake a regular flow of charitable giving over time.

At this time of year, APS Foundation attracts a lot of attention as people think about philanthropy and do their tax planning and prepare for the close of another financial year. I feel the privilege, excitement and 'pressure' of managing this Foundation and take it very seriously. The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic and resultant negative economic and market consequences have given me plenty to think about. Sometimes the words ‘cold sweat’ come to mind when investment markets fall 20%-30% virtually overnight and I think about how that may impact the APS Foundation and in turn its impact on the community!

The APS Foundation comprises around 300 giving funds (also known as sub-funds) established by individuals, families and companies. They make a tax-deductible donation of at least $50,000 to the Foundation, which is set aside into their own-named giving fund. Each year at least 4% of the giving-fund balance is given to charities recommended by the fund holder. The giving funds are pooled and invested together, with investment returns accruing to the underlying giving funds. Returns are tax-free, so good investment management can see the balance grow, increasing the amount for charities over time.

Investment objectives and strategy

The investment objective for the APS Foundation is to achieve a return after fees at least equal to CPI inflation +4% per annum, measured over rolling seven-year periods. A lot of factors were taken into account before landing on this objective, including:

  • the need to distribute a minimum of 4% per annum to charities
  • the likelihood of inflation affecting the value of the investments and income generated
  • the risk of capital or income loss
  • the liquidity of the investments
  • the costs of investment alternatives and transactions, and
  • the benefits of diversification of investments.

With these investment objectives in mind, we set broad investment ranges to ensure we have plenty of flexibility.

I decided long ago that it was paramount that a charitable foundation, like APS Foundation, needed to have a well-diversified investment portfolio. That would be my best protection against unexpected negative surprises that investment markets have a habit of delivering more often than we sometimes think.

As at the end of February 2020 (just before COVID-19 started to hit hard) the asset allocation of the APS Foundation was as follows:

High allocation to private debt is an anomaly

Compared to say a typical balanced superannuation fund, the high allocation to private debt stands out. Private debt is a significant subset of broader credit markets, often resulting from private equity, securitisation and direct lending activities across various assets pools and corporate borrowers. Such exposures include leveraged loans, commercial, industrial and residential real estate loans, asset-backed loans and loans to businesses secured by their operating assets.


Register here to receive the Firstlinks weekly newsletter for free

Generally speaking, private debt loans, as the name suggests, do not trade on open markets and hence are usually very illiquid (except for some asset-backed securities). Once a loan is made it is typically held to maturity, with terms generally ranging between one and five years, with varying repayment profiles.

Due to its illiquidity, private debt as an asset class will not suit all investors. But for a patient investor with a longer-term investment horizon, who is less concerned about liquidity and seeks attractive current income returns, private debt funds can provide a good risk/return trade off versus high-yield bonds, for example. This suits APS Foundation.

Driven by changes to bank capital requirements

Since the GFC, changes in the bank regulatory capital environment in Australia have increased bank reserving requirements. Similarly, relatively-buoyant equity markets and Australia’s dividend imputation system have seen corporates and investors alike continue to favour equity over corporate bond issuances.

The former has led to a significant contraction in traditional bank lending to small and mid-sized businesses with limited real estate security for example.

The latter has perpetuated an underservicing of capital requirements for these and much larger enterprises through private credit.

This has created a 'funding gap' among Australia's major banks to these businesses, which has now been filled by a number of specialist non-bank lenders. This has greatly assisted the growth of the private debt market and the opportunity for investors like APS Foundation to participate in an area that was once only the domain of the banks. It is interesting to note that Australia’s non-bank lending market is materially smaller as a percentage of the overall market relative to the US and Europe and is expected to continue to grow materially.

The nature of private debt markets

Typically, private debt funds, depending on their risk profile and security exposures, may yield between 5% - 15% per annum. While 'high yield' has generally been synonymous with high risk, this is mitigated if a focus is taken on senior secured investments. These rank in priority to other creditors or equity – particularly listed equity - for liquidity and payment and there is strong asset or cashflow backing to the loan. With a diversity of their underlying collateral, private debt markets deliver opportunities for experienced credit managers.

Australian-based providers of private debt who I have invested with include Revolution Asset Management, Realside Financial Group, PIMCO, Merricks Capital, Longreach Alternatives, Aquasia, Causeway Financial, Pure Asset Management, and Ventra Capital (of which I am also a shareholder and director). And there are many more in this growing market that I have not met.

Performance of the APS portfolio

So how has the APS Foundation investment performance fared of late? During the months of March and April 2020, when the pandemic hit hardest, the Foundation fell 6.1% in value. Although no one wants to see a negative result, this has been a credible performance relative to other multi-sector funds. During this same two-month period, Australian shares decreased 11.4%, unhedged international shares decreased 4.4%, listed property trusts decreased 21.5%, and fixed interest (as measured by the Bloomberg AusBond Composite Index) fell 0.3%.

I believe the private debt exposure has played a significant stabilising role in that result. We have carefully reviewed the value of all private debt in the portfolio to ensure they are realistic given the information currently known. This included a detailed enquiry with each underlying manager of the various private debt securities who in turn has done a granular review of each of their portfolios.

The investment objective of CPI inflation + 4% per annum after fees, measured over rolling seven-year periods, has been met to date, even taking into account the sharp falls over the last quarter. The returns since inception in mid-2012 are 10.1% compound per annum compared to the return objective of 5.9% compound per annum.

Apply these returns to a giving fund established seven years ago with a donation of $100,000 which has distributed the minimum 4% to charity each year. As at April 2020, the giving fund would have gifted $35,348 to charity and its balance grown to $140,949. The structure and its return deliver a compelling style of giving that allows a philanthropist to both give and grow money for charity.

 

Chris Cuffe is Chairman of Australian Philanthropic Services as well as Portfolio Manager of the APS Foundation. Anyone interested in knowing more about APS, including establishing a public ancillary fund before the end of the financial year, should check the APS website.

Chris is also involved with a number of other groups as a director, chairman and investment professional. Chris was one of the founders of Cuffelinks, the predecessor to Firstlinks. This article is general information and does not consider the circumstances fo any investors. Anyone wishing to know more about investments mentioned in this article should seek professional advice as private debts are not as secure as bank deposits or similar.

 

8 Comments
Martin
June 07, 2020

I found this article v helpful. As trustee of an SMSF, my "best" (based on estimated Sharpe ratio) single investment has been a private debt-type investment in a small business started by a friend. I am very aware of the "gap" in the market that banks have vacated and, with this investment due to mature in next year, I am interested to look for alternatives for the future. As other comments have noted, this is an area where there are some unscrupulous players so it was very helpful to get the names of organisations that could be worth further research DD.

S G B
June 05, 2020


Personally, I have no investments in private lenders although I have significant investments in ASX listed stocks ranging from commodities , tech, healthcare & financial.

I have worked as a BDM & credit manager for private lenders and understand how they work.

Private debt funds exist to provide solutions to borrowers that can’t get bank funding. Why can’t they get bank funding?

You might get 10% pa, but what happens if the borrower defaults and you need to sell him up?
What happens to your investment if the Private Debt company gets wound up ?

They have their place and could be potentially good investments but I would be very careful in the current environment.

Some good ones out there for sure. But its important to be aware of the following:

- Investors are either pooled or discrete
- Pooled investors will have to wait in the queue if default occurs
- These investments are ultimately real estate backed
- Real estate is being artificially stimulated & protected by significant gov hand outs ( Job keep / seeker/ loans to SME & now $25K building stimulus package)
- Once the majority of this protection unwinds be very weary of real estate values.
- CV19 will effect borrowers capacity to repay debt & in turn increase the risk of default
- Capital flight is a very big issue for private debt providers & will get worse
- If a firm goes under & I am invested - how many cents in the dollar will I get back ?
- The blood letting that occurred on the sharemarket has resolved itself to a large extent. Market forces have allowed it to bounce back. Private debt however is real estate backed, real estate has significant barriers to entry that make it vastly less flexible. How can you sell a part of the yard with out incurring significant costs to subdivide, surveyor fees, solicitor fees, time to get council approval, waiting on the OSR etc
- Investments cant be traded & are less liquid than other investments be very careful
- Understand how your interest is reflected on the mortgage - if at all
- Understand the notice periods to exit ( if possible at all )
- Private debt companies are not answerable to anyone
- Private debt companies often operate in unregulated areas
- Who owns / operates Private Debt firms historically & why, how does it benefit them ?

Chris Cuffe
June 08, 2020

Thanks for these comments. There are indeed many traps for the unwary which you point out and investors in this asset class need to do so with their eyes wide open. Illiquidity is acknowledged, and that is the reason that you need to hold these investments until maturity....and also one of the reasons an attractive rate of return is offered. Also, apart from regulatory capital reasons, banks tend not to be in this space as the amounts involved are too small for the resources required to assess/monitor the loan - but this leaves the door open to other lower cost small institutions.


A material part of the private debt portfolio of APSF is not backed by property but instead other solid assets, such as government receivables, receivables from insurance companies, insured company receivable.


Also, a lot of the private debt has a comfortable margin built in in case things don't go according to plan. This can include realistic LVR's (in the case of property), first loss buckets funded by others, various covenants, personal guarantees, rights over future cash flows etc.

Andrew Ramsay
June 04, 2020

He mentioned 9 product managers in a little understood asset class so I don’t think that constitutes a product push but rather helpful information to facilitate further research by those who are interested. However, I agree that any product promotion should be avoided on this website.

Graham Hand
June 04, 2020

To clarify ... 1. APS is a charity so some latitude is obviously merited for such a good cause 2. Clearly, Chris is a special case as a co-founder of Cuffelinks and 3. Warren, it's not that we don't want to mention any products, as Gary M is right that readers not only want to know the idea but how to implement it. So yes, we are predominantly about ideas but if an author wants to mention a product as an example of that idea, or how to access it, we're generally fine with that. In fact, we sometimes receive complaints about an interesting 'idea' but what next? Cheers, G

Warren Bird
June 04, 2020

Thanks Graham, I'll keep that in mind when I write something for you again. I've tried very hard not to mention any particular manager or product in my articles.

Gary M
June 04, 2020

Thanks for giving some names who we can contact. It really gives me the pips when other articles talk about a new investment category (like 'tailored securities') and doesn't tell you what they are or how to access them.

Warren Bird
June 04, 2020

Gary M,
one of the guidelines we've been given as contributors is not to do specific product pushes. Chris can push product if he wants to, but please don't have 'the pips' with the rest of us who are asked to write about issues not products.

 

Leave a Comment:

     

RELATED ARTICLES

What should you look for when investing in private debt?

How much bigger can the virus bubble get?

Fear and greed in markets: where to from here?

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Who's next? Discounts on LICs force managers to pivot

The boards and managers of six high-profile LICs, frustrated by their shares trading at large discounts to asset value, have embarked on radical strategies to fix the problems. Will they work?

Four simple things to do right now

Markets have recovered in the last six months but most investors remain nervous about the economic outlook. Morningstar analysts provide four quick tips on how to navigate this uncertainty.

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 374

Suddenly, it's the middle of September and we don't hear much about 'snap back' anymore. Now we have 'wind backs' and 'road maps'. Six months ago, I was flying back from Antarctica after two weeks aboard the ill-fated Greg Mortimer cruise ship, and then the world changed. So it's time to take your temperature again. Our survey checks your reaction to recent policies and your COVID-19 responses.

  • 9 September 2020

Reporting season winners and losers in listed property trusts

Many property trust results are better than expected, with the A-REIT sector on a dividend yield of 4.8%. But there's a wide variation by sector and the ability of tenants to pay the rent.

Have stock markets become a giant Ponzi scheme?

A global financial casino has been created where investors ignore realistic valuations in the low growth, high-risk environment. At some point, analysis of fundamental value will be rewarded.

How the age pension helps retirees cope with losses

It's often overlooked how wealthier couples can fall back on the age pension if a market loss hits their portfolio. The reassurance is never greater than in a financial (and now epidemic) crisis.

Latest Updates

Weekly Editorial

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 376

The US tech index, the NASDAQ, peaked on 2 September 2020 at 12,058 and three weeks later closed at 10,632. On the same days, Apple hit US$137.98 and then fell to US$107.12. These falls of over 10% and 20% seem high but both were simply returning to their early August levels. It's hardly a rout when a month's gains are given back. The bigger issue is whether such stock corrections will scare off the retail 'Robinhood' traders.

  • 24 September 2020
  • 2
Interviews

Interview on new technologies with more potential to grow

For many global tech companies, COVID has boosted their revenues and pushed share prices to all-time highs. We are on the cusp of amazing technical advances and there are plenty of new opportunities.

Shares

Five reasons why Tesla is the everything bubble

As fewer professionals actively research the merits of a company’s prospects, stocks become disproportionately driven by capital flows. Prices disconnect from fundamentals and there's no better example than Tesla.

Retirement

Three retirement checks for when you have enough

Not every retiree needs to gun for higher returns, but a conservative portfolio can court its own risks, especially with bond rates so low. But some retirees prefer to settle for a lower income.

Shares

Hide and seek: the FX impact on global equity investments

As more Australians tilt their investments to global equities, they often overlook the exchange rate risk and fees. The move from US57 cents to US73 cents in six months shows the unhedged impact.

Economy

When America sneezes, the world catches a ...

The recovery from COVID-19 is looking more like a K-shape, with some companies doing well while others struggle. The pandemic seems more akin to a black swan, exogenous shock than a structural downturn.

Retirement

How the age pension helps retirees cope with losses

It's often overlooked how wealthier couples can fall back on the age pension if a market loss hits their portfolio. The reassurance is never greater than in a financial (and now epidemic) crisis.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2020 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use.
Any general advice or class service prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, has been prepared by without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. Refer to our Financial Services Guide (FSG) for more information. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.