Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 297

Investor questions for marketplace lenders

One of the conceits of Gary Shteyngart’s Super Sad Love Story is a future in which everybody’s ability to continue accessing consumer credit is determined, in real time, by credit poles that announce to the world the credit ratings of those who pass by. The book, which was written back in 2010, seemed to anticipate a world in which, companies know more about you than you do about yourself.

Anticipating borrower credentials

Consumer lending seems ripe for these forms of corporate intelligence to anticipate the behaviour of potential or current borrowers. Advances in artificial intelligence have been used by banks on credit card lending for decades and seem to be paying off. The average annual U.S. net credit card loss rate for prime borrowers has been at its lowest recorded (below 3%) for the past five years, significantly below the 30-year 5% average. As the average interest rate on US credit cards has remained at over 13%, the average bank seems to be making a lot of money on this type of lending, as long as they can control its risk.

The original promise of peer-to-peer lending was precisely this: why should the banks benefit from this enormous spread between lending rates and funding rates? A potential investor in marketplace lending (i.e. a lender) should benefit instead. And the rates paid to marketplace lenders are higher than they would otherwise receive if lending to a bank itself. However, just as with securitisation lending, investors in marketplace lending own the risk, and need to ensure that it is carefully managed. The consumer credit arena was littered over the decades with those who flew too close to the sun, particularly in new forms of consumer credit [1].

Comparisons with other types of lending

On its surface, marketplace lending seems promising for a potential investor. A pool of consumer or commercial loans sourced through an intermediary provides the benefit of borrower diversification, just as a securitisation loan pool does, and at a higher net estimated spread than other types of lending.

Another perceived advantage is that pools of loans have the benefit of apparent familiarity. Unlike high yield bonds or loans or even asset-backed securities (ABS), these auto, commercial and consumer loans are easily understandable, not highly structured as ABS are, and locally (according to their originators) have experienced only nominal losses of less than 0.25% as a percentage of the pool.

The table below shows an estimate of the credit spread available from marketplace lending compared with other types of lending. Note that while most data is based on historical performance of debt type, the marketplace lending estimates are projected based on the experience of comparable types of consumer lending.

Estimated loss-adjusted credit spread by type of asset

Source: Moody’s, Credit Suisse. Loss-adjusted spread is estimated based on a four-year average loan life. Recoveries are assumed to occur simultaneously with defaults for simplicity (in reality there would be a lag). Long term spread for marketplace loans is interpolated to be historical average spread for BB unsecured consumer securitised debt, with lower assumed default rate (actual historical is 5-10%) and similar recovery rate.

Difficulties knowing default rates in advance

But there are also reasons for caution with respect to marketplace lending. In general, debt investing and equity investing are different. With less upside available in debt than equity, it ordinarily pays more to be an early investor in equity than in a new type of debt. The reason we have done so well (in some respects) as a species is because of our enthusiasm for what is new. But successful debt investors can perhaps be considered a particularly dour sub-species. Australia has gone through a period of around 30 years of economic expansion, has never had a full subprime lending cycle, and so new investors in consumer debt should be careful. Most marketplace loan packages also do not have the same level of equity protection as their predecessor securitisations, although this is beginning to change.

Potential investors should therefore be conservative with respect to the eventual losses expected on this type of lending. An annual loss rate of 3.5% when realised losses are less than 0.50% seems high, but subprime consumer lending annual losses have historically been in the high single digits virtually universally, and higher if a pool performs poorly. If this 3.5% loss rate doubles to 7%, for example, the annualised total return over a four-year period becomes -1.75%. In prior economic cycles, securitisation loan originators tried to limit investor losses by freezing credit, and in revolving pools by allowing payments to go to debt investors first. Still, some of the lowest-ranked ABS debt had net credit losses, which is why subordinate ABS have some of the worst loss-adjusted spreads over the past two decades.

The other way that loan originators have tried to limit losses is by setting interest rates high enough to compensate for the risk. Commercial marketplace lending rates are 15% and more. Some consumer rates may be lower than this, but higher than traditional credit card rates. A high annual interest rate should be enough to compensate a loan originator for residual credit risk. Part of this charge is also to cover loan servicing costs, which for subprime lending have traditionally been 4-6% annually. But without additional credit protection, potential investors might also ask is why the rates they receive are significantly lower than this, since the disintermediation of banks and their fees was meant to be a main advantage of this type of lending.

The making and pricing of loans

A key question for marketplace lenders should be how they use their intelligence on potential borrowers to make and price loans. If marketplace lenders truly have developed valuable ways of assessing customer behavioural risk through intelligence, they should be able to describe it in detail to potential investors without giving away their business advantage.

The world of credit poles for consumer credit assessment, just as with other forms of machine-learnt intelligence, is probably not as far away as we think. But along the way, there will almost certainly be some accidents, just as there have been over the past two decades. An investor evaluating marketplace lending should take care that he or she is aware of the risks for the potential return they can receive.

[1] NextCard, an internet-based credit card company that issued securitisation debt and failed in the early 2000s, is probably the easiest example to pick out. The technology was far ahead of the credit intelligence actually needed to make the business work. As investors, we try to learn from our mistakes.


John O’Brien is a Principal Adviser at Whitehelm Capital, an affiliate of Fidante Partners. The views expressed in this article are those of the author. This article is for general information purposes only and does not consider the circumstances of any investor.

Fidante is a sponsor of Cuffelinks. For more articles and papers from Fidante, please click here.


Most viewed in recent weeks

House prices surge but falls are common and coming

We tend to forget that house prices often fall. Direct lending controls are more effective than rate rises because macroprudential limits affect the volume of money for housing leaving business rates untouched.

Survey responses on pension eligibility for wealthy homeowners

The survey drew a fantastic 2,000 responses with over 1,000 comments and polar opposite views on what is good policy. Do most people believe the home should be in the age pension asset test, and what do they say?

100 Aussies: five charts on who earns, pays and owns

Any policy decision needs to recognise who is affected by a change. It pays to check the data on who pays taxes, who owns assets and who earns the income to ensure an equitable and efficient outcome.

Three good comments from the pension asset test article

With articles on the pensions assets test read about 40,000 times, 3,500 survey responses and thousands of comments, there was a lot of great reader participation. A few comments added extra insights.

The sorry saga of housing affordability and ownership

It is hard to think of any area of widespread public concern where the same policies have been pursued for so long, in the face of such incontrovertible evidence that they have failed to achieve their objectives.

Two strong themes and companies that will benefit

There are reasons to believe inflation will stay under control, and although we may see a slowing in the global economy, two companies should benefit from the themes of 'Stable Compounders' and 'Structural Winners'.

Latest Updates


Stop treating the family home as a retirement sacred cow

The way home ownership relates to retirement income is rated a 'D', as in Distortion, Decumulation and Denial. For many, their home is their largest asset but it's least likely to be used for retirement income.


Hey boomer, first home buyers and all the fuss

What is APRA worried about? Most mortgagees can easily absorb increases in interest rates without posing a systemic threat to the banking system. Housing lending is a relatively risk-free activity for banks.


Residential Property Survey Q3 2021

Housing market sentiment has eased from record highs and confidence has ticked down as house price rises slow. Construction costs overtook lack of development sites as the biggest impediment for new housing.

Investment strategies

Personal finance is 80% personal and 20% finance

Understanding your own biases and behaviours is even more important than learning about markets. Overcome four major cognitive biases that may be sabotaging your investing and recognise them in others.

Where do stockmarket returns come from over time?

Cash flow statements differ from income statements and balance sheets, and every company must balance payments to investors versus investing into the business. Cash flows drive the value of the business.

Fixed interest

How to invest in the ‘reopening of Australia’ in bonds

As Sydney and Melbourne emerge from lockdown, there are some reopening trades in the Australian credit market which 'sophisticated' investors should consider as part of their fixed income portfolios.


10 trends reshaping the future of emerging markets

Demand for air travel, China’s growing middle-class population, Brazil’s digital payments take-up, Indian IPOs, and increased urbanisation are just some of the trends being seen in emerging economies.



© 2021 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. Any general advice or ‘regulated financial advice’ under New Zealand law has been prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide (AU) and Financial Advice Provider Disclosure Statement (NZ). You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.

Website Development by Master Publisher.