Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 140

Lessons from Peter Lynch and Dick Smith

If you like the store, chances are you’ll love the stock.” Peter Lynch in Beating the Street (1993).

The biggest stock story of summer is the demise of Dick Smith Holdings (ASX:DSH). The high profile retailer listed on the ASX on 3 December 2013 at a valuation of $520 million only two years after private equity firm Anchorage bought the business from Woolworths for not much (the exact amount is disputed). Most analysis has focused on the role of private equity in taking the spoils from an audacious play. In this article, we draw on the advice of the legendary fund manager Peter Lynch to look for investing lessons from the Dick Smith debacle.

Who is Peter Lynch?

Peter Lynch managed the Fidelity Magellan Fund for 13 years until his retirement in 1990, increasing the value of $1,000 to $28,000 over this time. Time magazine called him the Number One money manager in the United States, and he cemented his reputation when his first book, One Up on Wall Street, became a worldwide bestseller and compulsory reading for all fund managers.

In his 1993 follow up, Beating the Street, he has a chapter called, ‘Shopping for stocks: the retail sector’ in which he says:

“Public companies on the way up, on the way down, on the way out, or turning themselves around can be investigated any day of the week by both amateur and professional stock shoppers. As an investment strategy, hanging out at the mall is far superior to taking a stockpicker’s advice on faith or combing the financial press for the latest tips.”

He then gives a detailed explanation of what he sees when he visits his local shopping mall, including kicking himself for missing out on Chili’s Restaurants which his three children loved. He says a lot can be learned in one location because what sells in one town is almost certain to sell in another.

“I don’t think of it as browsing. I think of it as fundamental analysis on an intriguing lineup of potential investments, arranged side by side for the convenience of stock shoppers. Here are more likely prospects than you could uncover in a month of investment conferences.”

My Dick Smith shopping experience

What happens when I apply the Peter Lynch shopping advice to Dick Smith? I’m a ‘typical’ consumer of electronic goods rather than a tech geek. I don’t need to be at the leading edge by buying every new gadget, but I like to keep up with technology. I have a basic understanding of what I want but often need technical assistance.

Going back a couple of years, I would regularly shop at Dick Smith for electronic needs, and even under the latter stages of the Woolworths ownership, I thought it was a good shopping experience. Young, enthusiastic techies knew their stuff, and were tolerant in explaining the obvious to an older generation. Prices were competitive and there was a willingness to price match.

One memorable incident sticks in my mind from a few years ago. The young salesman tried to upsell me into an extended warranty, but I knew these were usually expensive and not necessary.

I told him, “I would never find the receipt and warranty in a couple of years when I need them.”

“Don’t worry”, he said confidently. “We’ll keep your records here and all you have to do is bring the goods into the store and we will fix them.”

That was an impressive customer service.

In private equity hands, I felt their offer remained at least consistent and perhaps improved, especially on the marketing side. The yellow Dick Smith brochures came into our home every week, and along with JB Hi Fi, Harvey Norman, Bing Lee and online retailers, I would usually check Dick Smith’s prices. My impression as a consumer rather than a stock analyst was that Dick Smith and its private equity owners were building a solid business, but I made no attempt to analyse the company’s financials, nor did I participate in the float.

At the time of the ASX listing, Dick Smith passed the basic Peter Lynch test of being a good, busy place to shop with enthusiastic staff, smart products and competitive prices for the serious consumer. Based on Woolies’ experience, maybe this was never enough to make a decent return on capital and it was always doomed, but as a shopping experience, it looked on the money.

For the consumer, what went wrong?

Dick Smith was a listed company for only two years. In the post-float months, it retained the same external modus operandi as when in private hands. It increased store locations to an impressive 393, giving it scale and exposure.

But at some point, something changed. I have checked with friends who confirm my impressions. According to Lynch, I can make this judgement based on visiting just a couple of stores.

Notable was the less experienced staff, and a need to check with the manager to answer questions. There was significantly more Dick Smith-branded product, when electronics and communications are obviously brand markets. Nobody wants a Dick Smith laptop. And fewer of the bright yellow signs that enticed with specials.

But the real surprise came towards the end of 2015. I was shocked by the local store’s changes. Looking for a laptop, I had researched the market and knew what I wanted and the alternatives. Despite Dick Smith listing my chosen laptop online, the store range was pathetic. Old and inferior models, and no enticing price offers.

I asked a staff member if the laptop was in stock, and he did not know and checked his computer. This was a top seller which had sold out at a couple of Bing Lee stores, where their staff instantly knew the model. Then no attempt by Dick Smith staff to sell me something else. The store looked different. None of the eye-catching, large price posters you see in JB Hi Fi or Harvey Norman, but just shelves of tired-looking stuff. They had moved the checkout from a pod structure in the middle (where you were forced to pass heaps of other products) to a desk next to the exit door. The place looked like one of those standalone stores where no overall corporate marketing theme and look had been applied.

Many people in the media have criticised Dick Smith’s bankers for calling in administrators, but based on my experience, they had to. The problems were endemic, not a matter of a poor retail cycle. Harvey Norman and JB Hi Fi have been trading well, and household goods sales were up over 8% in the year to November 2015. Retailing is fast-moving where the quality traders respond to customer trends and manage their inventory, and applying the Peter Lynch test, Dick Smith lost its way.

Two months before going into administration, on the day of its 2015 Annual General Meeting, Dick Smith issued this market update:

“Gross profit was adversely affected by increased promotional activity and unfavourable product mix, with strong sales growth in unlocked phones and fitness and disappointing sales in tablets, gaming and accessories. Channel mix was also negative, with strong online sales growth offsetting softer retail store sales, impacting gross margin.”

Limitations of the Peter Lynch method … or me

Although there is great intuitive appeal in the Lynch method, I’ve often struggled with it. Maybe this says more about me than the company. I don’t like the way Harvey Norman stores are split into separate franchises, so one person cannot help on another’s product range. I hate loud music playing when I buy jeans, and I don’t get a thrill watching an app showing where the Domino’s Pizza delivery bike is located on its way to my house. I’d rather pay for an Italian gelato than a cheaper ice cream at Wendy’s. I like shopping at Myer and David Jones but they have both struggled.

On the other hand, the appeal of Bunnings is obvious, and Lynch would love the Sunday morning queues (and the direct exposure possible through the Bunnings Warehouse Property Trust and the less directly via Wesfarmers) if not the terrible sausage sandwiches.

And I like roasted almonds in my homemade muesli, and in recent years, I’ve noticed the incredible increases in price due to the Californian drought, and they’re still selling in my area for $13.99 for 500g. Yet Select Harvests’ share price has halved to around $6 from a high of $13.48 in April 2015, mainly due to rain on the US West Coast, where most of the world’s almonds are grown. I’m still waiting for cheaper almonds in my retail store.

Which shows that while ogling in a shopping centre can be part of the stock purchase decision, there are many other factors to check. So we’ll finish with a couple of other Peter Lynch quotes:

“Behind every stock is a company. Find out what it’s doing.”

“The person that turns over the most rocks wins the game.”

The analysts who were still recommending Dick Smith in late 2015 were too busy looking at numbers and not standing in a Dick Smith store, channeling Peter Lynch.

 

Graham Hand is Editor of Cuffelinks and has almost 40 years of experience in various segments of the finance industry. He has never worked in retailing.

RELATED ARTICLES

Failed IPOs show power of active vigilantes

Insane prices as private equity quits market

It's unlikely Uber has a long-term future

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Stop treating the family home as a retirement sacred cow

The way home ownership relates to retirement income is rated a 'D', as in Distortion, Decumulation and Denial. For many, their home is their largest asset but it's least likely to be used for retirement income.

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 433 with weekend update

There’s this story about a group of US Air Force generals in World War II who try to figure out ways to protect fighter bombers (and their crew) by examining the location of bullet holes on returning planes. Mapping the location of these holes, the generals quickly come to the conclusion that the areas with the most holes should be prioritised for additional armour.

  • 11 November 2021

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 431 with weekend update

House prices have risen at the fastest pace for 33 years, but what actually happened in 1988, and why is 2021 different? Here's a clue: the stockmarket crashed 50% between September and November 1987. Looking ahead, where did house prices head in the following years, 1989 to 1991?

  • 28 October 2021

Why has Australia slipped down the global super ranks?

Australia appears to be slipping from the pantheon of global superstar pension systems, with a recent report placing us sixth. A review of an earlier report, which had Australia in bronze position, points to some reasons why, and what might need to happen to regain our former glory.

How to help people with retirement spending decisions

Super funds will soon be required to offer retirement income strategies for members in decumulation. With uncertain returns, uncertain timelines, and different goals, it's possibly “the hardest, nastiest problem in finance".

Tips when taking large withdrawals from super

You want to take a lump sum from your super, but what's the best way? Should it come from you or your spouse, or the pension or accumulation account. There is a welcome flexibility to select the best outcome.

Latest Updates

Interviews

John Woods on diversification using asset allocation

All fund managers now claim to take ESG factors into account, but a multi-asset ethical fund will look quite different from a mainstream fund. Faced with low fixed income returns, alternatives have a bigger role.

SMSF strategies

Don't believe the SMSF statistics on investment allocation

The ATO's data on SMSF asset allocation is as much as 27 months out-of-date and categories such as cash and global investments are reported incorrectly. We should question the motives of some who quote the numbers.

Investment strategies

Highlights of reader tips for young investors

In this second part on the reader responses with advice to younger people, we have selected a dozen highlights, but there are so many quality contributions that a full list of comments is also attached.

Investment strategies

Four climate themes offer investors the next big thing

Climate-related companies will experience exponential growth driven by consumer demand and government action. Investors who identify the right companies will benefit from four themes which will last decades.

Investment strategies

Inflation remains transitory due to strong long-term trends

There is momentum to stop calling inflation 'transitory' but this overlooks deep-seated trends. A longer-term view will see companies like ARB, Reece, Macquarie Telecom and CSL more valuable in a decade.

Infrastructure

Infrastructure and the road to recovery

Infrastructure assets experienced varying fortunes during the pandemic, from less travel at airports to strong activity in communications. On the road to recovery, what role does infrastructure play in a portfolio?

Economy

The three prices that everyone should worry about

Among the myriad of numbers that bombard us every day, three prices matter greatly to the world economy. Recent changes in these prices help to understand the potential for a global recovery and interest rates.

Shares

Why green hydrogen is central to achieving net zero

Hundreds of green hydrogen projects show this energy opportunity is finally being taken seriously. While a cost disadvantage and technical challenges need to be overcome, it promises to deliver a path to net zero.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2021 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. Any general advice or ‘regulated financial advice’ under New Zealand law has been prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide (AU) and Financial Advice Provider Disclosure Statement (NZ). You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.

Website Development by Master Publisher.