Reporting season has delivered a clear message: the market is no longer paying simply for quality, resilience or an earnings beat. It is paying for change in earnings expectations.
The largest share price reactions occurred where results materially altered the market's view of a company's earnings trajectory. Companies demonstrating an earnings inflection, accelerating operating leverage or a credible path to higher margins were aggressively rewarded. Conversely, companies reporting solid results but signalling weaker outlooks through softer volumes, higher costs or limited incremental earnings growth were punished.
That distinction helps explain why this has been one of the most volatile reporting seasons in recent memory. For investors, understanding where earnings expectations are changing has become more important than identifying companies that simply look inexpensive or defensive.
During August, CSL rose over 40%, closely followed by gold miners Newmont (39%) and Evolution Mining (35%), and Pilbara Minerals (30%). Meanwhile, Charter Hall fell 16.5%, QBE Insurance 15%, CBA 13% and Wesfarmers 13%. The common thread was not "beats versus misses". Although 31% beat consensus and 24% missed, FY27 earnings forecasts still fell around 1-2%, while 51% of stocks moved more than 5% on result days.
Resources companies supplied the clearest leadership. BHP gained 12% and Rio Tinto 9%, while gold and critical-mineral exposures outperformed the broader market. BHP's underlying EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortisation) approached US$33bn, with copper contributing more than half of earnings, and its final dividend rose 65%. Evolution lifted its final dividend 62% and raised its payout target. Northern Star delivered record profit and a solid dividend, although elevated FY27 costs and capital expenditure may temper some of that leverage.
The portfolio lesson is to own structural scarcity assets such as copper, gold and rare earths, while distinguishing between commodity-price leverage and management execution. In an environment shaped by electrification, AI infrastructure demand and energy transition themes, scarcity remains valuable, but quality execution still matters.
The second winning factor was earnings rehabilitation: high-quality franchises where margins and earnings growth are inflecting upwards. CSL's spectacular rally followed what appeared to be a disappointing result on headline numbers, with underlying NPATA (net profit after tax adjusted) down 2% and US$7.1bn of impairments. Investors instead focused on management's FY27 profit growth guidance of around 5%, alongside maintained dividends and buybacks. The market rewarded future earnings potential rather than historical earnings pressure.
Another winning factor was pricing power, recurring revenues and operating leverage. Investors gravitated towards digital marketplaces, mission-critical software and installed-base service businesses capable of compounding earnings independently of underlying transaction volumes.
REA and CAR demonstrated why dominant marketplaces remain attractive. Their scale allows revenue and average revenue per user to grow faster than transaction volumes through premium listings, advertising, finance and data products. In a modest-growth economy, pricing power and network effects are becoming increasingly valuable.
WiseTech and Pro Medicus reinforced the premium attached to recurring revenue, margin expansion and productivity. WiseTech guided to FY27 revenue growth of 6-10% and underlying EBITDA growth of 12-21%, while Pro Medicus delivered 28% constant-currency revenue growth and a 75% EBIT margin. The AI trade is increasingly moving from narrative to measurable revenue growth, productivity gains and free cash flow generation.
The losers exposed three crowded assumptions: ever-rising bank returns, defensive certainty and cheap capital. Major banks including CBA, Westpac and NAB sold off despite strong profitability as investors focused on weaker outlooks for housing credit growth and margins. Wesfarmers fell despite underlying NPAT growth and dividend growth of 8%, as weaker Officeworks earnings and higher capital expenditure expectations mattered more. REITs including Charter Hall and Goodman reinforced the market's sensitivity to funding costs and long-duration valuations.
There is no single "consumer" trade. Stock selection matters. Consumer outcomes remain highly fragmented, driven by brand positioning, customer demographics and pricing power rather than broad economic trends alone. JB Hi-Fi's slowing sales momentum triggered a de-rating, while Universal Store continued to benefit from differentiated merchandise and stronger engagement with younger consumers. Woolworths represents another cohort, combining essential spending with loyalty, retail media and digital services.
By late August, market dividend forecasts had risen around 0.4% despite falling earnings estimates. Outliers included BHP and Evolution Mining on the upside, Fortescue's 2% lower full-year dividend, and an 11% cut to one published Woodside Energy 2026 EPS (earnings per share) forecast following higher tax and cost assumptions.
Takeover activity also created alpha during August. Steadfast signed a $6.00 scheme with KKR, Dragoneer and Amwins; EQT proposed $3.13 per share for Cleanaway; and Brookfield proposed $4.75 for Reliance Worldwide. The pattern suggests private capital continues to identify value where public markets remain sceptical, particularly among high-quality strategic assets experiencing cyclical weakness.
The outlook remains a barbell: structural resources and positive-revision growth on one side, and cash-generative recurring-revenue franchises on the other. The vulnerable middle remains expensive domestic duration, peak-margin financials, capital-intensive property and retailers dependent on broad consumption growth.
In our view, the opportunity set remains strongest where earnings expectations are improving, balance sheets are robust, and companies retain pricing power. Reporting season reinforced a simple but important lesson: markets are rewarding future earnings potential, not merely celebrating past performance.
Key takeaways
- Markets are rewarding future earnings, not past results: Share price moves were driven by changing earnings expectations rather than earnings beats or misses.
- Structural growth and pricing power are winning: Investors favoured scarce resource assets and businesses with recurring revenues, strong margins and pricing power.
- Stock selection matters more than ever: Winners are improving earnings outlooks; losers are facing weaker growth, higher costs or stretched valuations.
Zara Lyons is an Australian High Conviction Strategies portfolio manager at Fidelity International, a sponsor of Firstlinks. The views are their own. This content is issued by FIL Responsible Entity (Australia) Limited ABN 33 148 059 009, AFSL 409340 (‘Fidelity Australia’), a member of the FIL Limited group of companies commonly known as Fidelity and Fidelity International. This content is intended as general information only. You should consider the relevant Product Disclosure Statement available on our website www.fidelity.com.au.
For more articles and papers from Fidelity, please click here.
© 2026 FIL Responsible Entity (Australia) Limited. Fidelity, Fidelity International and the Fidelity International logo and F symbol are trademarks of FIL Limited.