Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 73

Why have small cap stocks underperformed?

According to the renowned Elroy Dimson, Emeritus Professor of Finance at the London Business School, the share prices of small companies have consistently outperformed large companies over the longer term. The ‘small-cap premium’, as Dimson describes it, equates to an average of 0.54% per month across global equities over the long term. In the United States the premium is 0.72% per month and in Australia, it accounts for 0.52% of outperformance per month, one of the highest premiums of the markets compared. However, over the last two years small caps have underperformed their large cap rivals in Australia. So why have our small company share prices bucked the historical trend?

Measuring up

Since mid-2012, the S&P/ASX All Ordinaries Accumulation Index, which represents the 500 largest companies listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX), has risen a remarkable 47.0% as the current bull market has charged ahead. Over the same period, the S&P/ASX Small Ordinaries Accumulation Index, which tracks the performance of the ASX’s small-cap companies (outside the top 100), has increased just 11.7%. The contrast between the two indexes is stark and particularly incongruous when you compare the two indexes over the preceding three years. Between March 2009 and June 2012 the Small Ordinaries Index outperformed the All Ordinaries by 9.6%.

Is the 35.0% outperformance by large companies over small companies in the last couple of years reflective of a structural change or is it a mere short term variance? In our view, the last two years in the Australian equities market represents a short term anomaly to the longer term trend. We believe this is the case for two main reasons. Firstly, small mining and mining services companies which dominate the Small Ordinaries Index have significantly underperformed in recent years. Secondly, the All Ordinaries Index  is dominated by the big four banks and Telstra and has relatively outperformed as investors have piled into these stocks in search of yield.

End of the mining boom

The well-documented end of Australia’s recent resources investment boom has hit the mining and mining services sector hard. As China adapts to lower economic growth, the demand for resources has softened and spot commodity prices have fallen, in some cases, significantly. While Australia’s miners were the major beneficiaries of numerous major mining projects announced, through the 2000s, many of these projects are now coming to an end. With Hancock Prospecting’s Roy Hill mine the only major new domestic project currently slated to come on line, the contract pipeline for many of Australia’s mining and mining services companies is now very weak. As a result the valuations and share prices of many of these companies have plummeted with some trading below their prices during the depths of the GFC. Tellingly, the five worst performers over the last two years are mining and mining services companies as shown in the following table.

In 2012, a total of 36% of companies that made up the Small Ordinaries Index were mining or mining services companies. As at 30 June 2014, this figure had dropped to 26%.  Over the last two years, the Small Resources Index which measures the performance of small mining companies alone, shows  they collectively fell 42%. Stripping out the mining companies from the Small Ordinaries Index, the Small Industrials Index reveals the remainder of the small caps performed strongly, rising 32% over the last two years. While mining companies have floundered, we have experienced a recovery in many cyclical industrial stocks such as those in the housing and finance sector.

The hunt for yield

A key market theme over the last couple of years has been investors’ chase for yield as the Baby Boomer generation moves into retirement. While in the past a reasonable income stream could have been derived from term deposits, the current historically low interest rates have driven investors into higher-yielding blue chip stocks. Whereas term deposit yields are averaging around 3.3% per annum, Telstra, for example, is currently paying a grossed-up yield of 7%. With some maturing term deposits previously paying around 6%, the choice between rolling over at around half the yield or investing in Telstra is compelling. And as banks have benefitted from low interest rates and better economic conditions, they have performed strongly.

Australia’s equity market is very narrow with the four major banks and Telstra currently accounting for 32% of the All Ordinaries Index. Their valuations have increased with a disproportionate impact on the equity market resulting in them being responsible for approximately two-thirds of the equity market’s performance over the last two years.

Small cap performance to return to long term trend

The key to small caps turning around will be the improvement in mining stocks. If commodity prices rise and investor sentiment towards mining stocks improves, this will necessarily improve their valuations. Already there has been an improvement in sentiment which has led to a rise in the sector’s share prices of approximately 15% off their recent lows.

We expect that current low interest rates could drive economic growth which would in turn lead to an uptick in small cap earnings. In our view, the small cap sector will again outperform the large caps reflecting Dimson’s findings over the longer term, and the recent underperformance by the small cap sector is a cyclical, rather than a structural change.

 

Chris Stott is Chief Investment Officer at Wilson Asset Management. His views are general in nature and readers should seek their own professional advice before making any financial decisions.

 


 

Leave a Comment:

RELATED ARTICLES

An odd and wild ASX reporting season

Small caps are compelling but not for the reasons you might think...

Two proven ways to make big money in markets

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Howard Marks: the investing game has changed

The famed investor says the rapid switch from globalisation to trade wars is the biggest upheaval in the investing environment since World War Two. And a new world requires a different investment approach.

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 605 with weekend update

Trump's tariffs and China's retaliatory strike have sent the Nasdaq into a bear market with the S&P 500 not far behind. What are the implications for the economy and markets, and what should investors do now? 

  • 3 April 2025

Pros and cons of Labor's home batteries scheme

Labor has announced a $2.3 billion Cheaper Home Batteries Program, aimed at slashing the cost of home batteries. The goal is to turbocharge battery uptake, though practical difficulties may prevent that happening.

Designing a life, with money to spare

Are you living your life by default or by design? It strikes me that many people are doing the former and living according to others’ expectations of them, leading to poor choices including with their finances.

World's largest asset manager wants to revolutionise your portfolio

Larry Fink is one of the smartest people in the finance industry. In his latest shareholder letter, the Blackrock CEO outlines his quest to become the biggest player in private assets and upend investor portfolios.

4 ways to take advantage of the market turmoil

Every crisis throws up opportunities. Here are ideas to capitalise on this one, including ‘overbalancing’ your portfolio in stocks, buying heavily discounted LICs, and cherry picking bombed out sectors like oil and gas.

Latest Updates

Investment strategies

An enlightened dividend path

While many chase high yields, true investment power lies in companies that steadily grow dividends. This strategy, rooted in patience and discipline, quietly compounds wealth and anchors investors through market turbulence.

Investment strategies

Don't let Trump derail your wealth creation plans

If you want to build wealth over the long-term, trying to guess the stock market's next move is generally a bad idea. In a month where this might be more tempting than ever, here is what you should focus on instead.

Economics

Pros and cons of Labor's home batteries scheme

Labor has announced a $2.3 billion Cheaper Home Batteries Program, aimed at slashing the cost of home batteries. The goal is to turbocharge battery uptake, though practical difficulties may prevent that happening.

Investment strategies

Will China's EV boom end in tears?

China's EV dominance is reshaping global auto markets - but with soaring tariffs, overcapacity, and rising scrutiny, the industry’s meteoric rise may face a turbulent road ahead. Can China maintain its lead - or will it stall?

Investment strategies

REITs: a haven in a Trumpian world?

Equity markets have been lashed by Trump's tariff policies, yet REITs have outperformed. Not only are they largely unaffected by tariffs, but they offer a unique combination of growth, sound fundamentals, and value.

Shares

Why Europe is back on the global investor map

European equities are surging ahead of the U.S this year, driven by strong earnings, undervaluation, and fiscal stimulus. With quality founder-led firms and a strengthening Euro, Europe may be the next global investment hotspot.

Chalmers' disingenuous budget claims

The Treasurer often touts a $207 billion improvement in Australia's financial position. A deeper look at the numbers reveals something less impressive, caused far more by commodity price surprises than policy.

Fixed interest

Duration: Friend or foe in a defensive allocation?

Duration is back. After years in the doghouse, shifting markets and higher yields are restoring its role as a reliable diversifier and income source - offering defensive strength in today’s uncertain environment.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2025 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.