Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 345

Worshipping at the altar of alternative assets

Investors are faced with a difficult conundrum today: run the risk of accepting lower returns from traditional asset classes (stocks, bonds, cash) or use alternative assets to try to boost prospective performance, generate inflation-beating returns, and improve diversification.

In this article, we’ll look at what the asset allocators in our rated universe are doing in the alternative, real return, or other portion of their portfolios and what this means from a risk and return perspective.

Definition of alternatives

The non-traditional or alternatives asset class is a broad church. Morningstar defines it as those strategies that don’t offer a consistent beta (market return) to the more traditional asset classes. We bucket them into four groups:

  • Unlisted real assets
  • Hedge funds (including managed futures)
  • Private equity and private debt
  • Structured products

The believers

The table below shows some of our rated multisector managers and their allocations to alternatives. The funds in the table all reside in our balanced or growth categories to try to ensure a fair comparison. The balanced category is for funds with a 41-60% growth allocation and the growth category is for funds with a 61-80% growth allocation.

Table of Morningstar multisector funds with allocations to alternative investments

Manager Name Alternative Allowance % Current Alternative % Portfolio Holdings Date
Diversified Funds      
Advance Balanced 0-22% 6% Mar-19
CFS Balanced 5-15% 10% Mar-19
MLC Horizon 4 Balanced N/A 14% Mar-19
Pendal Active Balanced 0-20% 15% Mar-19
Perpetual Balanced Growth 0-30% 11% Mar-19
Russell Balanced 0-35% 12.50% Mar-19
Industry Funds      
AustralianSuper Conservative Balanced 0-60% 17% Mar-19
CBUS Super Growth 0-81% 31% Dec-18
Sunsuper Balanced 0-90% 32% Dec-18

What is notable is the magnitude of the allowable ranges and the portion of the budget currently being used. Pendal introduced an alternative allocation into its strategic asset allocation in 2012 and is now allocating 15% of the portfolio, the highest among the non-industry funds in our rated universe.

At the other end of the table is Advance. The 6% weight appears modest compared with peers, but this allocation is likely to grow as the group plans to expand its unlisted alternatives programme over the next 12 months.

Unsurprisingly, the industry funds are far more aggressive with their allocations to non-traditional assets, due to their stickier client base and long-term investment horizon. AustralianSuper, CBUS, and Sunsuper are all permitted to have the majority of their portfolios invested in alternatives. According to our latest surveyed data, CBUS and Sunsuper have roughly 30% allocations, while AustralianSuper has roughly half as much.

Alternatives are a broad church

One important distinction in alternative investments is the choice between listed and unlisted assets. CFS, Pendal, Perpetual, and MLC have opted for the listed part of the spectrum, building real return strategies to deliver inflation-beating performance.

  • CFS’ Real Return strategy targets a return of 4.5% above inflation on a rolling five-year basis. The team invests in equities and bonds across both developed and emerging markets; but they are permitted to invest in commodities, currencies, and cross-asset relative value trades. The asset class ranges are very wide, so the beta to equities and fixed income can oscillate wildly.

  • Pendal’s approach uses two internally managed strategies: the Pendal Total Return Fund (16270) and the Pendal Multi-Asset Target Return Fund (42877). The former includes an AQR market-neutral hedge fund, a risk parity fund, and an alternative-risk premia fund, among others. The component strategies are given a long leash and often have volatility targets of 10% or more. The latter is a lower-risk fund designed for retirees that invests across equity, fixed income, commodities, and currencies. The portfolio is designed to have low-equity sensitivity to provide diversification benefits in a traditional portfolio.

  • Perpetual allocates to the Perpetual Diversified Real Return Fund, which targets a return of Consumer Price Index plus 5%. There are wide allowable ranges and the team can invest across equities, fixed income, commodities, FX, and unlisted property and infrastructure. Options are used to manage currency risk and to alter other exposures in the portfolio. The team does avoid private equity and illiquid hedge fund strategies.

  • MLC allocates a portion to third-party managers investing in catastrophe bonds. These instruments are insurance against natural disasters. They also use a Low Correlation Strategy that invest in specialist managers investing in government receivables, municipal bonds, relative value metals, and a range of other hedge fund programmes.

Industry funds are playing a slightly different game. These behemoths are able to access an illiquidity premium. That is, the additional return an investor should earn if the asset isn’t readily tradable. The industry funds can take advantage of the largely predictable inflows from generally younger members and the long-term nature of their liabilities. The three industry funds under our coverage (AustralianSuper, CBUS, and Sunsuper) all have meaningfully higher unlisted allocations than their non-industry fund peers.

The majority of AustralianSuper’s alternative portfolio is in direct investments in shopping malls, office buildings, industrial assets, toll roads, airports, seaports, and utilities. There is a smaller allocation to high-yield bonds, bank loans, and private equity. Similarly, CBUS has investments in property, with a notable domestic skew. This is hardly surprising given the occupation of its members.

However, CBUS does have more geographic diversity on the unlisted infrastructure portion of the portfolio. Similarly, Sunsuper has unlisted property and infrastructure exposure. They also have meaningful positions in a range of hedge fund and specialist alternative managers, including macro-hedge funds and event-driven managers.

It’s important to note that the strategies and securities discussed above is not an exhaustive list. We’ve also seen commodities, alternative-risk premia, long volatility, absolute return fixed income, and structured credit alongside the more vanilla stocks, government bonds, and investment-grade credit. In our view, this is a dizzying list of complex assets, and it’s important to understand whether multi-asset investment teams have the requisite skills and experience if they are increasingly venturing into these more complicated assets. It’s particularly important for those groups investing directly, not through third- party managers. The internal teams might be able to rely on an array of asset consultants with specialist knowledge, but the final decision rests with them.

The short-term results

Historically, many multi-asset managers have been highly conscious of their peer-relative performance. In fact, part of their processes often involves an analysis of how their competitors are positioned. It is unsurprising, therefore, that the long-term return outcomes have been quite similar among the peer group. As more managers introduce alternative allocations to their portfolios, we think the outcomes could diverge.

As shown below, CFS Wholesale Diversified and Pendal Active Balance have seen a notable difference in performance. This spread is partly attributable to the results of their alternative programmes. CFS’ Real Return Fund was a stellar performer, delivering 15% for 2019. Pendal’s Total Return strategy disappointed, as its allocation to the troubled AQR hurt.

One-year performance of Morningstar multisector funds with allocations to alternative investments

Name Return 2019-01-01 to 2019-12-31 AUD Morningstar Category
Diversified Funds    
Advance Balanced Multi-Blend W 18.54 Australia Fund Multisector Growth
CFS Wholesale Balanced 13.43 Australia Fund Multisector Balanced
MLC Wholesale Horizon 4 Balanced 16.45 Australia Fund Multisector Growth
Pendal Active Balanced 14.73 Australia Fund Multisector Growth
Perpetual Wholesale Balanced Growth 13.00 Australia Fund Multisector Growth
Russell Balanced A 15.88 Australia Fund Multisector Growth
Industry Funds    
AustralianSuper Conservative Balanced 13.16 Australia Superannuation Multisector Growth
CBUS Super Growth (MySuper) 15.07 Australia Superannuation Multisector Aggressive
Sunsuper Balanced 15.51 Australia Superannuation Multisector Aggressive
Real Return Funds    
CFS Multi-Asset Real Return - Class A
14.95 Australia Fund Multisector Flexible
Pendal Multi-Asset Target Return 3.78 Australia Fund Multisector Flexible
Pendal Total Return -1.90 Australia Fund Alternative Strategies Diversified
Perpetual Diversified Real Return W 7.35 Australia Fund Multisector Flexible

Investors should not overreact to short-term performance. However, the above example does highlight how the results can diverge due to different allocations to alternative assets. We’d urge investors to spend time assessing whether the multi-asset team responsible for their diversified funds have the requisite skills and experience to incorporate more-complicated assets to the strategic asset allocation.

We’d also recommend investors be vigilant about the risks these more esoteric assets bring. Traditional risk metrics, like standard deviation, aren’t particularly good at identifying the risks in less liquid assets with infrequent, and often opaque, pricing.

 

Simon Scott is an Associate Director, Multi-Asset & Alternative Strategies at Morningstar Australasia. For full reports on managed funds in all asset classes and a wide range of listed stocks, subscribe to Morninstar Premium. Morningstar has compiled a list of more than 150 companies that release earnings results during February 2020 Reporting Season. 


Try Morningstar Premium for free


 

3 Comments
Jerome Lander
February 23, 2020

Indeed, many of the so called alternatives are not genuine alternatives providing true diversification from the main risks that traditional asset classes are exposed to. Few multi-asset funds are actually willing to be genuinely different from one another as herding and peers drive asset allocations, rather than client goals. Indeed, the managed accounts and funds I am PM for appear to be most different - and most diversifying - from the industry alternatives we have examined. Most r managers will predictably fall heavily with the markets given their heavy reliance on traditional risks and unwillingness to be truly different or move their asset allocation around substantively.

Carlos
February 20, 2020

I find it ridiculous that property or infrastructure ( whether unlisted or listed ) would be considered "alternative" assets. there is nothing alternative about owning property, which is really a core investment for most people.
for me, alternative investments include long/short equity funds, market neutral equity funds, private equity & debt,
commodities including precious metals, and managed futures funds ( hedge funds ).
I am comfortable with a 10% allocation to a range of these alternatives.

Chris
February 24, 2020

Which is why (source: Roger Montgomery.com, Money News 20 February 2020 at 1:17) we have the current situation where the Harvard Endowment Fund = 40% in private equity and Australian Future Fund = 16% in private equity, because there's nowhere else to put this money, so they're chasing higher risks for a what they think will be a good return. Hopefully.

I don't think it will end well, especially considering that according to Miles Staude's article, 74% of the IPOs that came to market during the year were for loss-making businesses.

 

Leave a Comment:

     

RELATED ARTICLES

When good defensive investments go bad

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Stop treating the family home as a retirement sacred cow

The way home ownership relates to retirement income is rated a 'D', as in Distortion, Decumulation and Denial. For many, their home is their largest asset but it's least likely to be used for retirement income.

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 433 with weekend update

There’s this story about a group of US Air Force generals in World War II who try to figure out ways to protect fighter bombers (and their crew) by examining the location of bullet holes on returning planes. Mapping the location of these holes, the generals quickly come to the conclusion that the areas with the most holes should be prioritised for additional armour.

  • 11 November 2021

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 431 with weekend update

House prices have risen at the fastest pace for 33 years, but what actually happened in 1988, and why is 2021 different? Here's a clue: the stockmarket crashed 50% between September and November 1987. Looking ahead, where did house prices head in the following years, 1989 to 1991?

  • 28 October 2021

Why has Australia slipped down the global super ranks?

Australia appears to be slipping from the pantheon of global superstar pension systems, with a recent report placing us sixth. A review of an earlier report, which had Australia in bronze position, points to some reasons why, and what might need to happen to regain our former glory.

How to help people with retirement spending decisions

Super funds will soon be required to offer retirement income strategies for members in decumulation. With uncertain returns, uncertain timelines, and different goals, it's possibly “the hardest, nastiest problem in finance".

Tips when taking large withdrawals from super

You want to take a lump sum from your super, but what's the best way? Should it come from you or your spouse, or the pension or accumulation account. There is a welcome flexibility to select the best outcome.

Latest Updates

Investment strategies

Charlie Munger and stock picks at the Sohn Conference

The Sohn Australia Conference brings together leading fund managers to chose their highest conviction stock in a 10-minute pitch. Here are their 2021 selections with Charlie Munger's wisdom as the star feature.

Interviews

John Woods on diversification using asset allocation

All fund managers now claim to take ESG factors into account, but a multi-asset ethical fund will look quite different from a mainstream fund. Faced with low fixed income returns, alternatives have a bigger role.

SMSF strategies

Don't believe the SMSF statistics on investment allocation

The ATO's data on SMSF asset allocation is as much as 27 months out-of-date and categories such as cash and global investments are reported incorrectly. We should question the motives of some who quote the numbers.

Investment strategies

Highlights of reader tips for young investors

In this second part on the reader responses with advice to younger people, we have selected a dozen highlights, but there are so many quality contributions that a full list of comments is also attached.

Investment strategies

Four climate themes offer investors the next big thing

Climate-related companies will experience exponential growth driven by consumer demand and government action. Investors who identify the right companies will benefit from four themes which will last decades.

Investment strategies

Inflation remains transitory due to strong long-term trends

There is momentum to stop calling inflation 'transitory' but this overlooks deep-seated trends. A longer-term view will see companies like ARB, Reece, Macquarie Telecom and CSL more valuable in a decade.

Infrastructure

Infrastructure and the road to recovery

Infrastructure assets experienced varying fortunes during the pandemic, from less travel at airports to strong activity in communications. On the road to recovery, what role does infrastructure play in a portfolio?

Economy

The three prices that everyone should worry about

Among the myriad of numbers that bombard us every day, three prices matter greatly to the world economy. Recent changes in these prices help to understand the potential for a global recovery and interest rates.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2021 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. Any general advice or ‘regulated financial advice’ under New Zealand law has been prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide (AU) and Financial Advice Provider Disclosure Statement (NZ). You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.

Website Development by Master Publisher.