Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 149

Why SMSFs should have a corporate trustee

Did you know that 78% of SMSFs are set up with individual trustees but that over 90% of professional advisers I have canvassed would always recommend a Sole Purpose Company trustee? In the haste to set up funds, most people miss this vital step with many having to pay high fees to change trustee later.

The issue is worsening as in the three years to 2015, there was a 4% decline in SMSFs registering with a corporate trustee. Of newly registered SMSFs in 2015, an incredible 95% had individual trustees (see: ATO Self-managed super fund statistical report – June 2015 appendix 1, table 6)

LS Table6

LS Table6

I believe it is essential to have a company as trustee and that the option to have individual trustees is short-sighted.

Benefits of a corporate trustee

A corporate trustee facilitates:

  • Time to grieve or adapt. The strongest reason from 10 years’ experience with SMSFs is respect for your spouse or family’s needs in times of grief. Do you really want to leave them an awkward and expensive set of tasks to carry out just to save $700?
  • Continuous succession. A company has an indefinite life span; it does not die. A corporate trustee can ensure control of an SMSF is more certain following the death or mental or physical incapacity of a member.
  • Administrative efficiency. When members are admitted to, or cease, membership of the SMSF, all that is required is that the person becomes, or ceases to be, a director of the corporate trustee. The corporate trustee does not change as a result. Therefore, title to all the assets of the SMSF remains in the name of the corporate trustee, especially useful when dealing with property in an SMSF.
  • Sole member SMSF. An SMSF can have one individual as both the sole member and the sole director. Likewise, if a spouse is incapacitated, then the husband or wife can act as director under an enduring Power of Attorney to run the fund on their own without the need for interference by others.
  • Meets lenders’ requirements. Most lenders require a corporate trustee in the SMSF as it is easier to deal with.
  • Higher Loan to Valuation Ratios accepted. With a corporate trustee, many lenders will go to 80% on residential loans and 70% on commercial real estate.
  • Greater asset protection. As companies are subject to limited liability, a corporate trustee will provide improved protection for the directors where a party sues the trustee for damages. I use an electrician as an example here when I discuss this with clients. If he is on your property and is electrocuted because of the owner’s (SMSF) negligence, then the SMSF may be sued but your own personal liability is limited to your shareholding and member balance rather than your entire wealth

Problems with individual trustees

Individual trustees cause issues with:

  • Paperwork at the worst time. Welcome to a nightmare. When a spouse has barely had time to start grieving, they need to manage the SMSF and administer pensions, investments and deeds. Minutes to record death of trustee, deed update to add a new trustee or move to a corporate trustee, off-market transfer forms and identity forms and probate forms to put every investment in correct name(s). Worse still, deal with the Land & Property Management agency or Office of State Revenue and their endless forms!
  • Complexities relating to death. If the SMSF has individual trustees, e.g. a husband and wife, then timely action must be taken on the death of a member to ensure the trustee and member rules are adhered to properly. For example, SMSF rules do not allow a sole individual trustee/member SMSF.
  • Extra and costly administration. To bring in a new member to an SMSF with individual trustees requires that person to become a trustee. As trust assets must be held in the names of the trustees, the title to all assets must be transferred to the new trustees.
  • Sole member SMSF. A sole member SMSF must have two individual trustees. Does a spouse need to rely on the children, possibly from the first marriage? That’s really not going to work as we know what a problem blended families are when it comes to estate planning.
  • Tighter lending rules. Lower LVRs are common, due to legal concerns, lenders restrict the maximum borrowing of an SMSF with individual trustees to 70% for residential properties and 55-60% for commercial real estate.
  • Less asset protection. If an individual trustee suffers any liability, the trustee’s personal assets may be exposed. The trustee as well as the SMSF may be sued by someone doing work for the SMSF.

What do the ATO and ASIC think?

The Australian Securities & Investments Commission (ASIC) and the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) prefer corporate trustees. Last year, ASIC released a number of documents which outlined the advantages of an SMSF corporate trustee.

More recently, the ATO released an article and video on SMSFs titled Choose individual trustees or a corporate trustee that objectively outlines the pros and cons.

And even more advantages of a corporate trustee

With a bit of preparation and planning, combining your will and enduring powers of attorney, minuted resolutions and if needed clauses written into the deed, a person (usually the Executor or Legal Personal Representative) can be immediately appointed as a director so that the fund can continue to operate in the event of death regardless of whether a death certificate or probate have been granted.

Likewise, a person who loses mental capacity needs to be replaced if they were individual trustees. With a company, the constitution can immediately have a mechanism which allows the person holding the enduring power of attorney to be appointed as a replacement director, resigning the incapacitated director at the same time.

Under ASIC’s new administrative penalties, if a fine is made in relation to an SMSF that has individual trustees, then each trustee will be fined in their personal capacity. The fine is personally payable and cannot be reimbursed by the fund. Only one fine is payable by a corporate trustee.

It is also easy for Superannuation Industry Supervision (SIS) regulation 4.09A(2)(a) to be contravened by an individual trustee. It says:

“A trustee of a regulated superannuation fund that is a self-managed superannuation fund must keep the money and other assets of the fund separate from any money and assets, respectively: … (a) that are held by the trustee personally …”

For example, if individual trustees receive rental property income or a dividend into a personal account in their own names instead of an account in their personal names but with the account designation of their SMSF, it is a contravention. With a corporate trustee, it’s far less likely to mix fund assets with personal assets.

Summary

It’s difficult to believe that 90% of SMSFs are currently being established with individual trustees. Even if some costs of registering a company are initially avoided, the trustees are almost certainly inviting complications later in the life of the SMSF.

 

Liam Shorte is a specialist SMSF advisor and Director of Verante Financial Planning. This article contains general information only and does not address the circumstances of any individual. Professional personal financial advice should be sought before taking action.

6 Comments
Jonathan Hoyle
April 03, 2016

Well argued, Liam. A Corporate Trustee is nearly always the preferable option.

Randall Kingsley
April 01, 2016

Thanks for quite a good article, even if I disagree with the notion. Might be a tad aspirational but we have opted to have the maximum allowed four trustees in our smsf-two in retirement now and two in the 30s and building their super. Our hope is that our smsf will become almost perpetual and as hand the running off to the next generations. Almost like the now defunct idea put forward by our poor PM who is trying to get our leaders to take on more financial responsibilities. And after 12 years or so we are working well, I only wish we were allowed more trustees!

Liam Shorte
April 02, 2016

Randall, there are always exceptions to a rule. Hopefully your family will continue to benefit from your obvious good guidance to take super serious from an early age.

Wife about to win an argument..again!
April 01, 2016

Thank you, thank you, thank you. I have been arguing with my husband about this for a few years now and this is the best laid out set of reasons for moving to a corporate trustee I have seen. I am sure that my beloved hubby is just delaying because he is miserly and thinks he will pass away first and I can deal with the paperwork...like I do for everything else in our business.

Liam Shorte
April 02, 2016

Glad I could help you. Remember you can get a discount on the annual ASIC review fee for the Corporate trustee by paying up to ten years in advance at today's rate.

SMSF admin
March 31, 2016

These numbers are a mystery. I spoke to a few online providers and they say the stats don’t reflect their business which is about 80% corporate trustee. Everyone is perplexed about who is actually opening those individual trustee funds.

 

Leave a Comment:

     

RELATED ARTICLES

SMSFs and the control over estate planning

Importance of updating your SMSF Trust Deed

Every SMSF trustee should have an Enduring Power of Attorney

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

24 hot stocks and funds for 2021

Many investors use the new year to review their portfolios, and in this free ebook, two dozen fund managers and product providers give their best ideas for 2021 - some stocks, some funds, some sectors.

Great new ways the Government helps retirees

Last year's retiree checklist of services available was one of our most popular articles. There are some additions for 2021, and while it can take effort to set them up, they can pay off over the long term.

The hazards of asset allocation in a late-stage major bubble

The Grantham article everyone is quoting, in full. "The long, long bull market since 2009 has finally matured into a fully-fledged epic bubble ... this could very well be the most important event of your investing lives."

Four simple strategies deliver long-term investing comfort

A long-time advocate of the merits of generating income by investing in industrial companies rather than bonds or deposits checks his 'mothership' chart for the latest results, and continues to feel vindicated.

Cut it out ... millionaires are not wealthy

The widespread use of 'millionaire' must stop. Inflation means that the basket of goods and services that cost $1 million in 1960 now requires $15 million. Today, millionaires are not wealthy.

Retirement changes everything: a post-retirement investing framework

Categorising post-retirement needs – living, lifestyle, legacy and contingency – creates a framework for retirees. Advisers can translate these needs into investment goals and portfolios.

Latest Updates

Investment strategies

Unfortunately, all fund manager presentations are good

Part of the fund manager's job is to raise money from investors, and with years of practice, a few good stock stories and an educated guess on the future, it's not hard to present well. That's a problem for investors.

Latest from Morningstar

Win some, lose some: Buffett's 2020 scorecard

Warren Buffett's investment portfolio gains attention because of his legendary status, but parts of his empire in insurance, railways, metalworking and aircraft suppliers have been damaged by the pandemic.

Shares

Prefer or defer? Sector and investment themes for 2021

It's time for equity prices to more closely tie to a company’s underlying near-term earnings trajectory and financial strength. Despite the market trading at record levels, some stocks have been left behind.

Retirement

Is cancelling the SG increase a retiree version of ‘Buy now, pay later’?

No doubt, any reduction or deferral in the SG increase would be received favourably by many. However, early access and lower contributions undermine the foundation of our super system.

Three ways to match housing affordability with good returns

This increased focus on affordable housing is welcome but the challenge is that investors typically require ‘market’ rate financial returns. By definition, social housing tenants cannot pay market rent.

Investment strategies

Investors face their own Breaking Bad moment

Savers are making small decision after small decision that leads them away from investing and closer to outright speculating. Time will tell if this ends in a bloody climax or we all live happily ever after.

Shares

Australian banks prove resilient but risks remain

Australian major banks reported a decline in financial performance in 2020 but as the impact of the pandemic evolves, the banks maintained a strong focus on customers. Is the renewed market optimism justified?

  • KPMG
  • 1 January 2020

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2021 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use.
Any general advice or class service prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, has been prepared by without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. Refer to our Financial Services Guide (FSG) for more information. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.

Website Development by Master Publisher.