Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 44

Super funds need a member engagement makeover

For superannuation funds, members are their reason for being. Attracting new members and retaining existing ones is critical to their survival, especially in this world of continual change. The top priority on all superannuation funds’ lists is improving member engagement. But what does this mean and where do funds start?

Let’s begin by looking at the ways funds have traditionally engaged with their members and the challenges associated with these methods.

Correspondence filed away, web sites ignored

Legally, superannuation funds are required to inform their members of their balances and changes to the fund at certain times in writing. So members receive annual statements and other occasional correspondence from their funds.

However, disengaged members are likely to not even read their annual statements. Instead, they simply file them away until they are about to retire and want access to this money.

Over recent years, we have seen funds begin using their websites to correspond with members in a faster manner than by mail. But if a member is not engaged, why would they be looking at this website? Conversely, if a member actually does visit the fund’s website, how often is it refreshed with the type of information the member is looking for?

Lost call centre opportunity

For years, many superannuation funds have been outsourcing their call centre functions. Although funds have monitoring processes in place to listen to what their members are being told, this is usually done merely from a compliance perspective rather than from an engagement point of view.

When a member calls the fund to rollover their money to another fund for example, the call centre operator is obliged to follow member instructions in order to satisfy the member and all compliance obligations. While this results in a ‘pleasant transaction’ – the member gets what they wanted and the call centre meets its service level standards – the fund loses a member. In most cases, even if funds train call centre staff to use prescribed wording to encourage members to stay, by the time a member gets to this stage it is usually too late to change their mind.

Inadequate member surveys

Member surveys have been used by the superannuation industry for years. If the majority of survey respondents are satisfied and the fund’s targets have been met that is an excellent result, right? Wrong! Have the funds looked more closely at the members that are not satisfied or the members that have not responded at all, to understand the causes of dissatisfaction non-response and try to address the underlying issues?

Enquiries and complaints

Legally an enquiries and complaints mechanism is required for all Australian superannuation funds. As long as funds respond to any issues raised within the required timeframe, this is viewed as an excellent result. But what do funds do with the knowledge they have gained from these enquiries and complaints? How can they use the information to help them understand what members do or don’t want from the fund?

It’s clear the existing communication channels and frameworks need to be revisited if superannuation funds want to increase member engagement and retention levels. So now let’s examine some of the key areas that funds should consider as part of their overall member engagement strategies.

End outsourcing

In many cases, call centres remain a member’s main touch point with their superannuation fund. Having control of this channel is vital. Funds need to take back ownership of their members, not leave this important role in the hands of an outsourced service provider. 

Digital innovation

Funds have digital ambitions. There is no doubt that innovation in digital technology has transformed the world and is dramatically altering customer experiences across all sectors of the economy. Australians are enthusiastic adopters of digital and mobile technologies, so funds need to get on board this trend, and fast. However, this is easier said than done and, for funds to ride this wave of change, there are a number of factors they need to consider.

Firstly, there is the issue of technology investment. Funds need to look at whether their current infrastructure supports their digital ambitions. How easy will it be to design or develop the required infrastructure? For some it may be easier than others. Important areas to consider during the planning stage include the use of outsourced service providers, the cost to design and implement, and allowing flexibility for future changes. In the digital space, what is relevant today may not be tomorrow.

The second area that needs focus is organisational structure. Will the fund’s current organisational structure support its digital ambitions? Does the fund have people with the right skills to design, deliver and promote their digital strategy?

Make better use of social media and web sites

Social media is a relatively inexpensive marketing and customer communication tool. It’s an influential medium, particularly for digital savvy younger consumers. While some funds have started to incorporate social media elements into their member engagement toolkit, success to date has been minimal. The question that funds need to ask themselves is whether they have developed a robust social media strategy based on specific, measurable goals.

Having an engaging online presence is not about putting hard copy documents on your website. It’s about giving members meaningful information and allowing them to interact with it.

Funds need to make their websites more engaging. If members are leaving their superannuation management in the fund’s hands, it’s because they don’t want to think about it. They want funds to make the hard decisions and deliver the information they need to know – in simple terms. So funds need to consider not just whether their website has the content members want, but also how easy it is to access and use. Can customers complete forms and get questions to their answers directly from the website?

How can funds make their websites interactive and fun, so members want to go back for more? Photos and videos attract a more engaged online user. And what about gaming? The rise of smartphones means online games and apps are becoming increasingly popular and mainstream, not just the domain of Gen Y and the digital generation.

Building trust is the key

While improving channels and methods of customer engagement is important, doing so is meaningless unless one very important thing is achieved: trust.

The global financial crisis meant many members lost faith in the superannuation system. The talk of negative double digit returns was something members were not used to and, as a result, the rise of an ‘I can do better than you’ mentality has seen an increasing number of members switching to SMSFs.

People are increasingly looking to alternative channels, such as advice from friends and their family accountant, for financial decision-making, because these are channels they trust.

In this environment, implementing new means for members to keep in touch with their funds will not make a difference unless funds are prepared to analyse the results and learn from these, in order to build a trusted relationship.

Funds are already engaging with their members via emails, enquiries, complaints, and website visits. Developing a strategy to better analyse the information available through these interactions – and being willing to act on the findings – may be the starting point funds need when it comes to increasing member engagement.

Maree Pallisco is the national superannuation leader for Ernst & Young Australia.

The views expressed in this article are the views of the author, not Ernst & Young. The article provides general information, does not constitute advice and should not be relied on as such. Professional advice should be sought prior to any action being taken in reliance on any of the information. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.


December 13, 2013

I think the first issue is, what does member engagement mean? It seems to be used as a catch all phrase and a motherhood phrase for all sorts of solutions about member issues. Is member engagement increasing: brand awareness; the prevention of losing members; encouraging members to interact more with the fund and their investment; or member education. And if any of those in particular (or all), what are the outcomes and will they be beneficial.

You could argue that encouraging member engagement in the form of member interaction with their investment could have negative externalities. Surveys show that people over estimate their financial ability/literacy, and member engagement to encourage take up control of investments could lead to negative investment outcomes as members make sub-optimal decisions.

Funds are losing members to SMSF space, member engagement via social media doesn’t change that. They’re leaving primarily to control their assets, not because their fund doesn’t tweet to them enough. Or they die (nothing can help that!) or they retire and take a lump sum.

While social media is an influential medium for consumers, I think it’s a little disingenuous to liken super fund members to consumers. They’re very different beasts.

That being said, I think member engagement is important, and social media strategies are important; but we cannot sit here and use catch all phrases and talk about the benefits of social media, without being able to articulate what they mean, and what the desired outcomes are.


Leave a Comment:


Most viewed in recent weeks

Are you caught in the ‘retirement trap’?

Our retirement savings system is supposed to encourage financial independence but there is a ‘Retirement Trap’ due to the reduction of age pension entitlements as assets and income rise.

The power of letting winners run

Handling extreme winners is a complex task. Conventional wisdom such as “you never go broke taking a profit” often leaves a lot of money on the table as strong growth stocks continue to run.

Tony Togher on why cash isn’t just cash

An active manager of cash and fixed interest funds can achieve higher returns than the cash rate through a selection of other securities while managing both liquidity and income for clients.

NAB hybrid: one says buy, one says sell, you decide

Differences of opinion make a market, and hybrid specialists disagree on the likelihood that NAB will call one of its hybrids early. It makes a major difference to the expected return on NABHA.

Watch your SMSF’s annual return this year

The best way to preserve your SMSF’s favoured status is to make sure the fund’s annual return reaches the ATO on time. There are new rules this year that every SMSF trustee should know.

Worshipping at the altar of alternative assets

Investors worried about an overvalued sharemarket and low interest rates on term deposits and bonds are focusing on alternatives. What are they and how are they used by leading asset allocators?

Latest Updates


Kunal Kapoor on different paths to investor success

The Morningstar CEO on democratising investing, why saving in your youth is crucial, and why most investors care more about paying off their debts than comparing their results against benchmarks.

Investment strategies

Do sin stocks really give your portfolio the edge?

Should sin stocks, those companies who engage in activities that are considered unethical or immoral, be excluded from a portfolio, or would this compromise potential performance?


What is the likely effect of COVID-19 on the Australian economy?

Our close links to China mean the impact of the virus could tip the local economy into recession and certain sectors such as resources, education and travel will be harder hit than others.


Poor pricing of life insurance products and the impact on Australians

The use of discounted pricing by insurers to attract new business is unsustainable and leaves existing policyholders on higher premiums for what is essentially the same product.


Spotting signs of trouble in a retirement portfolio

Do you risk paying a lot of tax in accumulation phase? Or, if you're in retirement phase, do you face the risk of outliving your asset pool? Two key things to consider in the low-rate world of today.