Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 354

Magellan versus Platinum: which offers a less bumpy ride?

Following the COVID-19 outbreak, equity markets are likely to remain volatile over the near term unless there are clear signs that the virus is successfully contained on a global scale and economic stimuluses are effective in limiting the severity of a global downturn.

Morningstar's assessment of two leading Aussie global managers

Revenue will be under pressure for asset managers Magellan Financial Group (ASX:MFG) and Platinum Asset Management (ASX:PTM), which derive fee revenue from managing global equity portfolios. This includes base management fees that should reduce on the lower value of assets under management and performance fees that are likely to fall sharply.

Our 'narrow moat', 'medium fair value' uncertainty, and 'Standard stewardship' ratings are unchanged as we transition coverage of both Magellan and Platinum to a new analyst.

Factoring in volatile markets and an economic downturn, we have lowered our near-term funds under management, or FUM, and earnings forecasts for both firms. However, we've increased our outer-year projections on returns and inflows, corresponding with an expected recovery in equity markets and renewed confidence in established active managers like Magellan and Platinum, which should remain resilient in the aftermath of the pandemic.

Following our earnings revisions, our fair value estimate for Magellan remains at $52.00 per share, while our valuation for Platinum is reduced to $3.60 per share from $4.35 previously.

Magellan's unmatched inflows in recent years

In our view, Magellan's solid track record should allow it to attract and retain FUM through the bear market, while it's well placed to recover with equity markets. Conversely, Platinum is likely to see further net outflows from a combination of its historical underperformance and potential risk-aversion toward emerging market stocks (to which it has a sizable exposure).

Both firms possess the necessary brand strength, investment strategy, and distribution reach to navigate through the current downturn and to continue to attract inflows longer term.

However, we think Magellan has a competitive edge over Platinum and should recover faster, in particular given Magellan's strong track record of outperformance. Together with its strong distribution reach and active client engagements, we expect it to be successful in generating inflows over time. Platinum is likely to suffer near-term outflows due to its prolonged underperformance, but inflows should resume over the longer term as investors see the merits of its absolute-return focused strategy and downside protection capabilities, which should outperform amid current volatile markets.

We forecast Magellan to grow earnings per share, or EPS, at about 11.5% per year through to fiscal 2024, and a slower 2.5% per year over the same period for Platinum. Volatile equity markets should weigh on near-term market returns, and we forecast low-single-digit returns for Magellan and a slight loss for Platinum's for fiscal 2020. However, markets should recover over time and support higher investment returns in future. Accordingly, we see market returns growing at about 11% per year for Magellan and 8% per year for Platinum, from fiscal 2021 to fiscal 2024. We expect Magellan to continue attracting net inflows despite near-term volatility, while Platinum should experience further net outflows through to fiscal 2021, before seeing net inflows thereafter. We also forecast management fee margins for both to further compress by about 2 basis points by fiscal 2024.

Accordingly, we project Magellan to grow average FUM at a rate of 14% per year (from fiscal 2019) to about $147 billion by fiscal 2024, while Platinum should grow FUM at a more modest rate of around 2.5% per year to about $28 billion over the same period. In deriving our view, we have compared both firms based on their respective performances, investment styles, and distribution reach.

Magellan's superior history of outperformance stands out. Its core Global Equities and Infrastructure strategies have materially outperformed their benchmarks since inception as well as over a 1-, 3-, 5-, 7-, and 10-year time frame. As a result, Magellan's record of inflows is unmatched in the Australian market. In the five-and-a-half years to 30 December 2019, FUM grew at nearly 30% compound a year to more than quadruple. There have only been three months with a net client outflows.

On the flip side, Platinum's earnings have been hamstrung by the prolonged underperformance of its core International and Asian strategies. As a result, both FUM ($24.8 billion) and management fees ($295.2 million) in fiscal 2019 remain below their fiscal 2015 levels ($26.9 billion and $338.6 million, respectively).

Two leading names with different investment techniques

The disparity in both firms' track records can be explained by their varying investment approaches. Magellan has a sizable exposure to developed markets with a tilt toward large caps, while also exposed to growth-orientated technology stocks such as Facebook, Alphabet, and Alibaba. Magellan's performance has been strengthened by exposure to high-quality growth thematics. We also think large, developed-market stocks are better placed to recover from the current downturn, relative to small-cap or emerging market securities. Accordingly, while we have lowered our market return forecasts to around 3.5% (from 12.5% previously) for fiscal 2020, our return forecasts for the subsequent four years to fiscal 2024 are increased to around 11% per year (previously 8%). We do not expect Magellan to experience any net outflows throughout our forecast period, but inflows should grow slower than historically at about 5% per year over the next five years given its larger starting size.

On the flip side, Platinum's benchmark-agnostic approach has led to a much higher exposure to developing markets, relative to the MSCI World Index. Both low interest rates and trade tensions were unsupportive of its investment style. However, we believe its focus on absolute returns and strong downside protection capabilities should allow it to perform well amid current volatile markets. We've revised our market return forecasts to average 6.5% per year over the next five years, from 9.5% previously. We project net outflows of about 11% per year through to fiscal 2021 but expect net inflows of about 8% annually from fiscal 2022 onward, as investors gradually gain confidence in Platinum's distinct approach.

Compared with Platinum, we think that Magellan possesses a stronger distribution reach and greater client engagement, which helps with driving growth and building a stickier FUM base. While domiciled in Australia, it derives the majority of its FUM from a diverse range of internationally based institutional clients. Magellan's client-centric image has also assisted with generating new FUM, as evidenced by the successful raising of an additional $862 million (around 3% of its total retail FUM) for the newly listed Magellan High Conviction Trust.

Conversely, Platinum continues to source FUM mainly from domestic retail investors. It has, however, recently made moves to promote its products to U.S. and Canadian institutional investors. Given the small proportion of institutional money at present, we do not forecast foreign or institutional investors to account for a large percentage of total FUM throughout our forecast period.

There is much uncertainty over the immediate future, but the longer-term dynamics are favourable for both firms. Volatility is likely to remain elevated in the near term as it's difficult to deduce the exact repercussions from the pandemic; with poor business conditions and increasing unemployment being counteracted by tranches of fiscal stimulus and monetary easing designed to prevent a financial crisis. But recent market declines should mean future investment returns improve.

We look to news of (1) a globally scalable vaccine and (2) a successful containment of the virus to improve investor confidence and underpin an improvement in equity markets. Interest rates are likely to remain lower for longer, helping to buoy stock valuations and cushion the impact from the economic and consumer downturn. Australia's ageing demographics, the traditional underweight of Australian investors to international stocks, and the growing superannuation system should also expand demand for global equities products offered by both Magellan and Platinum.


Adam Fleck is Regional Director of Equity Research, Australia and NZ, at Morningstar Australasia. This article is general information and does not consider the circumstances of any investor. Please consult a financial adviser before taking investment decisions.

Morningstar Premium gives investors access to analyst ratings on hundreds of Australian and overseas companies, as well as a broad range of research material.



It’s the large stocks driving fund misery

Investment newsletters: making sense of stock recommendations


Most viewed in recent weeks

Who's next? Discounts on LICs force managers to pivot

The boards and managers of six high-profile LICs, frustrated by their shares trading at large discounts to asset value, have embarked on radical strategies to fix the problems. Will they work?

Four simple things to do right now

Markets have recovered in the last six months but most investors remain nervous about the economic outlook. Morningstar analysts provide four quick tips on how to navigate this uncertainty.

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 374

Suddenly, it's the middle of September and we don't hear much about 'snap back' anymore. Now we have 'wind backs' and 'road maps'. Six months ago, I was flying back from Antarctica after two weeks aboard the ill-fated Greg Mortimer cruise ship, and then the world changed. So it's time to take your temperature again. Our survey checks your reaction to recent policies and your COVID-19 responses.

  • 9 September 2020

Reporting season winners and losers in listed property trusts

Many property trust results are better than expected, with the A-REIT sector on a dividend yield of 4.8%. But there's a wide variation by sector and the ability of tenants to pay the rent.

Have stock markets become a giant Ponzi scheme?

A global financial casino has been created where investors ignore realistic valuations in the low growth, high-risk environment. At some point, analysis of fundamental value will be rewarded.

Every SMSF trustee should have an Enduring Power of Attorney

COVID-19 and the events of 2020 show why, more than ever, SMSF trustees need to prepare for the ‘unexpected’ by having an Enduring Power of Attorney in place. A Power of Attorney is not enough.

Latest Updates

Weekly Editorial

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 376

The US tech index, the NASDAQ, peaked on 2 September 2020 at 12,058 and closed three weeks later at 10,793. On the same days, Apple hit US$137.98 and then fell to US$110.08. These falls of 10% and 20% seem high but both were simply returning to their early August levels. It's hardly a rout when a month's gains are given back. The bigger issue is whether such a stock correction will scare off the retail 'Robinhood' traders.

  • 24 September 2020

Interview Series: What’s new in a global innovation fund?

For many global tech companies, COVID has boosted their revenues and pushed share prices to all-time highs. We are on the cusp of amazing technical advances and there are plenty of new opportunities.


Five reasons why Tesla is the everything bubble embodied

As fewer professionals actively research the merits of a company’s prospects, stocks become disproportionately driven by capital flows. Prices disconnect from fundamentals and there's no better example than Tesla.


Three retirement checks for when you have enough

Not every retiree needs to gun for higher returns, but a conservative portfolio can court its own risks, especially with bond rates so low. But some retirees prefer to settle for a lower income.


Hide and seek: the FX impact on global equity investments

As more Australians tilt their investments to global equities, they often overlook the exchange rate risk and fees. The move from US57 cents to US73 cents in six months shows the unhedged impact.


When America sneezes, the world catches a ...

The recovery from COVID-19 is looking more like a K-shape, with some companies doing well while others struggle. The pandemic seems more akin to a black swan, exogenous shock than a structural downturn.


How the age pension helps retirees cope with losses

It's often overlooked how wealthier couples can fall back on the age pension if a market loss hits their portfolio. The reassurance is never greater than in a financial (and now epidemic) crisis.



© 2020 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use.
Any general advice or class service prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, has been prepared by without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. Refer to our Financial Services Guide (FSG) for more information. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.