Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 678

The investing rule that explains the next market crash

Many investors think of the share market as a multiple-choice test with just two answers. An investment is either good or bad. Find the good investments and you get rewarded.

In reality investing is a multiplayer game. The people you are playing against matter in the outcome you achieve.

A company’s future earnings matter, but how they compare with everyone else’s expectations matters. A wonderful business can produce disappointing investment returns if priced for perfection. Conversely, a mediocre company can generate excellent returns if expectations were excessively pessimistic.

I try to explain this to friends of mine who have received company shares as part of their remuneration package. They tell me about their companies’ strong earnings and growth but can’t figure out why the share price is stagnant.

Investing isn’t a mathematical formula. Expectations and the decisions and opinions of other investors matter. Fundamentals matter but so does the study of how the decisions of others influence outcomes. This is called game theory.

The prisoner’s dilemma of investing

One of the best-known examples in game theory is the prisoner’s dilemma. For those who are unfamiliar, a quick explainer. This is a famous thought experiment where two criminals are arrested. Both prisoners are placed into solitary confinement with no means of communicating with each other.

Police do not have enough evidence to convict either criminal on a severe charge but enough to convict both on a lesser charge carrying a sentence of one year. The police offer both criminals the opportunity to testify against their partner. If they take the deal they will be let off and the other criminal will get the main charge and penalty of three years.

If both take the deal, they will be sentenced to two years of gaol. Neither criminal has any insight into what the other has decided.

Both criminals take the deal because they are worried the other will inform on them. They each get two years, but the best action would be to stay silent and get one year.

Investing has its own version of the prisoner’s dilemma.

The above chart from AMP looks at April 2025 during tariff turmoil in the US. It shows investor sentiment which includes surveys of investment newsletter writers and individual investors and the ratio of puts (options to sell shares) to calls (options to buy).

Extreme pessimism often leads to large dips in the index, where investors clammer to remove themselves before others do. They do not want to be the one left holding the bag. This is an example of the concept of loss aversion – where a loss feels twice as painful as an equivalent gain

Conversely, extreme optimism leads to insertion into the market as investors look to capitalise before others.

Imagine if more investors remained patient during a market correction. Share prices would likely recover more quickly, and everyone would benefit. Instead, many investors sell because they fear others will sell and try to get out first. Those sales encourage further selling, which reinforces the original fear.

The same dynamic occurs during market bubbles. Investors buy not because they believe prices are justified, but because they believe someone else will pay even more tomorrow. Neither behaviour needs irrational people, it just requires people responding to their perception of the incentives they face.

The best path forward as an investor is to avoid collusion with this short-term prisoner’s dilemma – in other words, focus on market fundamentals instead of following the herd.

Avoid portfolio decisions based on anticipating what everyone else is going to do. Make decisions based on frameworks that outline what does and doesn’t belong in your portfolio irrespective of how you think others will react over the short-term.

The danger of following the crowd

Game theory explains why following the crowd isn’t always the safest option. When uncertainty increases, investors naturally look to others for reassurance. If everyone seems optimistic, buying feels safer. If everyone appears fearful, selling feels sensible.

Markets have a habit of rewarding investors who can separate information from emotion. This doesn’t mean always being contrarian, because often the crowd is right. What it means is recognising that popularity itself isn’t evidence that an investment will pay off over the long term. By the time everyone agrees on an opportunity, much of the potential upside may already be reflected in the price.

Every generation has had their version of this danger. The dot-com bubble, lithium, crypto – the list goes on. Some of these prove to be great long-term investments, but many investors still lose money because they buy at inflated prices.

Think about incentives

One of the simplest lessons from game theory is that incentives are important. Every participant in financial markets has different objectives.

A fund manager may be judged against a benchmark every quarter, so they’re expected to keep adjusting their portfolio while providing compelling justifications to clients.

A CEO may focus on short-term earnings because their remuneration depends on it. Financial commentators and ‘finfluencers’ are rewarded for making bold predictions rather than admitting uncertainty because it generates engagement.

ETF providers compete by launching products that attract investor attention – including those that encourage investors to follow the herd.

None of these incentives are inherently bad. They’re simply different from the incentives I face as I invest for retirement over the next 30 years. I don’t need to outperform a benchmark every quarter, and I don’t need to have an opinion on every earnings season.

Fund managers and professionals are intelligent people, but that does not mean that every decision they make is appropriate for individual investors. Understanding this can help investors avoid reacting to decisions that make perfect sense for someone else but may not be appropriate for them. I’ve written about this in detail here.

Being the best investor is less about intelligence and more about discipline

One more insight for investors from game theory – success often comes from choosing the right game rather than trying to outsmart everyone else.

If you are picking individual shares, it’s important to recognise if you have an ‘edge’. What I would add to having an edge, is that you are able to maintain an edge and apply it consistently.

Most investors cannot consistently predict earnings better than the market or forecast interest rates more accurately than economists. Fortunately, long-term investors can hand off most of the work to the passage of time – an edge that institutional investors do not have.

There is no pressure for us to outperform this quarter or explain short-term underperformance to clients. We do not have to listen or respond to daily market noise.

Remaining invested in low-cost investments, diversifying appropriately for your goals and avoiding emotional decisions can be a powerful investment strategy.

Final thoughts

Game theory reminds us that investing is as much about human behaviour as it is about finance. Every day, millions of investors are responding to uncertainty, incentives, headlines and each other.

That interaction creates opportunities, but it also creates temptations to chase performance, panic during downturns or assume that popular investments are automatically good ones.

The investors who tend to succeed over long periods aren’t necessarily those who know the most. They’re often the ones who understand the game they’re playing.

 

Shani Jayamanne is Director, Investment Specialist, at Morningstar Australia.

 

  •   2 September 2026
  • 2
  •      
  •   
2 Comments
john
September 04, 2026

Well over a year ago when trump presented his tariff hikes on other countries I predicted the drop in the market. I was proved right and it was a good time for several months to be out of the market. Similarly when he started a war against Iran this year
I have a strong sense that when Trump’s term ends (or if he is removed beforehand), his billionaire allies, Wall Street interests, and similar power brokers may pull the prop out from under the share market. They could do it simply because they can as a way of proving a point. But more importantly for them to take stock trading advantages in advance. Those powerful interests will also make things very difficult for an ensuing democrat administration.
My advanced maturity has frequently stood me in good stead when it comes to forming opinions.

 

Leave a Comment:

RELATED ARTICLES

The new capital gains tax trap for your portfolio

How likely are market crashes?

Hold fire on your fund manager over short-term declines

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Division 296: the initial moves to make before the windows close

What if the best superannuation strategy isn't about earning more, but acting before your options disappear? Several overlooked planning windows are narrowing, with consequences that can last for decades.

The retirement scorecard: how many of these questions can you answer?

From the maths of retirement, estimating spending and picking the right asset allocation to survive a poor decade, here are the questions every retiree – current or future – should be able to answer for themselves.

Testamentary trusts: Treasury has picked the wrong reading

A decades-old estate planning tool has survived one tax crackdown only to be caught by another. The surprise isn't who the reform is targeting, but who could end up paying the price for drafting choices made years ago.

Superannuation’s structural failings

Politicians are fighting over access to super, but they may be arguing about the wrong thing. The system’s three fundamental flaws have been hiding in plain sight for decades, costing Australians far more than they realise.

Avoid unnecessary CGT with this estate planning clause

A simple estate plan can create a ticking time bomb. One overlooked clause can pit spouses against children, delay inheritances, and potentially leave a family facing an unexpected tax bill worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Does an American retirement rule work for Australians?

The 4% rule has survived decades of scrutiny, but Australia's retirement system changes the equation in ways most overlook. Before accepting or rejecting this rule of thumb, it pays to understand what really drives retirement outcomes.

Latest Updates

Superannuation

Bill Kelty: Super can't solve everyone's problems

One of the key figures behind Australia’s superannuation system reflects on how it began, what has changed, and why some of today’s biggest debates may be asking too much of a retirement savings system.

Investment strategies

Rising yields have put bonds back in business

For the past decade, investors were forced to chase income wherever they could find it. With yields now offering competition to dividends, the new challenge is deciding whether they're still being adequately rewarded for risk.

Strategy

Do you want a bucket with that?

Retirees, advisers and super funds all talk about the bucket strategy as if it's one thing. It's not. The differences can be significant, and some may matter far more than investors realise when markets become volatile.

Investment strategies

What The Odyssey can teach us about valuation discipline

Investment temptations are hard to resist in the moment, but successful investing is not about ignoring compelling opportunities or ideas. For value investors, the smart move is to prepare before momentum clouds judgement.

Shares

Does market concentration really mean more risk for investors?

One of the most closely watched trends in global markets has become a growing source of investor concern in recent years. Whether that concern is justified, however, turns out to be a far more complicated question.

Retirement

Retirement in reality - 8 months in

Health goals, new friendships and lingering questions about identity have dominated this month. The experience has challenged widely held beliefs about purpose, belonging and what it really means to leave work behind.

Shares

Stagnation might be OK at this point

Australia's economic problems are hardly a secret. The more interesting question for investors is whether the stock market is as exposed to those problems as commonly assumed, or whether the picture is more nuanced.

Sponsors

Alliances

  • ASA-Logo-RGB-ActiveGreen-web.png

© 2026 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.