Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 52

Six property potholes for SMSFs to avoid

I’m always concerned when I see advertisements such as, ‘Convert your Super to a Self Managed Fund and pay off your home in as quick as 10 years.’ In my 28 years at the Australian Taxation Office (ATO), I saw many people caught up in these schemes, especially when in financial difficulties.

To give you an idea on how to avoid some of these dodgy schemes, here are six things that you should always consider if you are entering into property investments using your SMSF.

1.  Does your SMSF’s trust deed allow for property investments?  There are two main sources that provide details of what you, as trustee of your SMSF, can and cannot do.  One is your SMSF’s trust deed and the other is  the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (SISA). An SMSF trustee is not able to undertake actions, regardless of whether it may be permitted by the superannuation law, if it is not also permitted by the SMSF’s trust deed. If your SMSF needs to borrow money to purchase a property, you must ensure your SMSF’s trust deed allows for security to be placed over its assets and allows for a separate trust to hold the asset while the loan remains outstanding.

2.  Is property part of your SMSF’s investment strategy?  There is nothing in the SISA that requires an investment strategy to be in writing. However, SMSF trustees are solely responsible and accountable for the prudential management of their members’ benefits. It is the trustees’ duty to make, implement and document decisions about investing in assets and to carefully monitor the performance of those assets. Also the SISA provides a defence to trustees against any action for loss or damage suffered as a result of them making an investment. The defence is available if trustees can show that the investment was made in accordance with the investment strategy formulated for their SMSF. I recommend that your SMSF investment strategy is documented.

3.  Who is the owner of the property prior to the property being acquired by your SMSF?  Under the SISA, only properties that meet the definition of a ‘Business Real Property’ (BRP) can be acquired by an SMSF from related parties. A BRP is any land and building used wholly and exclusively in a business. It can be residential property as long as the property is used in a business at the time the SMSF acquired it from a related party. Examples of BRP, can be found in the ATO’s publication SMSF Ruling 2009/1. You cannot use your SMSF’s money to purchase the residential property that you live in unless the property value does not exceed 5% of the total assets value of your SMSF. For most people, their SMSF is not worth enough to meet this requirement.

4.  Does the purchase reflect market value? The SISA states that all investment transactions must be conducted at arm’s length. Of course if the parties (i.e. the SMSF and the property owner) are related then they are not arm’s length. ‘ However, the SISA allows sales of BRP between related parties by stating that if the parties are not at arm’s length then they must act as though they are or on terms that do not disadvantage the SMSF. Therefore, the purchase price paid on properties should always reflect the true market value regardless of who the buyers and sellers are.

5.  Has the SMSF accumulated enough money to purchase the property outright or would it need to borrow?  If your SMSF needs to borrow to purchase the property, then the borrowings must be structured correctly in accordance with the requirements of a “Limited Recourse Borrowing  Arrangement” (LRBA) under the SISA.

If borrowing is required, it needs to be structured correctly, follow the correct process, have the correct wording on the loan document, and ensure the correct names are on the purchase and loan documents. A separate holding trust should be established by a qualified legal practitioner. Failure to properly execute a holding trust arrangement may lead to unnecessary stamp duty and/or capital gains tax implications. I recommend appropriate legal advice is obtained prior to any part of the purchase taking place. Also for more details on the application of the LRBA, refer to the ATO publication SMSF Ruling 2012/1.

6.  Once the property is acquired by your SMSF, who is it going to be leased to? The SISA prevents properties that do not meet the definition of a BRP to be leased to related parties unless the property value does not exceed 5% of the SMSF’s total asset value. So unless your SMSF has substantial wealth, beware of any claim that you can use your SMSF to pay off your mortgage. It cannot be done.

If everything is done correctly and in accordance with the superannuation law, property may be a good investment for SMSFs. If things are done incorrectly, not only can your SMSF be penalised by the ATO, it may end up paying three times the stamp duty as well as incur additional capital gains tax.


Monica Rule worked for the Australian Taxation Office for 28 years and is the author of ‘The Self Managed Superannuation Handbook – Superannuation Law for Self Managed Superannuation Fund in Plain English’. She now runs her own business focussed on SMSF and superannuation education and consulting.


5 more mistakes to avoid with SMSFs

Court holds SMSF trustees accountable

7 vital steps to compliance for your SMSF

Amanda McDermott
January 22, 2018

Thanks so much Monica, All the banks that I have spoken to so far, won't lend because the land doesn't generate income, despite the fact my 9.5% employer contributions will more than pay the loan installments each month.
They don't even want to know my details to proceed any further.
This led me to look up the following;

From the Superannuation Industry (Supervisory) Act 1993
Division 2—Interpretation
10 Definitions
invest means:
(a) apply assets in any way; or
(b) make a contract;
for the purpose of gaining interest, income, profit or gain.
The way i read that is gain is a gradual appreciation of the asset (land in this case).
I haven't given up though. I'll keep searching for finance. Thanks again for replying!

Monica Rule
January 19, 2018

Hi Amanda,

An SMSF is able to borrow under a "limited recourse borrowing arrangement" (LRBA) to acquire a single acquirable asset such as vacant land purchased from an unrelated land owner. The lender can be anyone as long as the terms of the loan are at arm's length.

You may wish to view the following ATO publications (ATOID 2010/162, PCG 2016/5, TD 2016/6) to understand what is meant by the terms arm's length in relation to LRBAs.

I hope this helps.

Amanda McDermott
January 19, 2018

Hi Monica
I have set up a single member SMSF and want to borrow 35% of the value of the vacant land and use my regular 9.5% contributions to repay the loan (more than enough). Is this possible? FYI I have no intention to do anything to the land until I retire in 30 years time.

Graham Hand
July 21, 2015

Debbie, see Monica's article: Do you mean your super fund will put in 40% and you will personally put in the other 60%? Is that the question?

July 21, 2015

I'm in the process of establishing my SMSF as a single member. I want to know if I can buy a house and land package with my super fund if I'm to borrow about 60-65% from the bank? Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.

Monica Rule
January 31, 2015

Oscar, you can only make an in-specie contribution (i.e. transferring land you own) to your SMSF if the land is used wholly and exclusively in your business. For example, you are a property developer and land is used in your business. Also, you cannot borrow under a limited recourse borrowing arrangement to develop, renovate, or improve a property already owned by an SMSF.

January 30, 2015

I wish to make a voluntary contribution to my smsf for 2 vacant blocks of residential land, both of which i own outright. Can i do this with a view to borrow (LRBA) to build on them individually?

Peter Rusbourne
March 14, 2014

This list is a great way to assess any proposed transaction. In my experience I would also add to the list:

11 If the SMSF has more than one member and the Vendor is one member, does the SMSF documents reflect the benefit being to the Vendor member?

12 Are your documents acceptable to your lender? Each lender has different requirements that change from time to time.

Greg Einfeld
March 14, 2014

This is a good checklist of things to consider. I would add a few more:

7. Is anyone recommending a property and if so, what conflicts of interest might be influencing their recommendation?

8. Do you have your documentation in order, including getting the name of the right entities on the right legal documents, with the right entities being established in the right order.

9. Are you planning to improve or renovate the property? If so, you should ensure your strategy is compliant before entering into a contract.

10. Do you have enough liquidity to get you through an unforeseen situation? Such as a vacant property, loss of income (and contributions), or death of one of the members of the fund.

What other points would you add to the list?

Monica Rule
March 07, 2014

'You cannot use your SMSF’s money to purchase the residential property that you live in unless the property value does not exceed 5% of the total assets value of your SMSF.'

I should also add that the property must be leased back to the members for this to be allowed under the in-house asset rules.


Leave a Comment:


Most viewed in recent weeks

Coronavirus and a roadmap for infected investing

As much as value investors with spare cash want to jump on undervalued companies, it's probably not the time to buy the dip in the market just yet as the US braces for coronavirus's full impact.

Why we’re not buying the market yet

The Australian market bounced back last Friday (13th) and Monday (16th) tempting analysts to call the bottom of the coronavirus scare. This is too early as the impact on companies is not yet evident.

Douglass on coronavirus: 'Expect volatility but don't panic'

As investors hit the panic button, Magellan's Hamish Douglass is staying his course, advising attendees at last week's Investor Evening to sit tight and take a long-term view.

Drawdown reductions needed for retirees - UPDATED POLICY

During the GFC, in the face of rapid falls in super balances, the minimum drawdowns required for pensions were reduced by 50% to help preserve overall retirement savings. It's time for a repeat.

What are the possible economic effects of COVID-19 on the world economy?

In a widely-quoted scenario using estimated attack and fatality rates of coronavirus, about 0.07% of the population of the US dies. That's about 230,000 people, which the market is not ready for.

Note to Australia: be more French in the COVID-19 war

Andrew Baker is well-known as a superannuation consultant. Now working in the UK, he was caught in France with his family and is in lockdown. He worries Australian policy was too slow.

Latest Updates

Latest from Morningstar

Four stages of a typical bear market - but is this typical?

Bear markets primarily caused by recession fears follow a pattern, but we have never seen anything like coronavirus. If financial stimulus and medicine prove ineffective, all bets are off. 


Small business in path of COVID-19 tsunami

The turning point in this crisis will be when the number of new COVID-19 cases starts to decrease. Until then, can we mitigate the damage to businesses and the economy so that we can snap back?


What are the possible economic effects of COVID-19 on the world economy?

In a widely-quoted scenario using estimated attack and fatality rates of coronavirus, about 0.07% of the population of the US dies. That's about 230,000 people, which the market is not ready for.

Exchange traded products

Fixed interest LIT carnage makes stamping fees worse

Retail investors in fixed interest LITs now realise some structures were not the defensive portfolios they expected, but have prices reached value? Plus it's time to act on stamping fees.


Optimism among forecasts of the COVID-19 peak

This detailed analysis of infections, deaths, drugs and vaccines includes an optimistic scenario: perhaps US and Australian infection numbers will peak in early to mid-April with a decline after.



© 2020 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use.
Any general advice or class service prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, has been prepared by without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. Refer to our Financial Services Guide (FSG) for more information. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.