Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 353

The $20,000 decision on early access to super

As part of its economic response to the coronavirus crisis, the Federal Government is allowing those facing financial hardship to access their superannuation in two tranches of $10,000. Whether or not to ‘tap’ your super is an important decision. You need to think about the trade-off between your present situation and the one you may face in retirement.

Be aware that most people are myopic (we put much more weighting on the present versus the future) which is one of the reasons why governments around the world have mandatory savings schemes designed to provide support the funding of retirement.

To date, 620,000 people have already registered to access their super, so this policy has become a major issue for retirement savings and superannuation funds.

Some numbers to help you decide

Withdrawing your super now, all else equal, can only reduce savings at retirement, which means less income after you stop working. The degree of impact is unknown so we need to make some assumptions.

Using assumptions similar to those made by many super funds to provide retirement estimates on annual statements to members, we can estimate the possible impact on your super savings at retirement (in today’s dollars) assuming you retire at age 67.  

In the table below, we assume that your savings grow annually at a rate of 3% above inflation less administration fees (assumed to be 0.5%). 

Current age

30

40

50

60

Reduction in retirement balance

$50,000

$39,000

$30,000

$24,000

There is a huge range in estimates of the impact of early access on retirement savings. Most disappointing is the ABC’s claim that the impact could be $500,000. This is clearly incorrect.

It is just as important to consider the possible impact on your spending in retirement:

Current age

30

40

50

60

Reduction in fortnightly income from superannuation

$108

$83

$65

$52

The change in income above does not consider the age pension. Depending on your financial circumstances, the age pension may form a significant component of your income in retirement. Due to means assessment, a lower super balance at retirement may actually slightly increase the amount of age pension you receive.

To consider your own situation in more detail, play around with the many assumptions and assess different scenarios, financial calculators such as ASIC Moneysmart retirement planner are informative and easy to use.

Other factors to consider

There are many other factors to consider:

  • Think about your household situation. Most people retire as a couple meaning that your joint financial situation is the one to focus on. An early access decision should be made jointly.
  • Not everything to do with your retirement plan is in your control. Future investment returns are uncertain, as highlighted by the current crisis. And many people do not choose their retirement age (they often ‘retire’ because they can’t find work). Planning for a retirement buffer is something to consider.
  • You may be pulling money out of superannuation at a point in time when asset prices are depressed. While it is true that equity, credit and property assets are lower than a few months ago, it is far from certain that asset prices will rise over the short to medium term.
  • You may have the ability to catch up on your retirement savings plan in better times. However, this takes discipline so perhaps plan for how you will achieve this.

Making a balanced decision

Superannuation combines mandatory savings with the power of compounding investment returns to produce better retirement outcomes and reduce the burden of funding the age pension on future tax payers. If you can leave your savings pot untouched then that is better for your retirement outcome. Super is also a tax-advantaged savings environment.

However, you may be feeling financial stress right now and that is not healthy. The early access scheme is designed to help people in this situation.

How to make a sensible decision? It may make sense to work through the following:

  • Assess your current level of financial stress. Are you experiencing debt problems? Do you have the income to support your living standards? If you don’t have one already, consider creating a household budget to help you assess living standards.
  • Can you make some adjustments to your lifestyle? Perhaps reduce some spending on non-essential items during the crisis to make your household budget more sustainable.
  • Have you accessed all the assistance programs which are available to you? There are a range of government support schemes to help those experiencing financial difficulty in the present environment.
  • Think about your retirement plans (lifestyle but also the age at which you would like to retire) and consider the amount of retirement income that is required to support that plan. Include other parts of your life plan such as home ownership.
  • Consider whether it is necessary to access your super once or twice (the early access programme allows for two separate withdrawals of up to $10,000 each).

Financial advice is valuable in situations like this. However, for some it may be expensive relative to your financial position. There are also financial counselling services available which may provide basic assistance.

For many people, the government’s early access to super scheme may help to alleviate financial stress. But tapping your retirement savings pool will naturally impact your retirement. Take the time to make a considered decision, especially if isolation provides the chance to do some research.

For more details on who can access super early, see here. Note also that authorities are warning that some promoters are offering early access schemes (such as transferring your super into an SMSF). These schemes are often illegal and heavy penalties apply. For more information, refer to Illegal early release of super.

 

This is not financial advice and it does not consider any individual circumstances. An ASIC class order allows super funds to provide retirement projections on member statements. A similar approach is used for the projections in this article they are estimates only.

David Bell is Executive Director of The Conexus Institute, a not-for-profit research institution focused on improving retirement outcomes for Australians.

 

8 Comments
darthvader
April 20, 2020

Those that have access to some of the Share Purchase Plans offered recently might consider whether they are a better option than leaving money in a poorly performing super fund having fees compounding against them etc.

Kevin
April 19, 2020

David,
A starting balance and then a final balance for each withdrawal would have given the reader a more balanced view on the outcomes.
I agree, there is significant impact on the end results but how many 30 year old's would have $20,000 in their fund to even consider withdrawal it.

David Bell
April 20, 2020

Hi Kevin, points well made. The other important issue along those lines is the role of the age pension in retirement. To explore all of this you really do start to step into personal advice world. The range of scenarios required to paint the full picture would also be significant. Calculators such as ASIC's Moneysmart can help people make their own assessment. Cheers, David

Byron
April 19, 2020

Assuming the $20k is needed to cover a loss of income, the analysis should cover how a person might alternatively access these funds. Alternatives such as deferring home loan repayments, using credit cards, deferring bill payments also impacts future income (in fact, isn’t this the basis for federal govt fiscal measures!). Properly weighing the opportunity cost would help the industry with its post-royal-commission credibility / self-interest images

David Bell
April 20, 2020

Hi Byron - your point is well made. I used basic calculations similar to those used in ASIC's class order relief for super funds providing annual retirement projections on statements. That framework doesn't readily incorporate the issues you have raised. Cheers, David

Jack
April 16, 2020

And to those wealthy people working in funds management (not referring to David here) who say a young family struggling to put food on the table or pay for utilities should not be able to access $20,000 from their super, and rather, wait 40 years until the day they turn 65, shame on you!

Michael2
April 18, 2020

Jack,
40 years sounds like a long time, but my experience was it went by in a flash.
I spent 33 of those years working in a job I didn't like doing things against my values to make a quid

It is tough for everybody

SMSF Trustee
April 19, 2020

Jack, that's harsh. I don't think anyone in the industry is saying that. What they are saying is that accessing cash like this has consequences and that (a) people need to properly decide between their short term financial need and the long term financial consequence and (b) that the government might like to consider better alternatives.
That's an entirely reasonable thing to be pointing out to people. But in no way is it telling someone who has no other option, 'starve now for the sake of your future'. I don't know anyone in the super industry who needs to feel ashamed, at least not for the reason you've put forward.

 

Leave a Comment:

     

RELATED ARTICLES

Why 10/30/60 is no longer the rule

Where is superannuation research heading?

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

After 30 years of investing, I prefer to skip this party

Eventually, prices become so extreme they bear no relationship to reality, and a bubble forms. I believe we are there today, not for all stocks but for many in the technology space.

Australian house prices: Part 2, the bigger picture

There is good reason to believe the negatives will continue to outweigh the positives over the next 12 to 18 months. There is more concern about house prices than the short-term indicators suggest.

How to handle the riskiest company results in history

It is better to miss a results bounce and buy after the company has delivered than it is to step on a landmine. With such uncertainty, avoid FOMO by following these result season investing tips.

Australian house prices: Part 1, how worried should we be?

Three key indicators are useful for predicting the short-term outlook for house prices, although tighter lockdowns make the outlook gloomier. There is enough doubt to create cause for concern.

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 367

There is a similarity between the current health crisis and economic crises of the past. For COVID-19, record amounts of biotech funding from government agencies and private companies are looking for a vaccine. Likewise, central banks once struggled treating recessions but the 'vaccine' now is record amounts of financial stimulus to ensure liquidity. While the world awaits a COVID treatment, markets are purring along, at least until side effects hit.

  • 22 July 2020

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 369

Imagine you had perfect foresight about COVID-19 at the start of the year. You correctly foresaw that the global pandemic would kill over 700,000 among 20 million infections by August. In Australia, borders would close, cities would be locked down, most mortgagors would be on income support and companies would be allowed to trade while insolvent. You then had to guess how much the stock market would fall. Would you say about 10%?

  • 6 August 2020

Latest Updates

Shares

How to handle the riskiest company results in history

It is better to miss a results bounce and buy after the company has delivered than it is to step on a landmine. With such uncertainty, avoid FOMO by following these result season investing tips.

Shares

The rise of Afterpay and emergence of a new business model

Sometimes the simplest ideas are the best. The founders of Afterpay stumbled on the attraction for consumers of paying by instalments, and now retailers must offer the facility or lose business.

Property

WFH and its impact on Australian offices and tenants

Although most office workers are currently WFH, an energy and a buzz comes from working in the same physical space. Other benefits include team building, relationships, talent mentoring and creative collaboration.

Fixed interest

Why 2020 has been the year of the bond market

Going back to June 2019, investors would have questioned the logic of diversifying away from outperforming growth assets. But when markets feel at their best, it is paramount to keep a perspective on long-term goals.

Investment strategies

Is 5G all hype or real investable opportunity?

While its impact will take time to unfold, 5G will meaningfully change the world. Once adoption takes hold, there is huge potential for its application across a wide range of industries.

Property

Australian house prices: Part 1, how worried should we be?

Three key indicators are useful for predicting the short-term outlook for house prices, although tighter lockdowns make the outlook gloomier. There is enough doubt to create cause for concern.

Property

Australian house prices: Part 2, the bigger picture

There is good reason to believe the negatives will continue to outweigh the positives over the next 12 to 18 months. There is more concern about house prices than the short-term indicators suggest.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2020 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use.
Any general advice or class service prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, has been prepared by without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. Refer to our Financial Services Guide (FSG) for more information. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.