Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 196

Insider sales can be a powerful warning

A company’s directors, particularly executive directors, have more insight into a business than anyone else in the market. Therefore, we are generally sceptical when a company’s board member substantially sells-down their ownership as it can signal a negative outlook for the company. Furthermore, a substantial reduction in a director's equity diminishes their 'skin in the game', which helps align their interests with shareholders.

Skin in the game

In our experience, when management (including directors and senior managers) have equity in the company they are running, it is likely to outperform other comparable businesses. This is particularly the case when the founder maintains a stake in the company. Managers with 'skin in the game', a term famously coined by Warren Buffett, have more exposure to the performance of the company they are running. This creates an inherent incentive for them to act in the interests of the company and its shareholders.

When we assess a company as a prospective investment, we always consider how management’s interests are aligned to its shareholders by evaluating remuneration structures including base salary, bonuses and performance hurdles. Our focus on management’s equity stake in the business also applies to our analysis of IPOs, particularly those businesses that are yet to generate a profit (for more, see my Cuffelinks article, ‘Nine factors to assess in IPOs with no earnings’).

Scrutiny of Appendix 3Y Notices

ASX-listed companies must notify the stock exchange (within five business days) using an Appendix 3Y - Change of Director’s Interest Notice when directors acquire or dispose of its shares.

Appendix 3Y Notices can provide valuable insights and we closely monitor these announcements on potential investments as well as those already in our portfolio. We pay particular attention to share sales by executive directors (such as CEOs) with responsibility for the day-to-day operations. Their decision can sometimes be tantamount to a vote of no confidence in the future prospects and may be a signal for us to sell-out of a holding, or at least seek to understand the rationale for the sale. Conversely, a company’s directors increasing their holding typically indicates a positive outlook and their ongoing commitment.

Director sales

Over the last 12 to 24 months, the market has seen the spectacular collapse of numerous company share prices. In many cases, the share price rout was preceded by significant sell-downs by company directors including:

Bellamy’s Australia (ASX: BAL). Former Managing Director and CEO Laura McBain and then-Chairman Rob Woolley sold 14.2% and 44.2% respectively of their shares in Bellamy’s. The sales in August 2016 for $14.60 were made just days before the stock hit an all-time high of $14.90 a share. The disposal of shares in the former market darling proved a portent of Bellamy’s share price performance with its stock plummeting around 69% off their high to trade around $4.61 each at the time of writing.

Vocus Communications (ASX: VOC). Founder and director of the telco James Spenceley substantially sold-down his stake in the business for $26.7 million in August 2016 before the company downgraded its profit guidance in November. Shares in Vocus are now down 54% from their May 2016 high.

Estia Health (ASX: EHE). After the company missed its profit guidance, director and founder of the aged-care operator and developer, Peter Arvanitis, surprised the market in August 2016 by selling his entire stake in the company (around 10%) for $3.15 a share (which compares to a high of $7.41 earlier in the year), or around $55 million. Simultaneously, Mr Arvanitis resigned as a director. The company’s share price had already declined sharply in the months leading up to Mr Arvanitis’s decision to sell-out and continued its decline with the company cutting its profit outlook in October 2016. Shares in Estia have since recovered to trade around Mr Arvanitis’s sale price.

Research reveals correlation

Our belief that insider sales can be a potent indicator of a company’s future performance was buttressed by recent research. An analysis by stockbroking firm Wilsons (not related to Wilson Asset Management) of Appendix 3Y Notices announced to the ASX in 2016 found that, of the companies whose management sold large parcels of shares, 76% underperformed following the sale with their share prices falling an average of 14% (excluding companies with a market capitalisation of less than $50 million and listed investment companies).

The research also found the larger the value of the shares sold, the greater the risk it would underperform. Interestingly, the disposal of shares of any size by a director holding the position of CEO, CFO and/or COO was correlated to significant underperformance of the share price.

When director selling is a positive

Insider sales are not always an ominous sign and director sales can sometimes be a positive for the company outlook. For example, a director that has sold shares but still holds a large parcel may be motivated to ensure a continuing and positive relationship with the buyer because they want to sell again in the future. Also, when a director is selling shares but leaving ‘something on the table’, it can give us confidence in the future prospects of the company. As an example, the executives at Monadelphous Group (ASX: MND) over the years have generally sold and left money on the table.

 

Chris Stott is Chief Investment Officer of Wilson Asset Management (WAM). This article is general information and does not consider the needs of any individual, and WAM may or may not hold some of the investments mentioned.

 

RELATED ARTICLES

When directors sell, should you sell too?

The market loves growth stocks – until it doesn’t

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

How to enjoy your retirement

Amid thousands of comments, tips include developing interests to keep occupied, planning in advance to have enough money, staying connected with friends and communities ... should you defer retirement or just do it?

Results from our retirement experiences survey

Retirement is a good experience if you plan for it and manage your time, but freedom from money worries is key. Many retirees enjoy managing their money but SMSFs are not for everyone. Each retirement is different.

A tonic for turbulent times: my nine tips for investing

Investing is often portrayed as unapproachably complex. Can it be distilled into nine tips? An economist with 35 years of experience through numerous market cycles and events has given it a shot.

Rival standard for savings and incomes in retirement

A new standard argues the majority of Australians will never achieve the ASFA 'comfortable' level of retirement savings and it amounts to 'fearmongering' by vested interests. If comfortable is aspirational, so be it.

Dalio v Marks is common sense v uncommon sense

Billionaire fund manager standoff: Ray Dalio thinks investing is common sense and markets are simple, while Howard Marks says complex and convoluted 'second-level' thinking is needed for superior returns.

Fear is good if you are not part of the herd

If you feel fear when the market loses its head, you become part of the herd. Develop habits to embrace the fear. Identify the cause, decide if you need to take action and own the result without looking back. 

Latest Updates

Economy

The paradox of investment cycles

Now we're captivated by inflation and higher rates but only a year ago, investors were certain of the supremacy of US companies, the benign nature of inflation and the remoteness of tighter monetary policy.

Shares

Reporting Season will show cost control and pricing power

Companies have been slow to update guidance and we have yet to see the impact of inflation expectations in earnings and outlooks. Companies need to insulate costs from inflation while enjoying an uptick in revenue.

Shares

The early signals for August company earnings

Weaker share prices may have already discounted some bad news, but cost inflation is creating wide divergences inside and across sectors. Early results show some companies are strong enough to resist sector falls.

Property

The compelling 20-year flight of SYD into private hands

In 2002, the share price of the company that became Sydney Airport (SYD) hit 80 cents from the $2 IPO price. After 20 years of astute investment driving revenue increases, it sold to private hands for $8.75 in 2022.

Investment strategies

Ethical investing responding to some short-term challenges

There are significant differences in the sector weightings of an ethical fund versus an index, and while this has caused some short-term headwinds recently, the tailwinds are expected to blow over the long term.

Investment strategies

If you are new to investing, avoid these 10 common mistakes

Many new investors make common mistakes while learning about markets. Losses are inevitable. Newbies should read more and develop a long-term focus while avoiding big mistakes and not aiming to be brilliant.

Investment strategies

RMBS today: rising rate-linked income with capital preservation

Lenders use Residential Mortgage-Backed Securities to finance mortgages and RMBS are available to retail investors through fund structures. They come with many layers of protection beyond movements in house prices. 

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2022 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. Any general advice or ‘regulated financial advice’ under New Zealand law has been prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide (AU) and Financial Advice Provider Disclosure Statement (NZ). You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.