Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 368

Is gold a growth or defensive asset?

Gold investors have enjoyed a stellar 2020, with the yellow metal rising by 16% in USD terms and 19% in AUD terms in the first six months of the calendar year. On 27 July, gold reached an all-time high in nominal terms of US$1,944 a troy ounce. Since the cyclical bear market bottom seen in late 2015, the gold price in USD terms has increased by more than 80%.

Investment demand continues to rise, seen most clearly through the more than 700 tonnes of inflows into gold exchange traded products (ETPs) in the first six months of 2020. Whilst the United States and Europe dominate these figures in terms of total tonnage, demand is also strong in Australia. Inflows into Perth Mint Gold (ASX:PMGOLD) have seen total holdings rise by more than 50% in the first half of this year.

The increase in demand locally is driven by self-directed investors like SMSF trustees, as well as financial intermediaries looking to allocate a portion of their client portfolios to gold. Nevertheless, some investors are still grappling with the question of where gold fits within a portfolio. In many cases, investors are assessing whether gold should be seen as a growth asset or a defensive asset.

What kind of asset is gold?

It’s easy to understand why some investors see gold as a growth asset. It is a commodity, and commodities are almost universally seen as growth assets. Gold has also historically exhibited price volatility that is similar or even slightly higher than the equity market. Gold also delivers no income stream, with capital growth the only way it can provide a return to investors.

Given defensive assets are expected to generate regular income, and typically display lower volatility than equity markets, some investors struggle to view gold as a defensive asset.

However, gold does have some defensive asset characteristics. Physical gold is a zero credit-risk instrument, meaning there is no default risk. This is one reason why central banks hold almost 35,000 tonnes (worth over US$2 trillion in value) of the metal as part of their reserve assets. These central bank gold holdings have been growing for more than a decade, indicating gold is still seen as an important monetary asset amongst these institutions.

Gold also behaves differently to traditional commodities in terms of its interplay with risk assets. Not only does gold have a low overall correlation to equity markets, but this correlation usually turns sharply negative during the worst equity market sell-offs.

Commodities, on the other hand, are positively correlated to equities, with this correlation rising in the worst equity market sell-offs.

The chart below illustrates these differences, highlighting the correlation of gold (LBMA PM gold price) and commodities (Bloomberg commodity index) to equity markets (S&P 500) based on weekly returns between 1971 and 2019.

The chart shows:

  • Correlations when the S&P500 falls by more than two standard deviations (top bars)
  • Unconditional correlations over the entire time period (middle bars)
  • Correlations when the S&P500 rises by more than two standard deviations (bottom bars)

Gold and commodity correlations to equity markets

Source: World Gold Council

The results show if an investor wishes to reduce overall portfolio drawdowns (losses) during periods of equity market stress, then history suggests gold is an asset to turn to, rather than a commodity basket.

Unlike other commodities, gold has historically delivered positive returns in low inflation environments and during deflationary scares.


Register here to receive the Firstlinks weekly newsletter for free

Gold trades more like a bond

Furthering the case that gold can be seen as a defensive asset is the fact that the precious metal tends to trade like a bond and has many attributes similar to types of bonds.

It has no maturity date like a perpetual bond, a credit risk of zero (like most sovereign bonds) and no coupon like a zero-coupon bond. History shows that investors have been willing to pay more for such an asset in environments where the real yield available on zero credit risk (but not zero inflation risk) bonds is declining.

This is demonstrated in the following chart, which plots the correlation between the USD gold price and the real yield (which is inverted on the chart) on United States 10-year Treasury bonds from January 2003 to June 2020.

USD gold price and real yield on US 10-year treasury bonds

Source: The Perth Mint, United States Treasury

While it is not a perfect correlation, the chart is evidence that the lower real yields on Treasury securities fall, the higher the gold price tends to go.

Given the above relationship, it is natural that investors who are worried that real yields may stay below zero or continue to decline for the foreseeable future are turning to gold today.

What do self-directed investors think?

Self-directed investors largely seem to see gold as a defensive asset. In a recent webinar for the Australian Investors Association, we asked attendees whether their motivation to invest in gold was driven primarily by a desire to preserve wealth or to generate a profit.

More than 75% of those who responded stated that wealth preservation would be the primary motivation for making an investment into gold. Indeed, this theme was addressed in a Firstlinks article written by Noel Whittaker last week. Titled Hedging for capital preservation, the article discussed three options an investor looking to protect a portfolio from equity market drawdowns could consider. Investing in physical gold was one of those options.

Irrespective of whether gold is considered a growth asset, a defensive asset or a hybrid of the two, the precious metal has attributes that can be beneficial to investors managing a balanced portfolio, especially given the challenging economic and monetary environment that investors are expected to face for many years.

 

Jordan Eliseo is Manager of Listed Products and Investment Research at The Perth Mint, a sponsor of Firstlinks. The information in this article is for general information only and should not be taken as constituting professional advice from The Perth Mint. You should consider seeking independent financial advice to check how the information in this article relates to your unique circumstances.

For more articles and papers from The Perth Mint, click here.

 

15 Comments
Rodion Pomykalov
August 07, 2020

Gold is not an investment. Gold is your anchor, it is a Gods asset, it should be used as a hedge against the currency. You should never sell Gold, it’s used as a reserve bank. You never sell it as it gives you cash flow it’s a God asset, it’s an attractor of wealth. For every quantity of Gold spot price you will have cash flow of that amount going into your account every month indefinitely. But if you use it as an investment you will never get cash flow. 

Mark
August 02, 2020

To say gold offers anything like the pay off of any type of bond seems false to me. You’ve cherry picked characteristics of some bonds (perpetual and zero coupon) that would never been combined in the same bond, to the best of my knowledge - a perpetual zero coupon bonds offers a pretty bad payoff..Any asset that doesn’t provide an ongoing cash flow and is more volatile than equities can’t be a considered similar to bonds and cash, even if it goes up during periods of disruption. The hype atm reminds me of the same discussion almost 10 years ago..

Alexander McClintockp
August 03, 2020

Gold has risen by around 9.5% per year on average since 2000. In only 3 years did gold go down in value.
Yes prior to 2000 there were crazy ups and downs.
I would consider an average of 9% as nice growth. I don’t mind if you want to define this as defensive or growth ??

Jerome Lander
August 02, 2020

Great article Jordan. Gold tends to be an unnecessarily divisive asset.

billy bloggs
August 01, 2020

With the ease governments can devalue currencies as has been demonstrated over the past 6 months, gold should be a part of all investors portfolios. It'll be a great hedge for when the music stops.

Jeff Oughton
July 30, 2020

what does the return on 10 year bonds look like v gold returns?
is chart 2 an illusion - level of gold v real running yield?
has anyone seen the research on returns?

James B
July 30, 2020

This site shows a 100 year inflation adjusted return: https://www.macrotrends.net/1333/historical-gold-prices-100-year-chart. You would have experienced major losses if holding Gold for the 20 year period between 1980 & 2000! It's a major roller coaster when viewed over the long term.

Phil the Alien
July 30, 2020

Not in Au. It has been great. The 1kg bullion bar I bought in 2010 for 46971 has a buyback price today of
87046 or about 8.5% per annum with holding costs of $50 per annum in bank SD box. Accounting is easy. A photograph with the national daily satisfies my auditors. Silver has been even better of late. During decades of booming shares and solvent governments gold would be a poor bet but since 2008 and the growth of infinite funny money, precious metals have seen steady rises. It will never be worth zero unlike many a share certificate and with banks paying nothing in interest, people are now seeing gold as being worth a punt. At least when the bail in happens you have your money and not an IOU or equity in a dead bank.

James B
July 31, 2020

Phil - Yes in AUD you would have experienced inflation adjusted losses for the 20 years between 1980 & 2000. It's hard to find data on it, but you can see pricing (not adjusted for inflation) between 1980-2000 in AUD here: https://goldprice.org/gold-price-australia.html. Be careful!

Michael Armitage
August 01, 2020

If all assets in your portfolio are going up at the same time - You are not diversified. .
Bonds , stocks , commodities, all go through periods of negative return. Volatility can be managed ( sizing and rebalancing). Further , Australians holding gold m Aussie $ have an natural equity tail risk protection.

Jordan Eliseo
August 06, 2020

Hi James - you are right that gold can go through bear markets. As can any asset class. For example bonds had a circa 50 year bear leading into the end of the 1970s, US equities didn't recover their 1929 top until 1954 in real terms from memory, and I think Aussie investors in the ASX 200 are still well behind (on capital only admittedly) relative to where they were pre GFC. No asset is perfect, and they all have cycles in which they thrive, and others in which they don't, hence the importance of diversification

Frank Gomez
July 30, 2020

Gold is not an asset, is not money any more and further discussions beyond it being a pretty shiny metal used for jewellery is pointless.

CC
July 30, 2020

utter nonsense to say it's not an asset. gold price will never go to zero, unlike some share prices....

Jason
July 30, 2020

I suppose the reason that central banks keep 30,000 tonnes of bullion is because CBs have nothing to do with money and just like to collect jewellery. The fact they have continued to buy the stuff for over a decade after Costello sold off most of Australia's for a song must mean they still haven't learnt their lesson.

Max Argent
August 07, 2020

So why is gold minted as legal tender under the Currency Act? Enjoy your fiat!

 

Leave a Comment:

     

RELATED ARTICLES

The outlook for gold in a post COVID world

Republican or Democrat: does it matter for gold?

The asymmetric value of gold for Australian investors

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Great new ways the Government helps retirees

Last year's retiree checklist of services available was one of our most popular articles. There are some additions for 2021, and while it can take effort to set them up, they can pay off over the long term.

Four simple strategies deliver long-term investing comfort

A long-time advocate of the merits of generating income by investing in industrial companies rather than bonds or deposits checks his 'mothership' chart for the latest results, and continues to feel vindicated.

$100 billion! Five reasons investors are flocking to ETFs

It's not official, but Australian ETFs are clicking over $100 billion right now. It's a remarkable rise, leaving the traditional rivals, the Listed Investment Companies, in their dust. Why are they so popular?

A close look at retiree fears and expectations

Half of Australians retire early due to unexpected circumstances and within timeframes they did not choose, and two-thirds of pre-retirees worry about funding their retirement. But neither are the greatest fear in retirement.

Cut it out ... millionaires are not wealthy

The widespread use of 'millionaire' must stop. Inflation means that the basket of goods and services that cost $1 million in 1960 now requires $15 million. Today, millionaires are not wealthy.

Minister Jane Hume on SMSFs and superannuation reform

Senator Jane Hume presented at the SMSFA conference this week, and we reproduce the full transcript as a guide to what the Government is thinking on superannuation reforms as we head into the next election.

Latest Updates

Investment strategies

Dog-eat-dinner: a tough day in the life of a broker analyst

What do stock analysts do in reporting season, faced with hundreds of company reports? Take a look inside the secret world of broking and the analysts burning the midnight oil for a month, hoping for a special insight.

Shares

What drives Australian versus global equity performance?

We tend to think of the 'stockmarket' as one beast, but it pays to know the drivers of the different parts, especially global versus Australian stocks. The outlook favours global due to better sector exposure.

Shares

Invest in Australian value stocks before it is too late

By now, we know 'growth' stocks have outperformed 'value' for many years and investors look to the future, but there are good reasons why the switch is on, especially as value companies emerge from the pandemic.  

Shares

Gains of a lifetime reward new retail investors

Nobody knows how to pick the bottom of the market, but new investors did well in 2020. They captured most of the returns since the lows, and contrary to popular opinion, they are not punting away on tech stocks. 

Investment strategies

FANMAG: Because FAANGs are so yesterday

FANMAG returns have been strong but not relative to their predecessors. Looking at a broader group of large tech companies, most have lagged the market. Fad-based investing is no substitute for broad diversification.

Overdue overhaul of Australia’s aged care system

To support a better aged care system appropriate to the needs of all Australians, critical changes are needed including a new financing approach. The current system has failed seniors, carers and providers for years. 

Shares

‘Super-defensive equities’ may rescue struggling 60/40 portfolios

The 60/40 portfolio has been the mainstay of 'default' Australian investing, but large allocations to bonds compromise returns when rates are low. Strategies with exposures negatively-correlated to equities are needed.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2021 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use.
Any general advice or class service prepared by Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892) and/or Morningstar Research Ltd, subsidiaries of Morningstar, Inc, has been prepared by without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. Refer to our Financial Services Guide (FSG) for more information. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.

Website Development by Master Publisher.