Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 523

Matildas reality check: little impact on the A-League

On 12 August 2023, the Matildas played France in the Women’s World Cup Quarter Final. Australia’s victory after a tense and dramatic penalty shootout was the most-viewed television event since Cathy Freeman’s gold medal race at the 2000 Olympics. A few days later, a new all-time viewing record of 11 million people tuned in for the England Semi Final.

The World Cup is widely hailed as a new beginning not only for women’s sport and women’s football in Australia, but for football generally. By the end of the tournament, total attendances had reached almost two million and global television audiences will surpass two billion.

The morning after the night before

The day after the France game, on 13 August 2023, the reigning champions of the A-League, Central Coast Mariners, played the most successful club in the history of the competition, Sydney FC, in the Australia Cup. The game was held at WIN Stadium, the home ground of Wollongong Wolves FC. The Illawarra club claims a catchment area of 500,000 and has attempted to join the A-League several times, including in 2009 when Gold Coast United and North Queensland Fury were accepted into the top league. Neither of those clubs still exists.

Wollongong should be a good football territory. When Danny Townsend, CEO of the Australian Professional Leagues (APL) which runs the A-League, was recently asked about the planned expansion of teams in 2024, he said:

“Obviously, Wollongong have been banging on the door for a while now.”

WIN Stadium has a capacity of 23,000, but the only green or gold evident the day after the Matildas’ record-breaking success was the empty grass on three sides of the stadium. The attendance was 2,540, the lowest number at WIN since 2,502 turned out for an A-League game between Wellington and Western Sydney Wanderers in December 2022. Two weeks before the Australia Cup game, 15,000 people watched an NRL game between the Dragons and the Sea Eagles.

The dawn of a new beginning for Australian professional football leagues? Where were the thousands of kids enthralled by the Matildas, suddenly captured by football and desperate to see more live action? They were at home posting to Instagram and TikTok on how much they love Sam Kerr and Mackenzie Arnold and the other Matildas. They were dreaming of becoming a Matilda but showed no interest in going to the best local football Australia can offer.

Australia is a ‘footballing nation’ when national pride and a winning team kicks in, or when Barcelona or Manchester United or Liverpool visit these shores, but not in big numbers when it comes to watching the local professional leagues. The media can barely find the space to report the scores.

The bright side and jumping on the bandwagon

Journalists and commentators caught up in the wonderful achievements of the Matildas were desperate for a headline to show their enthusiasm was greater than everyone else. Even The Australian Financial Review felt obliged to cover the event, with “How women saved Australian soccer”. The Sydney Morning Herald headline was “OMG, what a rush: The Matildas have made even nihilists believe.” Sports editors covered the game for the first time but revealed their true colours when they breathlessly wrote about Australia ‘kicking’ a goal. In football, goals are ‘scored’ not kicked.

Let’s look at some major positives first:

1. Participation

Football has never had a problem with participation. The Australian Sports Commission's official survey has long confirmed football is the most popular sport to play with 1.2 million participants, followed by golf (740,000), Aussie Rules (700,000) and tennis (650,000). Rugby league and rugby union are far behind.

Junior football clubs report that enquiry levels in the last month are up significantly, from both boys and girls, and the major headache now will not be lack of interest in playing football, but funding and finding the fields, facilities and referees to accommodate the demand. A recent Government promise to inject $200 million into women’s sport will help but it is not specifically for football, and will not go far spread across the country and many sports.

2. Matildas brand and support

The value of the Matildas brand has risen multiple times. They showed that women’s sport can attract immense crowds that are friendlier, welcoming and inclusive. The biggest problem at Stadium Australia was the long queues at the women’s toilets as the designers did not anticipate the rise in female demand.

In analysing the impact on the A-League, this article does not for one moment diminish what a wonderful event Australia staged, proving again that the country does big sport as well as anyone.

3. Attendance at A-League Women

All kids under the age of 16 can attend Liberty A-League (Women) games for free, as can anyone with a season ticket to the Men. Sydney FC women’s team is the current Champions and Premiers, and Courtnee Vine, the Matildas' penalty hero, plays on the right wing.

During the World Cup, Sydney FC announced it had broken the club’s A-League Women’s membership record two months ahead of the new season. While the club did not reveal the number, it is targeting 1,000 members.

So while the women’s competition should receive a good boost, it is from a very low base. The average attendance in 2022/2023 was 1,249 and although a healthy 9,519 attended the Grand Final, a month earlier, only 201 turned up to watch Western Sydney Wanderers, a club that should have one of the larger fan bases in the league.

What about the main game in town, A-League Men?

The new A-League season commences on 20 October 2023, two months after the conclusion of the Women’s World Cup.

How many new fans among the millions of Australians who watched football for the first time, who claim to finally ‘get it’, or the avid followers of the global game who have scorned the local version, will attend the opening game due to the Matildas' experience? My guess is not many.

As the chart below shows, the average attendance at the A-League last season was less than 8,000. Sydney FC is far ahead of all others with almost 17,000, boosted by a return to the $1 billion Allianz Stadium but not matching the levels of a decade ago. Previous high-flyers Western Sydney Wanderers, whose success at filling the 20,000-seat Parramatta Stadium in the early days led to the reconstruction of the ground to hold 30,000, now average only 12,000. The move from the old stadium was a disaster for the club compared with the excitement of the first few years. The previous best-attended club, Melbourne Victory, is a shadow of its former self at 10,000 last year and heaven knows why Macarthur and Western United owners campaigned so aggressively for entry to the A-League in 2020/2021. At 3,000 each, they have failed to attract a following, despite Western United being Champions in 2022.   

Total and Average Attendances, A-League Men, Season 2022/2023


Source: Ultimate A-League

The highest-profile Australian coach in the world is Ange Postecoglou, previously in charge of the Socceroos and Celtic and now at Tottenham Hotspur. There are few people more knowledgeable about Australian and global football. When asked whether football will finally “crack it in Australia” (SMH 21 August 2023), he replied:

“I battle with that, mate. I really don’t know if we will ever crack Australia. I hope so.”

Earlier, Postecoglou had reflected on his success with Australia in the Asian Cup in 2015:

“Where it is right now, it’s where it’s been many times. It’s what happens from now on ... we won the Asian Cup and barely a ripple.”

Sport in three: participation, commercial and jingoistic

Similarly, Colin Carter was a Commissioner with the AFL and a major factor in its modern success. He gives an informed perspective. He says:

“What the Matildas did was fantastic, but it’s unlikely to translate into all the things that people are imagining it will. That idea is grossly exaggerated ... People don’t watch second best in anything. On television, you can always see the best in the world.”

Carter divides sports into three: participation, commercial and jingoistic. He sees the Matildas and this World Cup in the last category of teams or events that create a short term but intense patriotic pride, without leaving a lasting legacy for their sport. The players will go back to their clubs, nearly all overseas, leaving behind fond memories and struggling A-League competitions, both men and women. As Carter points out, the best football in Europe attracts a big Australian following and that is part of the problem. In football, Australian players will always leave, unlike in Aussie Rules or Rugby League.

Unlike other sports, football in Australia is run by multiple bodies, and the fragmentation is part of the problem. There is no unified voice. The governing body for the Matildas and the Socceroos is Football Australia. APL represents the club owners and organises the A-Leagues. State competitions are managed by powerful state bodies.

It’s the commercial side of the local professional league based on attendance, broadcast views and overall sponsorship that is the ongoing failing. Media coverage is poor in all major newspapers, and radio and television stations, even after a full weekend of good games. Long-time backers of the A-League, Hyundai, NAB and Caltex, all failed to renew their contracts recently. Foxtel abandoned its coverage, Optus was not interested and a below-standard coverage is available on Paramount Plus.

Tony Sage, long-time owner of Perth Glory, has finally given up after injecting millions into the club over 18 years. He put out this scathing media release when announcing he would no longer finance the club. Newcastle Jets is looking for a new owner as it is currently in the hands of other clubs. Brisbane Roar owners want out. I doubt Tony Sage is looking at the success of the Matildas and regretting his exit.

Others are more optimistic. David Rowe, a Professor at Western Sydney University with special interest in sport and society, says:

“I’m a bit cautious, we’ve seen a few false dawns in the past. But on reflection, I actually do think this is a watershed moment. I don’t think there’s any going back from here. Quite how big the leap will be we still don’t know, but it’s substantial both for football and for women’s sport in general.”

The Matildas, yes. Women's sport, yes. Participation, yes. Better media coverage and attendance at the A-League, highly unlikely.

There is a lot of enthusiastic talk about how football has united a migrant nation, how it brings in shared cultures from different global backgrounds, and how boys and fathers will now understand that women can play competitive football in a superior spirt to the men. Fair enough, but will they now go to a game?

There have been too many false dawns to list for the local professional league, but let’s mention one: the recent men’s World Cup. Australia qualified for the knockout stage by defeating Denmark and Tunisia. The Socceroos pushed the  eventual winners, Argentina, all the way in a 2-1 loss. Like the Matildas, it was a time of national pride and football authorities hoped it would herald a new era of local interest.

Then came the disaster of the pitch invasion at Melbourne Victory and the assault on a goalkeeper, but even before that, there was little evidence of larger crowds, including when many Socceroos featured in the Sydney FC versus Melbourne City game. In fact, Melbourne City has been the best club in the league over the last three years and averages only 8,000 fans.

The APL and the clubs will work hard to attract more fans on 20 October 2023, although much of the joy of community and winning as one will have evaporated. Courtnee Vine has signed for another domestic season, and will feature as the face of the women’s competition this year. But nobody need worry whether they will be able to buy a ticket.   

A final word from Tony Gustavsson, the Matilda’s Swedish coach:

“It’s easy now when the spotlight is on all of us, but what about a week or 10 days from now? What are we doing to keep this going? To stay in this. And what are you guys (journalists) doing in a month from now or six months from now or a year from now to keep making sure the spotlight is on women’s football and investment keeps happening?”

Exactly. Regardless of how much we loved the World Cup, most people will move on to the next bright thing the media focusses on.

 

Graham Hand is Editor-at-Large for Firstlinks. He is a Foundation Member of Sydney FC, a season ticket holder for 19 years and rarely misses a home game. He would love to see more people at games, but don't try to sit in the seat he always occupies. Graham plays in an Over-60s football competition and has attended three men's World Cups in Germany (2006), South Africa (2010) and Brazil (2014).

 

12 Comments
George
August 25, 2023

I don't agree with Colin Carter than people only want to see the 'best' in the world. It overlooks the joys and added attraction of watching live football. TV misses so much. I like to watch what happens off the ball, where a midfielder stands when the team is attacking or defending, how the formations change, the runs that the cameras miss. I sometimes watch a particular player rather than the overall game. And how does only wanting watch the the best explain the fanatical crowds of South America and increasingly, Asia, when all their best players have also gone to Europe?

RR
August 25, 2023

Very well written, but a removal of the rose-tinted glasses..........

I think most sports fans (especially Aussies) will turn up to watch the best in their field, regardless of the actual sport being played. The Women's World Cup was a sell-out not because it was football, but because it showcased the best players in the world, and the Matildas were competitive.

The best footballers in Australia will never stay and play in Australia. Or Brazil, Argentina or Uruguay for that matter, where football is a religion. They will join the best leagues, where they can earn respect and of course more money.

The circus has left town ..........

Stephen
August 25, 2023

People generally follow sports they played in their youth. With so many playing football the game will likely be the most followed in the nation. Mostly it will be followed by attendance at Socceroos and Matildas matches and on the various streaming services that carry the English Professional League, the European Champions League, the World Cup and other overseas competitions. Attendance at the A League will run a distant second. Does that matter? Not so much. In comparison Rugby League is mainly a TV sport. It has relatively few participants. AFL has nowhere to go. It’s an Australian game and no one outside this country has the faintest interest in it. Football will be the most followed sport despite crowds at the A League being modest.

NeilB
August 24, 2023

I read that Sam Kerr grew up playing Aussie Rules since that was her family’s “DNA”. Imagine if she had continued - I hate to think.
There must be thousands of other talented kids that are playing Aussie rules but who would be gun soccer players instead. We just have to convince parents that their kids would be better off with soccer! I can think of several reasons - Money , international fame, less severe injuries etc.
Maybe a focus on head injuries will gradually reduce participation in afl and so effect a change in our sporting DNA.

John
August 24, 2023

Regarding the part about
"15,000 people watched an NRL game between the Dragons and the Sea Eagles".
And almost 100,000 sometimes turn up to Australian Rules football.
I watched The Matildas and the game was very skilful but against France it turned out a game between individuals and not a team sport. I believe this sort of thing happens quite often.
I also found it a bit frustrating and defensive. Was a bit one dimensional with no high and long distance kicking, marking and tackling. Unlike AFL which is more spectacular, high scoring and dynamic.

Stephen
August 25, 2023

"Was a bit one dimensional with no high and long distance kicking, marking and tackling. Unlike AFL which is more spectacular, high scoring and dynamic."

So what you are saying John is that the game didn't have the AFL elements in it (high kicks, marking, tackling, high scores). Which is absolutely correct because the game is not Australian Rules Football. As a football follower I would find a football game with high kicks and high scores to be pretty meh, I much prefer the skills (which includes preventing goals as well as scoring them) that football requires. You obviously prefer watching AFL to football, which is completely ok so continue to watch the AFL. No one ever will be forcing you to watch football if you don't want to.

Steve
August 25, 2023

Maaate,
Just thank someone up high that we don't play AFL internationally. The standard of our "elite" players is embarrassing at times. Missing set shots at goal from 25-30 metres, right in front. What the @#$%?

Of course the Matildas still have to live down the 7-1 thrashing from an U-15 boys side a few years ago, which puts a dint in their own claims of "eliteness". And therein I suspect lays a little seed of doubt over the calibre of our best ladies.......

George Hamor
August 27, 2023

But Steve, the US women’s football team was beaten by a junior boys team by a similar or greater margin.
Your comment says less about the fact that the Matildas may not have been in the elite class some time ago- although they have made great strides since- than the more obvious, that being that male footballers are far superior to females.

James Gruber
August 27, 2023

Steve and George, What point are you trying to make here? That male athletes are superior to women? Genetics dictates that is pretty obvious across most sports. Unlike probably both of you, I've been an elite athlete and know many sportspeople of both genders. And I know for instance that Serena Williams at her peak couldn't beat the men's world number 400. But that didn't mean people didn't find her enjoyable to watch and she has hundreds of millions in her bank account to prove it. People generally won't compare men's soccer to women's soccer as they generally don't compare men's tennis to women's tennis. It doesn't make women less elite sportspeople and less marketable to a wider audience. That's nonsense. And if it encourages young girls to take up a sport that they can play for the rest of their lives, all the better.

Mart
August 24, 2023

Graham - my feelings exactly. And Colin Carter is right too. Interesting having girls and boys who play soccer and AFL (in Melbourne). Whilst the soccer participation numbers are huge the teams (and clubs) are run on best efforts / dedicated volunteer basis typically. The usual story - a few dedicated volunteers are typically the ones who do the bulk of what work is needed. The contrast with AFL is stark - in our AFL teams multiple parents have match day / behind scenes work and the clubs are way better resourced / run. I think this is because AFL is "the Aussie sport" and we've had a similar experience with cricket too. I also get the feeling this translates to the professional level ... i.e. compare how AFL clubs are run / marketed compared to A League, again a stark difference. It's interesting the Australian Rugby has just announced a 'takeover' of the Aussie Super League rugby teams to try and increase performance / success ... at least they are having a crack and you'd have to think a centralised approach would be better over time in terms of success ? I suspect that would benefit soccer too but don't see it happening any time soon ........

Dave
August 24, 2023

An excellent and thorough article but you bring a minority consumer perspective. You are obviously very frustrated and disappointed by the public’s response to the A-L. Mr Carter summarised the issue... People don’t watch second best in anything. On television, you can always see the best in the world.”

Young people enjoy playing and the excitement and camaraderie that brings but they don’t want to watch in an empty stadium. Look what’s written on the back of kids jerseys. Messi, Neymar ($670K per day) but not any A-League players.

Neil
August 24, 2023

Agreed. The other important thing to note is that in most areas of the world where football is the dominant code, the commercial opportunities generate the interest (whether that be fans or media or sponsors) and therefore $. In Australia, we have four football codes – if we only had one, the proposition would be very different…but we don’t, and we won’t (in my lifetime).

 

Leave a Comment:

     

RELATED ARTICLES

The numbers behind Australia’s record-breaking Olympics

Julie Bishop on leaders, life, Liberals and libertines

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Vale Graham Hand

It’s with heavy hearts that we announce Firstlinks’ co-founder and former Managing Editor, Graham Hand, has died aged 66. Graham was a legendary figure in the finance industry and here are three tributes to him.

Warren Buffett is preparing for a bear market. Should you?

Berkshire Hathaway’s third quarter earnings update reveals Buffett is selling stocks and building record cash reserves. Here’s a look at his track record in calling market tops and whether you should follow his lead and dial down risk.

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 583 with weekend update

Investing guru Howard Marks says he had two epiphanies while visiting Australia recently: the two major asset classes aren’t what you think they are, and one key decision matters above all else when building portfolios.

  • 24 October 2024

A big win for bank customers against scammers

A recent ruling from The Australian Financial Complaints Authority may herald a new era for financial scams. For the first time, a bank is being forced to reimburse a customer for the amount they were scammed.

The gentle art of death cleaning

Most of us don't want to think about death. But there is a compelling reason why we do need to plan ahead, and that's because leaving our loved ones with a mess - financial or otherwise - is not how we want them to remember us.

Why has nothing worked to fix Australia's housing mess?

Why has a succession of inquiries and reports, along with a plethora of academic papers, not led to effective action to improve housing affordability? Because the work has been aimless and unsupported by a national consensus.

Latest Updates

90% of housing is unaffordable for average Australians

A new report shows that only 10% of the housing market is genuinely affordable for the median income family, and that drops to 0% for those on low incomes. This may be positive for the apartment market though.

Taxpayers betrayed by Future Fund debacle

The Future Fund's original purpose was to meet the unfunded liabilities of Commonwealth defined benefit schemes. These liabilities have ballooned to an estimated $290 billion and taxpayers continue to be treated like fools.

Property

The net benefit of living in Australia’s cities has fallen dramatically

Rising urban housing costs in Australia are outpacing wage growth, particularly in cities like Sydney and Melbourne. This is leading to an exodus of workers, especially in their 30s, from cities to regions. 

Shares

Fending off short sellers and gaining conviction in a stock

Taking the path less travelled led to a remarkable return from this small-cap. Here is the inside track on how our investment unfolded, and why we don't think the story has finished yet.

Planning

The nuts and bolts of testamentary trusts

Unlike family trusts, testamentary trusts are activated posthumously, empowering you to exert post-death control over your assets. Learn how testamentary trusts offer unique benefits and protective measures.

Investing

The US market outlook is more nuanced than it seems

Investors are getting back to business after a tumultuous election year. Weighing up the fundamentals is complicated, however, by policy crosscurrents that splinter the outlook in several industries.

Investing

Book and podcast recommendations for the summer

Dive into these recommendations for your summer reading and listening. Uncover the genius behind a secretive hedge fund, debunk healthcare myths, and explore the Cuban Missile Crisis in gripping detail.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2024 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.