Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 177

US shares at new highs, but where's Australia?

US share prices have been doing well this year. The broad market indexes have reached new all-time highs, finally topping their previous peaks at the top of the 1990s ‘dot com’ boom and the 2000s credit boom.

The chart below shows four of the main US market indexes over the past four decades.



Click to enlarge

This shows that the current boom is not confined to just a few ‘hot stocks’, but enjoyed by the whole market. The Dow Jones Industrial Average measures the prices of just 30 of the largest stocks including Apple, Microsoft, IBM, McDonalds, Coca-Cola and Disney. The S&P 500 index covers 500 large and mid-sized companies, and the Wilshire 5000 index covers 5000 companies including thousands of small and micro stocks. The NASDAQ composite is heavily weighted toward technology companies.

The stock market boom in the US has been driven by two main factors: low interest rates and the global smart phone revolution. However, the US Federal Reserve turned off the ‘QE’ tap in 2014 and started raising interest rates in December 2015. The US government has also been tightening fiscal policy in recent years with progressively lower budget deficits. So the boom is overcoming the twin headwinds of tightening monetary and fiscal policies.

The main driving force has been the global technology revolution. The smart phone is changing how billions of people in virtually every country on the planet go about their daily lives. New technology is also revolutionising how businesses operate, from cloud computing to inventory management to accounting.

All of this requires new hardware and software. Factory workers in low wage countries build the hardware out of rocks dug up from quarries like Australia. But the real money is in the know-how and software and those come mostly from American companies. The American economy may be struggling to get back to normal growth but American companies are leading the global technology revolution.

Australian versus US shares

US shares have beaten Australian shares handsomely over the past five years despite Australia enjoying stronger economic growth and population growth.

The US S&P500 Price Index is 40% above its 2007 high, and with dividends, it is 70% above. The Total Return series after US inflation is 48% above 2007 highs. But the Australian All Ords Price Index is still 18% below its 2007 highs. With dividends it is 20% above, but the Total Return series after local inflation is still 2% below the peak (these numbers are to end September 2016).

A better comparison is an Australian investor in Australian shares after Australian inflation versus the same Australian investor in US shares after Australian inflation (that is, an Australian investor can chose to invest in either Australian shares or US shares but suffers Australian inflation either way). Then US shares Total Returns less Australian inflation is +66% since 2007 high versus -2% for Australian shares. The difference is the currency effect of a falling AUD and higher inflation here than in the US. Investors tend to ignore inflation when comparing long-term performance.

Here is the longer term picture.

Both markets have returned average real total returns (including dividends and after CPI inflation) of 6.5% per year since 1900. While the real total returns have been the same, the components of returns have been different. Australian shares have delivered higher nominal price growth and higher dividend yields than US shares, but these benefits have been neutralised by Australia’s higher inflation rate, so the net real total returns after inflation have been the same in both markets.

The two markets have also followed different paths along the way. The next chart shows the accumulated real total returns from both markets – green for Australia and red for the US.

real-total-returns-from-shares-aus-vs-us-since-1900 Click to enlarge

The lower section shows when Australia was winning (positive green bars) and when the US was winning (negative red bars). Both markets have risen in global booms and then fallen in the global busts, but Australia and the US have taken turns in having bigger booms and busts.

Starting from the right side of the chart we see that Australia had a bigger 2000s boom than the US, and so it suffered worse in the 2008 bust. On the other hand, the US had a much bigger ‘dot com’ boom in the late 1990s, so it had a more severe ‘tech wreck’ in 2001 and 2002. Australia had a much bigger mid 1980s ‘entrepreneurial’ boom (Bond, Skase, Herscue, Elliott, Connell and the rest), and so it had further to fall in the 1987 crash. And so it goes back through history.

The fact that the US market has been winning in recent years is more a reflection of our bigger 2000s boom and our bigger bust in the GFC. Australia and the US both had a credit boom in the 2000s but Australia also had a mining boom that crashed as well, and it is still recovering.

So it is America’s turn, and we are seeing it already with the US clearly leading the global technology boom.


Ashley Owen is Chief Investment Officer at independent advisory firm Stanford Brown and The Lunar Group. He is also a Director of Third Link Investment Managers, a fund that supports Australian charities. These past returns are not an indication of future returns.


US will fall more than Australia in next bust


Most viewed in recent weeks

How to include homes in the age pension assets test

A reader speaks out about the inequity of ignoring own homes in the assets test for the age pension, plus a proposal on how it could work politically. Take our survey on the merit of the policy. 

How much super is enough?

We cannot see into the future, but here are some general guidelines on how much to save in super, and then how much you can spend to enjoy a good retirement. Start as soon as possible.

Four reasons to engage a financial adviser

The value of financial advice is increasingly questioned after the Royal Commission and changes to advice business models, but the case for financial advice for many people remains strong.

Should you buy CBA PERLS XII Capital Notes?

CBA's latest PERLS offer is directly offered to hundreds of thousands of investors who already hold CBA shares or other PERLS securities. How does it compare with the rest of the hybrid market? 

Reader poll on the home in pension assets test

Two-thirds of the responses to our reader poll say the family home should be included in some way in the age pension assets test, but the comments show it is an emotional and divisive subject. 

Latest Updates


OK Boomer: fessing up that we’ve had it good

The pre-Boomer generations faced global wars and depressions, but Australians born after 1946 have enjoyed prosperity. Superannuation, education, strong markets and surging property prices locked in gains.  

Investment strategies

Young women are investing more in shares

Young woment are showing increasing confidence in the sharemarket, promising a better future than the Boomers and Gen X women who hold significantly less assets than males of their generation.  

Investment strategies

Shorting deserves more respect

A fund manager that can short sell stocks with weak investment characteristics while reinvesting the proceeds in long positions in preferred stocks has a high degree of flexibility.


Policymakers fear cutting stimulus can lead to recession

Prolonging a recovery with stimulus could lead to a worse slump later. Even today, policymakers are haunted by actions taken in 1937 which led to a loss of production and jobs and a falling GDP.


Bank reporting season scorecard for FY19

Our annual scorecard for Australian banks shows earnings were hit by remediation costs and slow credit growth, but they are in good health and look attractive versus other listed companies. 



Special eBooks

Specially-selected collections of the best articles 

Read more

Earn CPD Hours

Accredited CPD hours reading Firstlinks

Read more

Pandora Archive

Firstlinks articles are collected in Pandora, Australia's national archive.

Read more