Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 301

Caveat auditor and feeble SMSF investment strategies

As lawyers in the area of wealth, we always read cases for interesting legal issues that affect us and our clients. However, two recent cases resonate for the people who refer clients to us.

They show the risk to professionals who are not even giving the financial advice arising from investments which may go down as well as up. An Irish expression is, “It could have happened to a bishop” and, we can now add “It could have happened to an auditor.”

Case 1: Audits are not simply high level reviews

The first case is Ryan Wealth Holdings Pty Ltd v Baumgartner [2018] NSWSC 1502 which arose from a divorcee, Ms Crittle, entrusting her $7 million property settlement with a Mr Moylan from Charlestown near Newcastle. She met Mr Moylan because her lawyer, Mr Turnbull of Turnbull Hill Lawyers, had offices on the same floor as him and he introduced her. You can see how this can happen, but it is rarely in the client’s best interests.

Audits are sometimes considered high level reviews of other people’s advice and decisions but when things go bad, lawyers will look to who to blame. The person who has to pay is not always the bad guy. In this case, the investments were worthless and most of the key companies were in liquidation, the advisers Mr Moylan and Mr Turnbull were bankrupts and their professional indemnity policies had lapsed. So they initiated proceedings against the auditor, Baumgartner Partners.

Baumgartner Partners undertook audits for the fund making the investments for the financial years ending 2007 to 2009. Their problem was that the investment strategy for those years was bland to the point of meaningless. It said the strategy for each investment class was “a normal investment range for each type of investment shall be: … 0% to 100%”.

We act for many excellent investment managers and they put a huge amount of effort and intellectual capital into the design of their asset allocation. It is considered the holy grail. So, when there is a bad strategy, it looks terrible.

The auditors claimed Ms Crittle was only entitled to an award of nominal damages of $300 in total for the admitted breach of the retainers. The Court found the client Ms Crittle 10% responsible and the auditors 90% responsible in this case, and 90% amounted to $2,034,126 plus costs. Of that, the Court found that Moylan Business Solutions Pty Limited should be responsible for 20%. It's a lot of money no matter who is counting it!

The lesson for professionals is to be careful who they introduce to clients.

Case 2: Auditor needs to look behind the accounts

In another recent case, the NSW Court of Appeal in the case of Cam & Bear Pty Ltd v McGoldrick [2018] NSWCA 110, was asked to consider whether the actions of an SMSF auditor, John McGoldrick, caused the losses suffered by an SMSF. The trustee of the SMSF, Cam & Bear, was established for Dr Lance Bear and his wife, Ms Jennifer Campbell. Dr Bear and Ms Campbell were directors of the trustee for the SMSF.

Some years after the SMSF was established, a close friend of Dr Bear, Mr Anthony Lewis, who conducted a finance business, offered to manage the fund’s investments. Sadly, this was not Dr Bear’s best decision and Mr Lewis’ advice resulted in heavy losses. The Court found: "The damage was, as made clear in the judgment on liability, caused by the conduct of LSL Holdings, Mr Tony Lewis and Databank (if they be different).”

We applaud funny names like 'Cam & Bear' mainly because we love cheese. However, no-one was laughing except perhaps the lawyers after the initial seven-day hearing and then the appeal.

The main issue was whether the auditor should have looked behind a description in the accounts of “Cash – LS Holdings P/L” to see whether it was cash or cash equivalents.  LS Holdings P/L was of course the vehicle for Mr Lewis. The poor Doctor had to give evidence as to his inferior understanding of investments and even cash. These were more correctly loans to that company but not necessarily recoverable.

Again, 10% of the loss was attributable to the trustee and 90% to the auditor but arguably Mr Lewis was more to blame.

We may complain that the bad guys got away again but these decisions are not surprising to those of us who read the cases and act in them. The practical solution is to have advisers that will be around to assist if things do not go to plan.

We know that most investment strategies for SMSFs are vague and not prepared by specialists in asset allocation. That is a form of madness and, in our experience, people who set up SMSFs sometimes suffer from taking their own advice or that of friends. We commend professional advisers and can give names if you contact us directly.

 

Donal Griffin is the Principal of Legacy Law, a Sydney-based legal firm specialising in protecting family assets. The firm is not licensed to give financial advice. This article does not consider any individual circumstances and Cuffelinks does not know the merits or otherwise of the case.

RELATED ARTICLES

Clime time: Asset allocation decisions for SMSFs

Avoid complacency with your SMSF's investment strategy

Court holds SMSF trustees accountable

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Raising the GST to 15%

Treasurer Jim Chalmers aims to tackle tax reform but faces challenges. Previous reviews struggled due to political sensitivities, highlighting the need for comprehensive and politically feasible change.

7 examples of how the new super tax will be calculated

You've no doubt heard about Division 296. These case studies show what people at various levels above the $3 million threshold might need to pay the ATO, with examples ranging from under $500 to more than $35,000.

The revolt against Baby Boomer wealth

The $3m super tax could be put down to the Government needing money and the wealthy being easy targets. It’s deeper than that though and this looks at the factors behind the policy and why more taxes on the wealthy are coming.

Meg on SMSFs: Withdrawing assets ahead of the $3m super tax

The super tax has caused an almighty scuffle, but for SMSFs impacted by the proposed tax, a big question remains: what should they do now? Here are ideas for those wanting to withdraw money from their SMSF.

Are franking credits hurting Australia’s economy?

Business investment and per capita GDP have languished over the past decade and the Labor Government is conducting inquiries to find out why. Franking credits should be part of the debate about our stalling economy.

Here's what should replace the $3 million super tax

With Div. 296 looming, is there a smarter way to tax superannuation? This proposes a fairer, income-linked alternative that respects compounding, ensures predictability, and avoids taxing unrealised capital gains. 

Latest Updates

Investment strategies

9 winning investment strategies

There are many ways to invest in stocks, but some strategies are more effective than others. Here are nine tried and tested investment approaches - choosing one of these can improve your chances of reaching your financial goals.

Planning

Super, death and taxes – time to rethink your estate plans?

The $3 million super tax has many rethinking their super strategies, especially issues of wealth transfer on death. This reviews the taxes on super benefits and offers investment alternatives.

Taxation

Raising the GST to 15%

Treasurer Jim Chalmers aims to tackle tax reform but faces challenges. Previous reviews struggled due to political sensitivities, highlighting the need for comprehensive and politically feasible change.

Shares

The megatrend you simply cannot ignore

Markets are reassessing the impact of AI, with initial euphoria giving way to growing scepticism. This shift is evident in the performance of ASX-listed AI beneficiaries, creating potential opportunities.

Gold

Is this the real reason for gold's surge past $3,000?

Concerns over the US fiscal position seem to have overtaken geopolitics and interest rates as the biggest tailwind for gold prices. Even if a debt crisis doesn't seem likely, there could be more support on the way.

Exchange traded products

Is now the time to invest in small caps?

With further RBA rate cuts forecast this year, small caps may be key beneficiaries. There are quality small cap LICs and LITs trading at discounts to net assets, offering opportunities for astute investors.

Strategy

Welcome to the grey war

Forget speculation about a future US-China conflict - it's already happening. Through cyberwarfare and propaganda, China is waging a grey war designed to weaken democracies without firing a single shot.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2025 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.