Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 486

Four principles for choosing the right active manager

Most investors now realise their portfolio can, and probably should, be made up of a diversified set of investments that balance lower-cost and usually lower-return passive funds with those that are actively managed with a higher fee but usually higher returns in the long-term.

However, that is easier said than done. For passive options there are many things to consider, but the key question remains price. Meanwhile, with active managers, the dilemma for investors is in identifying skilled managers for the long-term. And when data suggests the majority (around 75%) of active fund managers underperform their benchmarks, that may raise the question whether it’s worth it at all.

That statistic, however, shouldn’t come as a surprise. Like a seesaw or a set of balancing scales, in the investment markets there is always a buyer and a seller and if one makes a profit, the other has to make a loss.

Therefore, not everyone can outperform the market – it’s just simple maths!

Making the right choice

Of course, that doesn’t mean that investors should give up and just stuff their money under the mattress. It’s just that instead of striving for the impossible – perfect – performance they should understand that even a modest outperformance can make a big difference to their portfolios over the longer term.

But to do that, investors need to identify managers that have a particular set of skills - they should be unique, transparent and have a sustainable long-term advantage that is difficult to replicate.

We believe there are four principles that can be helpful in narrowing down the field, that are typically overlooked by investors in general.

1. Understand the incentives

This is another way of asking whether their interests are aligned with yours, as incentives are strong drivers of human behaviour.

One example of this in the investment world is often described as ‘herding’ or ‘momentum’ where investors tend to follow the crowd. This can sometimes be driven by fears of career risk, where fund managers might prefer to play it safe and stay in line with their peers to protect their job, rather than take a different position and potentially risk underperformance and standing out from the crowd.

Key things to look for that show a manager is more aligned with their clients’ interests:

The ownership structure – Is fund management a key focus for the business, or a side hustle? Is it privately owned, or are there thousands of external shareholders driving behaviour and requesting shorter-term results rather than thinking long-term?

Co-investment – According to Morningstar, only half of all US mutual fund managers invest their own money in their funds. Does your manager put their money where their mouth is?

Performance fees – Do they benefit the manager no matter whether they under or outperform or are they dependent on actual results?

Activism – Does the manager make use of opportunities to potentially influence companies towards shareholder best interests. This could include things like engaging on remuneration, and corporate governance.

2. Focus on the long-term

Investors should remind themselves that when buying shares, they are investing in a business. This is sometimes ignored, as is evident by the fact that the average holding period for shares listed on the New York Stock Exchange is about 5.5 months. Is your manager making decisions based on the long-term fundamentals, or on short-term noise? Or a combination of both?

3. Be sceptical of overconfidence – especially about the future

The future is more uncertain than people believe, and many investors are prone to overconfidence in their assumptions and their ability to interpret information.

Though it is tempting to think that we can accurately predict the future, history tells us a different story. The key is to accept no-one can predict the future, but even modest outperformance compounded over time can make a big difference.

4. Embrace creativity

This is not opposing consensus for the sake of it, but rather being independent thinkers and looking at the counter view to the more popular one. As mentioned above, humans like to stick with the herd and look at what other people have done and say that’s probably the right thing to do. But there are exceptions, and investing is one of them.

This is because share prices don’t move based on the outcome of some event. They move based on the difference between the outcome and what people expected the outcome to be. So, for contrarian investors it comes down to finding opportunities where the outcomes are likely to be better than the expectations.

Thinking differently

The more successful investors over the years are those that look at the wider picture, and many active managers have evolved to do just that.

We try to only invest in a company once we have a strong view of what it’s worth (its intrinsic value) and aim to buy its shares at a price that is below that. But you have to understand the reasons why the seller is selling at a lower value.

We also tend to try and let other people take it off our hands once the share goes past our estimate of fair value. We can then invest those proceeds into something that we think is unfairly priced.

Sometimes people say that contrarian investing, opposing the consensus, comes with more risk. But our view is that it’s actually a risk averse approach as you’re seeking to avoid overpaying for shares that are very overpriced.

While we may not get it right all the time, as we’ve discussed, no-one can do that, but to create modest outperformance consistently over the long-term is a goal that we are proud to pursue.

 

 

Shane Woldendorp, Investment Specialist, Orbis Investments, a sponsor of Firstlinks. This article contains general information at a point in time and not personal financial or investment advice. It should not be used as a guide to invest or trade and does not take into account the specific investment objectives or financial situation of any particular person. The Orbis Funds may take a different view depending on facts and circumstances. For more articles and papers from Orbis, please click here.

 

5 Comments
michael
November 30, 2022

Thank you for a thoughtful article.

" But you have to understand the reasons why the seller is selling at a lower value."
I can't understand the reasoning for this point. If you have done your homework, what does someone else's decision matter, unless the seller is an insider? With the ASX, you don't know who you are buying from, so how do you find out why they are selling?

Dudley
November 30, 2022

"The rare few can and do.": If investor long term returns are normally distributed, or some such, then one in a billion will make a squillion.

John
November 30, 2022

For any active manager to outperform the market, they have to be doing things better than their "average" opposition. To achieve that, they need to have insight over and above their opposition. As rightly pointed out, for someone to outperform the average, someone has to under perform. The numbers seem to suggest that no single active manager can consistently out perform the market. The problem is, lets assume that EVERYONE comes to the conclusion that active managers can't outperform the market, and EVERYONE then decides to go passive/index. The result will be that EVERYONE is following NO-ONE - a sure recipe for disaster In the meantime, those choosing the passive approach, are effectively getting the analysis of the average of all active managers at (almost) no cost (the cost being paid by those who chose to go active)

Adam
November 30, 2022

Sorry Shane but anybody that believes one manager/team/business/person can pick companies that are better than anybody else, consistently, long term, forever..is fooling themselves.

James
November 30, 2022

Better ring Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, Steve Lynch .......etc and tell them they're kidding themselves then! The rare few can and do.

Many great pretenders that like to quote Buffet in their sales spiels though! For us mere mortals maybe an index fund is best or buy Berkshire shares!

 

Leave a Comment:

RELATED ARTICLES

A contrarian bet on Magellan Financial Group

Active or passive – it’s time to change the narrative

Investors don't forecast well, and that's good news

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Australian house prices close in on world record

Sydney is set to become the world’s most expensive city for housing over the next 12 months, a new report shows. Our other major cities aren’t far behind unless there are major changes to improve housing affordability.

The case for the $3 million super tax

The Government's proposed tax has copped a lot of flack though I think it's a reasonable approach to improve the long-term sustainability of superannuation and the retirement income system. Here’s why.

Tariffs are a smokescreen to Trump's real endgame

Behind market volatility and tariff threats lies a deeper strategy. Trump’s real goal isn’t trade reform but managing America's massive debts, preserving bond market confidence, and preparing for potential QE.

The super tax and the defined benefits scandal

Australia's superannuation inequities date back to poor decisions made by Parliament two decades ago. If super for the wealthy needs resetting, so too does the defined benefits schemes for our public servants.

Meg on SMSFs: Withdrawing assets ahead of the $3m super tax

The super tax has caused an almighty scuffle, but for SMSFs impacted by the proposed tax, a big question remains: what should they do now? Here are ideas for those wanting to withdraw money from their SMSF.

Getting rich vs staying rich

Strategies to get rich versus stay rich are markedly different. Here is a look at the five main ways to get rich, including through work, business, investing and luck, as well as those that preserve wealth.

Latest Updates

SMSF strategies

Meg on SMSFs: Withdrawing assets ahead of the $3m super tax

The super tax has caused an almighty scuffle, but for SMSFs impacted by the proposed tax, a big question remains: what should they do now? Here are ideas for those wanting to withdraw money from their SMSF.

Superannuation

The huge cost of super tax concessions

The current net annual cost of superannuation tax subsidies is around $40 billion, growing to more than $110 billion by 2060. These subsidies have always been bad policy, representing a waste of taxpayers' money.

Planning

How to avoid inheritance fights

Inspired by the papal conclave, this explores how families can avoid post-death drama through honest conversations, better planning, and trial runs - so there are no surprises when it really matters.

Superannuation

Super contribution splitting

Super contribution splitting allows couples to divide before-tax contributions to super between spouses, maximizing savings. It’s not for everyone, but in the right circumstances, it can be a smart strategy worth exploring.

Economy

Trump vs Powell: Who will blink first?

The US economy faces an unprecedented clash in leadership styles, but the President and Fed Chair could both take a lesson from the other. Not least because the fiscal and monetary authorities need to work together.

Gold

Credit cuts, rising risks, and the case for gold

Shares trade at steep valuations despite higher risks of a recession. Amid doubts that a 60/40 portfolio can still provide enough protection through times of market stress, gold's record shines bright.

Investment strategies

Buffett acolyte warns passive investors of mediocre future returns

While Chris Bloomstan doesn't have the track record of his hero, it's impressive nonetheless. And he's recently warned that today has uncanny resemblances to the 1990s tech bubble and US returns are likely to be disappointing.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2025 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.