Home / 298

Review: Howard Marks on the market cycle

Howard Marks has long been regarded as one of the great investment communicators; wise enough to understand how investment markets work and witty enough to explain it in an interesting way. His ad-hoc memos always receive broad coverage and are considered essential reading by many including Warren Buffett.

Marks' recently released book, 'Mastering the Market Cycle', combines new material with passages from some of his historical memos. The subtitle, 'Getting the odds on your side' explains the reason for the book. He regularly asks the question, "Where are we at in the market cycle"?

It's not about knowing the future

From the outset, Marks is explicit that no one can know the future, particularly regarding market timing. Those who are given credit for calling the top of one cycle almost never repeat that feat again. However, investors should plan and invest with the market position in mind. Whilst the probabilities are never certain, they are often slanted towards above- or below- average future returns. The pendulum of market cycles often swings well past the mid-point, creating opportunities for patient investors to buy assets cheaply and sell them richly.

Marks is pragmatic in his advice. Even if an institutional investor could perfectly predict the peak or trough, it would be impossible to trade everything near that level given the relative illiquidity in markets for large portfolios. Marks notes how his firm, Oaktree Capital, was raising capital in 2007 and 2008, then started buying heavily in late 2008, all ahead of the market’s nadir in March 2009. If Oaktree had waited, it simply would not have been able to deploy its capital in meaningful size before the bargains were grabbed by others.

Structure of the book

Marks explains the characteristics of market cycles and the frequency with which they occur. Readers are then taken through chapters on the economic cycle and its impacts on the cycle of company profits, followed by investment psychology and attitudes to risk as the market cycle evolves. The book flows onto an analysis of the credit cycle, distressed debt cycle and property cycle, with the three interlinked as the boom and bust of credit cycles creates the other two. Marks finishes off with chapters on coping and positioning for market cycles, and a reminder that human behaviour isn’t always rational.

Marks’ book has the potential to either engage readers or frustrate them, over two types of repetition: reusing slabs of his memos, and repeating points from previous chapters before progressing. I was fine with this method but I’ve spoken to others who found it annoying.

The final chapter is a 22-page summary, a quick review which might be helpful for a professional before an asset allocation meeting.

Key risk lessons in market timing and asset allocation

Three key components of investment returns are market timing, asset allocation and security selection. Marks focusses on the first two.

Evaluating what the crowd is doing is partly art and partly science. The art is judging whether investors are seeing risk everywhere or ignoring risk everywhere, an ability enhanced by experience but never really definable. It often comes back to the anecdotes of stock tips from amateurs and people investing with expectations of rapid gains. The science aspect is more definable, for example P/E ratios for stocks and credit spreads on debt instruments. Marks notes that perceived risk dictates future long-term returns, in that when everyone is fearful long-term returns are likely to be above average and when optimism abounds, below-average returns lie ahead.

The impact of credit on economic and market cycles in chapters nine to eleven are compulsory reading. Marks sums up the impact of bad lending with: “look around the next time there’s a crisis; you’ll probably find a lender”. Excessive risk taking in lending inflates asset prices, particularly in sectors like property and infrastructure that use large amounts of leverage. The widespread withdrawal of credit, as lenders switch from being risk embracing to risk averse, leads to bankruptcies and fire sales of assets.

Market timing and asset allocation are highly interlinked. Market timing is not as simple as increasing cash and reducing risk assets or vice versa, it is nuanced across and within asset classes. For instance, a late cycle view on credit points to owing higher-rated securities and having lower credit duration across a portfolio. But it also has implications for bank equity, with the likelihood that credit losses will increase from their current low levels, reducing future bank profits.

An Oaktree crisis story

For portfolio managers, Marks inclusion of an Oaktree crisis story on pages 129-134 is a standout. He details how Oaktree had started managing geared funds of leveraged (sub-investment grade) loans in the years before the crisis. As loan prices declined and margin calls were imminent, Marks had to visit clients and plead with them to add more equity to their position in one fund. He could not convince all investors to add to their positions but saved the fund by adding either his own or Oaktree’s capital and reaping a great return as a result. Marks uses the story as an illustration of an investor’s irrational risk avoidance, but there are far deeper lessons for portfolio managers which he leaves out.

First, Oaktree should never have been in a situation where it was facing margin calls on its funds. When leverage is used, it should be locked in for a long enough period for the underlying assets to materially paydown the debt from normal cashflows. Strategies that include borrowing short to lend long (e.g. structured investment vehicles in 2007/2008) or giving lenders control via mark to market triggers (e.g. LTCM in 1998), have a long history of blowing portfolio managers out of their positions.

Second, using leverage creates the wrong conversation at the wrong time. Margin calls always occur at the most inconvenient time and will almost always be seen by clients as mismanagement on the part of the portfolio manager. Rather than pleading for more equity for a precariously placed fund, Oaktree should have been pointing to the good management on its existing funds and asking for additional capital for a new distressed debt fund.

Going beyond the book

Howard Marks sticks to high level commentary and strategy in his writing and interviews. This is understandable given his role as Chairman and face of Oaktree, which would involve far more time on marketing and client engagement than 'on the tools' investment analysis. However, I like to give more detail on what I’m doing with the capital I’m entrusted with.

I’m in hearty agreement with Marks that we are late in the cycle but simply cannot know how long it will be before there is a meaningful downturn. Sell-offs in late 2015 and late 2018 turned out to be blips rather than busts. Holding cash and hoping that the next major downturn will arrive soon is both unprofitable and unnecessary for credit investors.

I’m finding plenty of opportunities to invest in low risk, short duration securities. What I’m typically giving up is immediate liquidity, instead getting liquidity from a portfolio of securities that predominantly matures or amortises over the next 6-24 months. It’s a case of fishing in a different pond, rather than fighting with the crowd who are seeking higher returns from subordinated securities, by extending duration and by giving up covenants.

This delivers on almost all of what clients are looking for. They have below average risk, they receive good returns (often equivalent to the long-term average returns of listed equities) and they will have cash available when asset prices fall and the bargains are there. The portfolios have also been surprisingly stable month to month, experiencing little of the losses seen through the sell-off late last year.

One final point on the value of market timing. Using basic estimates of long-term returns, inflation and asset prices through the cycle, 15 years of alpha can be made in 5 years from buying crossover (BBB/BB) credit securities towards the bottom of the credit cycle. This demonstrates the optionality from having near-term maturities in a credit portfolio during buoyant times. There may be underperformance of 1-2% per year for two to three years before a downturn occurs, but this can be recouped many times over through buying bargain securities in the downturn.


Jonathan Rochford, CFA, is Portfolio Manager for Narrow Road Capital. This article is for general information purposes only and does not consider the circumstances of any investor.


Howard Marks and his 'Latest Thinking'

Howard Marks: move forward with caution

Most Viewed

Retirees facing steep increases for basic items

ASFA has updated its tables on how much money is needed for a 'comfortable' or 'modest' lifestyle in retirement, but there are some unavoidable prices rising well ahead of inflation.

Let’s stop calling them ‘bond proxies’

With cash and term deposit rates at all-time lows, and fixed interest bonds not much better, investors are looking for ‘bond proxies’ to deliver more income. But is ‘proxy’ a misnomer, and what are they anyway?

Adele Ferguson on ‘Banking Bad’ and weaving magic

The journalist most responsible for the calling of the Royal Commission takes care not to be roped in by everyone with a complaint to push. It takes experienced judgement to gather the right information.

Six warning bells against property spruikers

Property spruikers use common techniques, and con men will increasingly target older people who feel they do not have enough financial independence for their retirement years.

Helping your children build their super

It has become more difficult to build large superannuation balances with contribution caps and more people paying off home loans for longer. How can wealthy parents help their adult children?





Special eBooks

Specially-selected collections of the best articles 

Read more

Earn CPD Hours

Accredited CPD hours reading Firstlinks

Read more

Pandora Archive

Firstlinks articles are collected in Pandora, Australia's national archive.

Read more