Register For Our Mailing List

Register to receive our free weekly newsletter including editorials.

Home / 274

Active or passive ETFs: how do you decide?

Working for an Exchange Traded Fund (ETF) manager, investors might presume that I’ll always favour a simple passive index-tracking ETF. Whilst I may think that indexing is the way to go most of the time because of the instant diversification, lower costs, and the historical inability of the majority of active managers to outperform their benchmarks, active strategies have their role in portfolios.

However, as an investor, how do you decide which approach to use?

The evolution of ETFs

Exchange traded products have gone through an evolution over the years like products in other industries:

  1. At first there were passive index-tracking ETFs which seek to mirror the performance of a specific investment index, and which often utilise a simple market-cap weighted methodology or aim to track a specific commodity or currency, or group of commodities and currencies.

  1. Then came smart beta or rules-based exchange traded products, typically using a systematic investment approach. Some of these approaches can still be index tracking. However, such indices typically go beyond market-cap weighted methodologies and may consider factors like size, value and volatility as an alternative weighting methodology. Other products may not track an index but still use a prescriptive set of rules as part of their investment objectives (for example, yield-oriented buy-write strategies or funds that aim to provide short exposure to share markets).

  1. More recently, active ETFs have portfolio managers making decisions on the underlying portfolio composition and do not try to mirror the performance of any underlying index. Instead, typically the manager’s main goal is to outperform a benchmark index by actively trading or changing sector allocations.

What should an investor take into consideration when deciding whether to select active or passive investment strategies? Here are three considerations:

1. How efficient is the underlying market?

There are segments of the market that are inefficient, giving an opportunity to exploit mis-pricing and potentially deliver outperformance, or ‘alpha’. Active management or smart beta, rules-based strategies may do better. Two examples are hybrids and small cap markets.

In hybrids, an active manager can potentially add value over an index-tracking approach by accessing deeper liquidity and improved trading costs, with specialist knowledge to assess the complex and varied issuance terms of securities, and the ability to sell securities when they become overvalued.

In small caps, we believe that most of the outperformance in the sector can be achieved over market cycles, by identifying and avoiding companies with undesirable investment characteristics. This can be achieved with some sensible screens, delivered in a cost-effective way via an exchange traded product.

2. Where are we in the market cycle?

When a momentum-driven market is generally moving higher, there may be no need to look at active or smart beta strategies. “A rising tide lifts all boats” is the saying, and just having exposure to the right sector may be all that is needed.

However, as a market peaks and corrects, market pull backs and risks may be mitigated by using a strategy that is active or rules-based, which will hopefully have exposure to higher quality securities that will be less affected by the fall.

High volatility or trendless markets present another opportunity for active and smart beta strategies to take advantage of specific securities or sectors. Or alternative strategies that are defensive, or not as correlated to rest of the market, can also shine.

Yield strategies have always been popular with Australian investors. A few years ago, most yield stocks performed well. The market environment is different today. Banks may struggle to grow their earnings and therefore their share prices in the years ahead. There is some prospect that interest rates could rise again, which would impact interest rate sensitive investments, and many market observers feel the top 20 stocks on the ASX will have a more difficult time.

For funds with a specific income objective, active management can add value above a passive strategy by navigating the markets in changed market conditions. Specific strategies aim to deliver an attractive, tax-effective and low volatility income stream that can increase with inflation, targeted at retirees and low-tax paying investors.

3. Is the added cost for active or rules-based strategies worth the money?

Shopping for any product is about value. A top quality shirt may cost more but with longer wear, it might cost less in the long run. The same goes for investing. Will there be enough outperformance in the long term to justify the added cost? Management fees eat into returns and, although an active manager may outperform their benchmark, after considering their fees may underperform.

The cheapest Aussie equities exposure in the world is currently the BetaShares Australia 200 ETF (ASX:A200), with a management fee of 0.07% per annum. However, this is a market cap-weighted index and potential outperformance may come from a smart beta approach such as Fundamental Indexing. It is also available via an ETF and has outperformed the market cap-weighted index over the long term by about 2% per annum*, but with higher fees.

In summary, active, rules-based and passive strategies can be used in conjunction with one another and should be considered as part of a diversified portfolio.

 

*Source: Bloomberg. FTSE RAFI Australia 200 Index v S&P/ASX 200 Index, 1992 to June 2018. Does not take into account ETF fees and expenses. You can’t invest directly in an index. Past performance is not indicative of future returns.

 

Justin Arzadon is a senior member of the Distribution team at BetaShares, a sponsor of Cuffelinks. This material has been prepared as general information only, without reference to your objectives, financial situation or needs. You should seek your own financial advice before making any investment decision.

For more articles and papers from BetaShares, please click here.


 

Leave a Comment:

RELATED ARTICLES

The challenges of building a lazy portfolio

Global ETFs: insights into a multi-trillion-dollar industry

Australian ETFs: end of year reviews 2018

banner

Most viewed in recent weeks

Simple maths says the AI investment boom ends badly

This AI cycle feels less like a revolution and more like a rerun. Just like fibre in 2000, shale in 2014, and cannabis in 2019, the technology or product is real but the capital cycle will be brutal. Investors beware.

Why we should follow Canada and cut migration

An explosion in low-skilled migration to Australia has depressed wages, killed productivity, and cut rental vacancy rates to near decades-lows. It’s time both sides of politics addressed the issue.

Are LICs licked?

LICs are continuing to struggle with large discounts and frustrated investors are wondering whether it’s worth holding onto them. This explains why the next 6-12 months will be make or break for many LICs.

Australian house price speculators: What were you thinking?

Australian housing’s 50-year boom was driven by falling rates and rising borrowing power — not rent or yield. With those drivers exhausted, future returns must reconcile with economic fundamentals. Are we ready?

Retirement income expectations hit new highs

Younger Australians think they’ll need $100k a year in retirement - nearly double what current retirees spend. Expectations are rising fast, but are they realistic or just another case of lifestyle inflation?

Welcome to Firstlinks Edition 627 with weekend update

This week, I got the news that my mother has dementia. It came shortly after my father received the same diagnosis. This is a meditation on getting old and my regrets in not getting my parents’ affairs in order sooner.

  • 4 September 2025

Latest Updates

Shares

Why the ASX may be more expensive than the US market

On every valuation metric, the US appears significantly more expensive than Australia. However, American companies are also much more profitable than ours, which means the ASX may be more overvalued than most think.

Economy

No one holds the government to account on spending

Government spending is out of control and there's little sign that Labor will curb it. We need enforceable rules on spending and an empowered budget office to ensure governments act responsibly with taxpayers money.

Retirement

Why a traditional retirement may be pushed back 25 years

The idea of stopping work during your sixties is a man-made concept from another age. In a world where many jobs are knowledge based and can be done from anywhere, it may no longer make much sense at all.

Shares

The quiet winners of AI competition

The tech giants are in a money-throwing contest to secure AI supremacy and may fall short of high investor expectations. The companies supplying this arms race could offer a more attractive way to play AI adoption.

Preparing for aged care

Whether for yourself or a family member, it’s never too early to start thinking about aged care. This looks at the best ways to plan ahead, as well as the changes coming to aged care from November 1 this year.

Infrastructure

Renewable energy investment: gloom or boom?

ESG investing has fallen out of favour with many investors, and Trump's anti-green policies haven't helped. Yet, renewables investment is still surging, which could prove a boon for infrastructure companies.

Investing

The enduring wisdom of John Bogle in five quotes

From buying the whole market to controlling emotions, John Bogle’s legendary advice reminds investors that patience, discipline, and low costs are the keys to investment success in any market environment.

Sponsors

Alliances

© 2025 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer
The data, research and opinions provided here are for information purposes; are not an offer to buy or sell a security; and are not warranted to be correct, complete or accurate. Morningstar, its affiliates, and third-party content providers are not responsible for any investment decisions, damages or losses resulting from, or related to, the data and analyses or their use. To the extent any content is general advice, it has been prepared for clients of Morningstar Australasia Pty Ltd (ABN: 95 090 665 544, AFSL: 240892), without reference to your financial objectives, situation or needs. For more information refer to our Financial Services Guide. You should consider the advice in light of these matters and if applicable, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement before making any decision to invest. Past performance does not necessarily indicate a financial product’s future performance. To obtain advice tailored to your situation, contact a professional financial adviser. Articles are current as at date of publication.
This website contains information and opinions provided by third parties. Inclusion of this information does not necessarily represent Morningstar’s positions, strategies or opinions and should not be considered an endorsement by Morningstar.